Miscellaneous Music is a Language

A blog about Music as a (second) language:

Music as a (Second) Language
I think he's missed it. The same sounds have different meanings for different people. And although you could argue that some of the music seems to work similarly - take the music in the northern soul/motown thread, there's a lot that doesn't Coltrane's ballads for instance.

There seems to be an underlying assumption that music can convey a message. And if the message is emotional, I'd agree. But without formalisation it can't carry factual information. We do have this formalisation in limited amount - for instance the siren on an ambulance, the tones used to dial phone numbers. But is it still music?
 
A blog about Music as a (second) language:

Music as a (Second) Language
This is really interesting and something I have suspected for a while. I have said for a long time learning music is like learning a new language.
The way most of us learn is very much as he points out "learning" and we end up especially as adult learners with all our time following the rules instead of taking the time to acquire our chosen new language.

Really interesting Trimmy and Mandy thank you. Some teachers though do use the aquired method but as their student you have to let go of your preconceived ideas of learning.

Jx
 
Here are a few keys to follow in learning or teaching music:

  • In the beginning embrace mistakes instead of correcting them. Like a child playing air guitar there are no wrong notes.
  • Allow young musicians to play and perform with accomplished musicians on a daily basis.
  • Encourage young musicians to play more than they practice. The more they play, the more they will practice on their own.
  • Music comes from the musician, not the instrument.
  • And most important: Remember that a language works the best when we have something interesting to say. Many music teachers never find out what their students have to say. We only tell them what they are supposed to say.
  • A child speaks a language for years before they even learn the alphabet. Too many rules at the onset will actually slow them down.
I wouldn't disagree with any of that. But it's hardly new.
 
Is mood different to emotion? It's very apparent that music can convey a mood, but an emotion? Not sure. Certain pieces will bring forth an emotional response but is this in the music or is it just activating and stimulating memories or prompting creativity. Some music brings forth pictures in the mind and it seems to us that a musician plays more expressively when we can see they feel it, but is this emotion or performance?

Music and dance go together and always have it seems. A story can be told without words quite thoroughly and with intricate detail.

Many find a song easier to remember than a poem and didn't the travelling bards of old deliver the news in song form?

Popular music can unite people in memories of the time it was popular and stimulate reminiscence and nostalgia. Certain pieces take us back to a specific time and place.

Music is a language. You can learn it's grammar and vocabulary or just mimic like a parrot but who knows what we're saying? Sad , Happy, Serious, Frivolous, Good time, Formal. The clue is usually in the title.

Play with the best players you know is an old adage and if they all want to play with you, then you must be "the best"
 
I wouldn't disagree with any of that. But it's hardly new.
It is for beginners 😉

It would be great to play and perform everyday with a more experienced musician, (no innuendos) but alas life doesn't allow that, or at least my life.

This makes sense...
  • A child speaks a language for years before they even learn the alphabet. Too many rules at the onset will actually slow them down.
 
There is a lot of food for thought in this thread. As someone who taught students to play wind instruments for 32 years I can tell you that practically no child except Louis Armstrong and those few like him could pick up a wind instrument and be "expressing themselves" in a short time. The gist of these presentations seems to be based upon those musical instruments where the tone production is automatic such as keyboards, fretted string instruments, and melodic percussion. On those types of instruments a person of any age can pick out a series of notes that sound pleasing to them without any formal training. On the other groups of instruments it is more challenging simply because the "tone production" is produced and controlled by the player.

That said, I do strongly agree that written music is indeed a universal language. Players from Africa, South America, Germany, Japan, Italy, etc. can sit in an orchestra and play the music together even though they cannot communicate with their spoken language. What's more they all can "feel" the human emotion of the piece together if it is a great work and they are playing it well.

There has been a grand experiment going on for quite some time now. That is teaching very young children to play stringed instruments by rote imitation---just like language. It is called the Suzuki Method. Although it produces some wonderful players, the downside is that many of those student's form a mental block years later when they are finally taught to read printed music on the page. There needs to be a happy medium with this or any other approach.

[Insert Broken Record] Anyone, anywhere, can play in groups with professional musicians much better than themselves every day if they are using Smart Music. That is perhaps the most valid point made in the presentations.
 
Music is a language in my opinion because just listening to different aspects of music can put one in various moods. I find listening to a piece with a good happy beat puts me in a good frame of mind and vice versa. I actually find certain classical piece can put me in a morose state of mind. Give me something like"in the mood" sets me for the day. Another depressing issue is when ones favourite cd malfunctions....like disk 2 of my EAGLES cd has just done. Lucky for me disk 1 is fine. Long road to Eden....a very long road indeed. Well that's my bit of useless info🙂
 
Many find a song easier to remember than a poem and didn't the travelling bards of old deliver the news in song form?

In good old Greece, poems and music were not so distinct. Hence most metric forms.
I've been lucky to hear improvised poem contests, in Tuscany.
The metric is really strict: ABABABCC, eleven syllables per verse (and C becomes the A of the contestant).
There is a melody supporting all of it. Amazingly, the Divine Comedy sits very well on that melody.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,504
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom