Playing the saxophone Mustang sally d major

From the film? I didn’t know there was a film.

Also, in the original I hear a lot of roots in the verse. Yours has a lot of thirds, major 7ths, very weird stuff. Can you post a recording (YouTube link or something) to the version you want to play?

Regardless, even if I wrote the rhythms out for you, I doubt that would help you understand them. Plus they’d be completely lost by the time you transferred to your letter note name based word doc.
Only meef the note names ill sort it..play to yhe track...
 
Ah, I remember that film now. In the clip I'm hearing a lot of F naturals and C naturals, not what you've written. More like:

D F F F F C D D
C D D A A A A

Hope that helps.
 
Last edited:
Ah, I remember that film now. In the clip I'm hearing a lot of F naturals and C naturals, not what you've written. More like:

D F F F F C D D
C D D A A A A

Hope that helps.
Thanks @lydian..I don't know where ive gone wrong..The originals in c major so ive transposed to D and ended up with c#s and F#s..
 
@eb424 have you considered what’s probably a more conventional approach? Listen to the song, learn how it goes then find those notes on your saxophone that sound like the same melody?

To make it easy you can do it line by line.
 
Great film
Yes, but who is playing the baritone sax? Seems to be the alto player. Now I'm picky.

I think songs like "Mustang Sally" is hard to play alone. You are going to play the melody/singing lines instead of a very good singer. I tried to play "Cry To Me" (Solomon Burke) and I gave up. I'm not King Curtis. I sang it better than I played it on tenor sax.

I don't think we should stop playing song like this. It's great practicing. Play and enjoy it. We played a Sally version that was more in a "wrestler" style. And we were tired of searching for good B-side blues and Rock & Roll songs to make us less mainstream. We also wanted to some action and some recognition on the few times we played in front of a small audience on the small stage wagon down in the hollow. So we started to play "Unchange My Heart", "Burning Love", "You Left the Water Running", "Gimme Some Lovin'", "Real Real Gone". All songs had horns. The horns practice a lot to get a big and tight sound.

I think you should try learn to play MS without sheet music.

Good luck and I'm sorry that I went off topic.
 
Last edited:
@eb424 have you considered what’s probably a more conventional approach? Listen to the song, learn how it goes then find those notes on your saxophone that sound like the same melody?

To make it easy you can do it line by line.
Hi @petethomas..that is my aim eventually..but my current way of doing things is hopefully giving me reading skills that will help me play with others..

There is enough in the song that isn't on the score that i will hopefully have to do some working out by ear on..to finish it of.

At least i have learnt some transposition circle of 5ths, key sigs to know what main notes to use..its only 2 lines im stuck on..usually in most songs the rhythm of the 2nd verse is similar i.e. sweet caroline..but the words in the 2nd verse of sally are way of the first..A good learning curve..
 
but my current way of doing things is hopefully giving me reading skills that will help me play with others..
No it isn't, it's just putting off learning those skills. If you are learning reading skills, then why would you write the notes in as alphabetical characters, that has nothing to do with music reading skills.

Learning to read music means learning the note names on the staves along with the note values and positions (rhythm). people do that and combine it with using their ears and memory.

Just writing in the note names is not at all helping. OK, it's something that might be useful for a day or two while you learn the note names on the staves but otherwise continuing to do it for years, all the time saying it is hopefully giving you reading skills, is actually detrimental to the learning process. Especially when you write in the wrong notes.

But this song is an ideal candidate for just using your ears to learn it on the saxophone.
 
Last edited:
Yes, but who is playing the baritone sax? Seems to be the alto player. Now I'm picky.

I think songs like "Mustang Sally" is hard to play alone. You are going to play the melody/singing lines instead of a very good singer. I tried to play "Cry To Me" (Solomon Burke) and I gave up. I'm not King Curtis. I sang it better than I played it on tenor sax.

I don't think we should stop playing song like this. It's great practicing. Play and enjoy it. We played a Sally version that was more in a "wrestler" style. And we were tired of searching for good B-side blues and Rock & Roll songs to make us less mainstream. We also wanted to some action and some recognition on the few times we played in front of a small audience on the small stage wagon down in the hollow. So we started to play "Unchange My Heart", "Burning Love", "You Left the Water Running", "Gimme Some Lovin'", "Real Real Gone". All songs had horns. The horns practice a lot to get a big and tight sound.

I think you should try learn to play MS without sheet music.

Good luck and I'm sorry that I went off topic.
Lol...i always enjoy your contributions as they're quite supportive..I will probably only play by myself and do it a bit different playing to backing tracks..The one i have has all the music and backing vocals so i can just replace the singer..hopefully it works out..
 
I write the note names as well. I can read (badly) but to write a letter below the note helps me to speed up my learning. Sheet music becomes blurry to me. I need big sheet paper , A3 or A2 paper is even better, and that is not so practical. So a small letter ... helps me. I don't read from charts. I memorize and then I play from memory.
 
No it isn't, it's just putting off learning almost skills. If you are learning reading skills, then why would you write the notes in as alphabetical characters, that has nothing to do with music reading skills.

Learning to read music means learning the note names on the staves along with the note values and positions (rhythm). people do that and combine it with using their ears and memory.

Just writing in the note names is not at all helping. OK, it's something that might be useful for a day or two while you learn the note names on the staves but otherwise continuing to do it for years, all the time saying it is hopefully giving you reading skills, is actually detrimental to the learning process. Especially when you write in the wrong notes.

But this song is an ideal candidate for just using your ears to learn it on the saxophone.
I do agree with what you say @petethomas but there is a but..lol. I have l have learnt note names and values and mark the score so as its easier to transfer to my doc..not ideal i know..

I play some slow stuff from scores but think I would have lost interest in playing had i had to learn to read first. Im an old man if i was 20 again i would probably have gone the right way. Playing for me is the important thing who knows how long there is..enjoy it..

There has to be more than one way to achieve your goals..because i play songs from beginning to end many of them are over 5 pages i found i had to condense them anyway..or use 3 music stands lol..my eyes arent great i need bigger sheets than A4 just to confuse it even more.

I am now trying to learn to read rhythym look at chords and try to learn the right way but unstructured as both time and finances impact more on me as an adult learner.. I started for fun i have to have that but also realise that unless i do learn i will only be able to play alone to backing tracks and my goals have changed regrding this..Eddie
 
do agree with what you say @petethomas

Really? Doesn't seem like it.

think I would have lost interest in playing had i had to learn to read first.
Me too probably. So I learned to play at the same time as learning to read music
I have l have learnt note names and values and mark the score so as its easier to transfer to my doc..not ideal i know..
I don't really know what you mean by that. Yes there are times when you might write note names down. I do that sometimes for notes when there is no score paper to hand. However I don't believe it will ever works as a way to learn reading music as I said, beyond the first few days of sorting out the lines and spaces.

I bought you a brand new mustang

F# F # E c C# C AA

All of those notes are wrong, try something more like this and see how it sounds.

Iboughtyouabrandnewmus-tang
DFFFFDDD
 
Last edited:
Really? Doesn't seem like it.


Me too probably. So I learned to play at the same time as learning to read music

I don't really know what you mean by that. Yes there are times when you might write note names down. I do that sometimes for notes when there is no score paper to hand. However I don't believe it will ever works as a way to learn reading music as I said, beyond the first few days of sorting out the lines and spaces.



All of those notes are wrong, try something more like this and see how it sounds.

Iboughtyouabrandnewmus-tang
DFFFFDDD
Hi thanks ill try those notes tonight. There for d major because the words werent there i struggled with the bar line tho its easier on the song sheet..I'm not being argumentative thobit may sound so but you learnt many years ago and made a career out of music because you were good enough..for me its a hobby that because of my love for it has taken over my life..if i didn't have family and a full time job id devote more time than thec15 or so hours a week into it and do itbthe right way like you..thanks again for the advice I really appreciate your time and patience..
 
if i didn't have family and a full time job id devote more time than thec15 or so hours a week into it
If time is limited it kind of begs the question why waste so much of that time trying to learn in a long winded way then?
 
When I was teaching I always advised students not to write note names in. They did it anyway.

Mind you, if there are more than 4 leger lines I’ll not follow my own advice.
I end up with 3 A4 pages of notes and lyrics..as I play them more i am changing and adding a bit but i play the whole song..even if i could read fast enough which given the time i dedicate to it ( which is nowhere near what i want or need) id have to condense the scores..
 
If time is limited it kind of begs the question why waste so much of that time trying to learn in a long winded way then?
I dont find it to long winded..I write a song out in a night and start practicing Pete..I am never going to be a pro its just for fun and if i can perform in care home for free and give something that is / will have to be enough for me..whilst i learn to read.

I'm gutted that I didn't find the sax earlier in life and follow a structured pathway, it's difficult but i have to balance and work within my own weaknesses.. I genuinely believe that even if i had a lesson a week and had started when i joined the SC i still wouldn't be able to play the songs i enjoy from scores..I can only afford ltd lessons re commitments and am running a 2 horse race. Doing it the way i do gives me the fun of playing whilst learning theory and playing from scores has not been afforded so much time i do, do it and hope the ability to do it will catch up..
 
So you're trying to play the melody?

Second verse sung melody is all roots in the first two lines.

But the exact notes of the melody aren't particularly important in this song anyway. Every singer will do it a bit different, in blues shouter tradition.

Anyway, it's the horn section parts that are interesting. No one wants to hear a sax player honking away on dozens of repeated notes trying to play exactly the notes one particular singer sang on one particular recording on one particular day. They want to hear those hip horn parts and lines. Get those down and then you can embellish as needed (for example, when my band did this we had one guitar, bass, sax, drums - no Hammond, no full sax section, etc. - so I had to fill in on sax. I did a lot of double time stuff to make up for missing rhythm players, and a lot of long sustained notes to make up for no organ. I can't remember exactly what I'd play on this particular song. I think I did it on baritone to get the scoops that are such an important part of the horn parts.)

No need for notation OR half-assed note letter names. This one, you do it by ear. Just like Pickett did. Do you think he had a written part? Nah, if he had the words written down that was a lot. Probably had the first couple words of each line on a bar napkin, just to make sure he didn't forget the words when he got in front of the recording mike.
 
Second verse sung melody is all roots in the first two lines.
Not on the version I heard
But the exact notes of the melody aren't particularly important in this song anyway.
Absolutely 100% correct IMO so my comment above is irrelevant and moot 🙂
No one wants to hear a sax player honking away on dozens of repeated notes trying to play exactly the notes one particular singer sang on one particular recording on one particular day.
Exactly.
This one, you do it by ear.
I’d say ear and memory, which kind of goes without saying but I thought id say it anyway.
Just like Pickett did. Do you think he had a written part? Nah
and another “exactly”
 
Not on the version I heard
I just pulled up "Mustang Sally Wilson Pickett" to see if perchance he was doing operatic arpeggios rather than the simple blues shouter lines I thought I remembered. Nope, simple blues shouter style throughout. Seemed to me like the first two lines of the second verse were all root note.

Interestingly for questions of blues singing style, the first verse I heard a lot of major thirds being sung, not the minor thirds the modern "gotta slather the blues scale all over everything or it won't be blues" types would have us using now. That so-called blues style and blues scale that's being imposed nowadays is like taking your dinner and just pouring ketchup on everything - the baked fish, the broccoli, the squash casserole, the apple pie, your coffee....
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,578
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom