Mouthpiece resistance

generally speaking - more baffle, smaller chamber and smaller opening - less resistance. - easier to play. The secret is in the combination of these three variables. The reed adds to the equation, soft - less resistance.
There has to be some resistance of course otherwise the whole thing won't work.
gruss - spike
 
There's much in what you say Spike, I can see all of your points. However, some people have described their own mpc as being either more or less resistant, so leaving aside the difference a reed of different strength would make, is there some kind of 'mystical' combination that produces a particularly free-blowing or resistant piece, or are people comparing apples with oranges when they note the difference between say a Jody Jazz and a Link....?
 
Hi Bobby,

I'm a complete novice, so treat this accordingly!

I tried a load of tenor HR mpcs back-to-back at sax.co.uk recently. Of them all, the JJ HR and Classic seemed to me to be amongst the most free-blowing, noticeably so. The Link seemed to me to be the most resistant, again noticeably so.

Your Mileage May (and probably will!) Vary

The full description of those I tried can be found towards the end of this thread - http://www.breakfastroom.co.uk/index.cgi?fid=01&topic_id=1189605022

All the best,

Frank
 
The only time I consider 'resistance' is when you test mouthpieces back to back that are similar in design and producing very similar tonal results for the player.

In other words I don't think people generally compare a guardala king and an otto link STM when speaking of resistance and free blowing attributes because they expect the differences.
I may be wrong ?
If however I am right, then resistance for you, may be different for someone else. It comes back to what is typical of the whole mouthpiece can of worms. Your individual technique and the variables in the design that happen to work for you.

IMO its why a mouthpiece will be stuffy for one person but nice and dark for another.

Edited. 6.30pm 09/12/07
 
If I might offer another way of looking at this, it all boils down to airflow and aerodynamics.

If the air can pass smoothly and speedily through the mouthpiece the player will "perceive" less resistance at the reed.

As soon as, for instance the "chamber" is enlarged, to be bigger than the bore of the neck, turbulence will occur (a bottleneck has been created) and the air will back up accordingly and the player will experience that resistance at the reed.

The same will occur with: higher/lower baffle - shorter/longer facing - larger/smaller opening and harder/softer reed.

It's a can of worms in some ways granted but go fly a kite or a glider or fly to mallorca - it's airflow and turbulence and turbulence causes resistance to the airflow, check the vibrations in the plane when the flaps go out on your next landing.

gruss - spike
 
Just to make things even more interesting, it seems that the same thing applies to horns. I find Keilwerths the most free-blowing. Selmers (apart from the series 3 and Ref 36) were on the opposite end of the scale and were more resistant. Bore size perhaps.

Regarding mouthpieces, I can rank the ones I own at the moment:

Alto Mouthpieces in order of restistance (highest first)
Meyer ebonite
Otto Link ebonite 6
Otto Link STM 6*
Lawton 7 (plain)
Morgan Excalibur 8EL
Jody Jazz ESP 7* (super-free blowing)

Tenor Mouthpieces
Otto Link STM 6*
Lawton 7BB
Lawton 8B
Morgan Excalibur 8E

Just my personal experience of the ones I currently own.
 
As Locutus once said, "resistance is futile". But then perhaps he had never played the sax (the Borg are such dull folk). I personally think he was just avoiding the "resistance is useless" cliche.

Cheers

Moz

(off on a tangent as usual)
 
I believe it's best to think of a mouthpiece as a system. The facing, baffle, and chamber design all need to work together to provide the idea mouthpiece. Generally speaking I have found that the facing curve (also referred to by many as the resistance curve) needs to be well executed. This is to say that the curve should not have any bumps in it or dips. Making changes to the facing curve is the easiest way to increase resistance in a piece.
 
Hi: Just my first post but I have been using Berg Larsen since '59 and it has a 100/2 lay. I am getting tired of it as it seems far to resistant (maybe it's or my age!!!) anyway have just ordered an RPC 125 from Ron Coelho in Oregon. So I will post my thoughts on it if anyone wants.
 
What about 'modified' mouthpieces? - I had a couple of Freddy Gregorys. One was a Brilhart and it was VERY lively- very responsive. He had opened it right up to an 8star from a 5.
 
Will comparing RPCs have any validity?
Ron makes them for your 'sound', so they are all individual.

Griff, You can have a bash on mine, when you give mine it's yearly. Will disinfect first as we don't want you getting as decrepit as me. >:)
 
Absolutely right "old git" He did mention my Berg was quite a narrow opening and asked what kind of music I was playing and what sound did I want ie. 50's etc. My answer was the Berg had stuck me in the 50's (could be a song!!!!) and I felt like flying differently..... but since he hasn't heard my sound then really he can't make it that personal to me , right? but being as they are not machine made, they certainly are all different.

Well "Bobby G" you do look in your picture a young wippersnapper so I guess I was playing with the Stratatones (funny name eh?) at battle of the bands run by Red Robinson when you were 3. Time flies when you play a horn.... but please don't speed up... :whistle:
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,511
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom