Mouthpieces Mouthpiece matching - tuning

I just want ot say ...

...... I could put an old (stubby, "big chamber" ...) mouthpiece on my old saxes and start searching for the perfect pitch ......

or

...... pack my old saxes and modern mouthpiece and go to a Rock & Blues Jam and have a good time ......

I like RockSax and so the Rock & Blues Jam was my first choice. Nobody cared if I missed tones or was 10-15 % out of tune in the upper register. Today I'm not playing anymore so who cares .... ?
 
We hear of people adding neck extensions so that they can use modern (smaller chamber) mouthpieces on older instruments however I don't think this is ideal. It certainly increases the internal volume (of neck and mouthpiece) thus making up for some of the truncated cone, but I've also heard that the extra length would throw out the intonation - especially at the top - due to the length of tube not being optimal for the tone hole positioning.
Not to disagree, as it makes perfect sense, but Ed Pillinger has added shank extensions to one alto and two baritone PPT mouthpieces for me to match vintage horns and it has worked great. Baritone is probably rather forgiving in this sense. I have noted that others, including the one and only Fabrizio D'Alisera on this site, also play mouthpieces with extended shanks. Taken to extremes, it likely will affect intonation, but it doesn't appear necessary to achieve the intended effects.
 
Not to disagree, as it makes perfect sense, but Ed Pillinger has added shank extensions to one alto and two baritone PPT mouthpieces for me to match vintage horns and it has worked great.
I know but I'd say (a) there is no exact science, different instruments have different quirks and also just because a shank is actually longer may not mean that you add the exact same extra length compared with a different mouthpiece.

The mouthpieces do not all have the same length, I just today lost my baritone mouthpiece so pulled one out of a box and noticed the shank was probably a good 5mm longer. I just push it on a bit more.
 
Last edited:
I know but I'd say (a) there is no exact science, different instruments have different quirks and also just because a shank is actually longer amy not mean that you add the exact same extra length comapred with a different mouthpiece.

The mouthpieces do not all have the same length, I just today lost my baritone mouthpiece so pulled one out of a box and noticed the shank was probably a good 5mm longer. I just push it on a bit more.
I agree or at least I don't know of an exact science either. It just...works.

Bet you have a tree in you back yard with PPT mouthpieces. 😀
 
Last edited:
The biggest issue with playing a modern MPC on certain vintage horns is that you can't pull them out far enough to get them in tune without the MPC just hanging on the edge and becoming wobbly. 10M, TrueTone, older King horns all have this issue. On my 1924 TT, I did a re-cork of the neck using the Valentino synthetic (3M) cork and it became unplayable because that "cork" is too soft and the MPC was never axial with he neck. So I had to destroy a perfectly fine brand new cork and go back to the natural version (much harder) but all the issues went away.

That "length" issue is why Morgan offer some of their pieces with "extended shank" and in all "vintage horn cases" I have found the mechanical stability or rather the lack thereof is at least one of the main contributing factors for a "mismatch". If you put on a fresh neck cork so that you don't have to "play flat", the problem will most likely become much less or go away.
 
That "length" issue is why Morgan offer some of their pieces with "extended shank" and in all "vintage horn cases" I have found the mechanical stability or rather the lack thereof is at least one of the main contributing factors for a "mismatch". If you put on a fresh neck cork so that you don't have to "play flat", the problem will most likely become much less or go away.

Yes I know of some people who have had extensions because the mouthpiece needs to be on only about 5mm of cork/neck and that is never going to hold up.

SWe generally now make a slightly longer shank than the Slant Sig the baritone was sort of based off, so it should ideally accomdate both vintage with those issues and non-vintage.

I did develop the PPT with both a 12M and a Martin Handcraft. Never had isses myself, nor did IO on my previous RPC baritones. But I am aware for some people and/or their instruments it can be.
 
Morgan mouthpieces offer their Mulligan mouthpiece with a shank extension for vintage bars. I know that Ron Coelho also offered to extend shanks on mouthpieces. Apparently, SYOS make their mouthpieces with shank lengths relative to chamber and facing.

I believe that anatomy may factor into this as well. In spite of my big mouth, my oral cavity is relatively small. I had some enjoyous encounters with my then dentist (and her associate) in my teens to have four teeth removed, because there was not enough room. Perhaps, for people who have a big mouth in the literal sense, there is more flexibility to move the mouthpiece further out on the cork without having it wobble on the end.
 
Morgan mouthpieces offer their Mulligan mouthpiece with a shank extension for vintage bars. I know that Ron Coelho also offered to extend shanks on mouthpieces. Apparently, SYOS make their mouthpieces with shank lengths relative to chamber and facing.

I believe that anatomy may factor into this as well. In spite of my big mouth, my oral cavity is relatively small. I had some enjoyous encounters with my then dentist (and her associate) in my teens to have four teeth removed, because there was not enough room. Perhaps, for people who have a big mouth in the literal sense, there is more flexibility to move the mouthpiece further out on the cork without having it wobble on the end.
Yes, I discussed this topic many times with Ron. There are many other factors as well, anatomy, facing curve etc.

But the wobble or shift from axial alignment is simply an issue of how much length of the cork you can get into the bore and how compressible the cork is. And that's exactly the reason why I have moved away completely from the Valentino neck corks except for some altos where I have to push the MPC on almost an inch.
 
Yes I know of some people who have had extensions because the mouthpiece needs to be on only about 5mm of cork/neck and that is never going to hold up.

SWe generally now make a slightly longer shank than the Slant Sig the baritone was sort of based off, so it should ideally accomdate both vintage with those issues and non-vintage.

I did develop the PPT with both a 12M and a Martin Handcraft. Never had isses myself, nor did IO on my previous RPC baritones. But I am aware for some people and/or their instruments it can be.

A longer shank doesn't hurt, as long as you adjust the depth of the bore accordingly. Even on a modern horn, you can always adjust the back portion of the cork without compromising the front.
 
The words "modern" and "old fashioned" are highly misleading in this discussion. It makes a lot more sense to discuss chamber size and baffle type.

I have played Conns for over 40 years. So I do know a little about how they work.

My most immediately relevant experience came when I investigated mouthpieces for my Conn 12M baritone, a notoriously "mouthpiece picky" horn. I started out playing this horn with a small round chamber Vandoren piece. To get the horn generally in tune, I had to pull out so far that I ended by extending the MP by 1.5", to give it mechanical stability. Many people recommend stopping here, as if that's all that's needed.

But there were some wonky notes; altissimo was pretty much impossible; and there was an ongoing tendency to squeaking in the palm key notes.

When I went to a Meyer (with a small wedge), the distance from tip of mouthpiece to octave vent decreased by about an inch(!) which immediately brought the scale into compliance - the wonky notes disappeared, altissimo popped out nicely; no more squeaks. Tonally, the Meyer and the Vandoren are very similar, but one of them gets there with a small round chamber and the other one gets there with a medium round chamber (same diameter as the bore) and a small wedge baffle.

And if you do the other, increase sounding length to attempt to get a too-small chamber to kind of sort of tune; short tube notes get flat, long tube notes get sharp. Then instead of looking for an MP that works properly with the horn, people start soldering pieces of pipe onto the neck, even putting crescents into bell tone holes. (I had a horn that had those modifications; when I reversed them and played it with a MP of the right type, it played perfectly in tune.)

So I continued the experiment. I took a second Meyer mouthpiece, same wedge, and hogged out the chamber below the window and above the cork bore. I guess I increased its ID by 1/8" or more. And remarkably enough, it behaved just like the theory says it should. Tonal quality was essentially unchanged, but I had to push on another 3/4" or so; all the short tube notes (palm keys down to, say, C) got sharp and the bell key notes got relatively flatter. In other words, exactly what you would expect to happen if you take 3/4" out of the sounding length, you give it a stretched scale as defined by tone hole positions.

Now I don't know if you want to call a Meyer with a wedge a "modern" mouthpiece, or a Vandoren small round chamber that sounds pretty much exactly the same. The whole "modern mouthpieces don't work on vintage horns" trope is largely created, I believe, to confuse "modern" with "better" and to sell more new horns. "Oh, you don't want that old Conn; you can't play a modern [i.e., good] mouthpiece on it; why, it's really only good for playing ragtime and Sousa marches, not the hip modern stuff you really want to play..."

But, whatever the case on that, I can tell you positively that there are such things as high baffle large chamber mouthpieces that will play on old horns, well in tune, and with a bright "modern" sound. Ever heard of a company called Dukoff? I can tell you from personal experience that a Dukoff D7 will play perfectly in tune on a Conn 10M, without having to pull way way out. And it certainly is BRIGHT and POWERFUL. Ever hear of a guy named Michael Brecker? He made his name playing on a Dukoff D chamber piece. Brilhart Level Air is another high baffle large chamber piece. Jody Jazz makes several as well. You don't have to play on a dill pickle size mouthpiece that feels like blowing into an old gym sock, just because you have an older instrument. That's a total misconception.

And don't try to hide a wrong scale length for sounding length, by saying "everything's a compromise, you have to play the horn in tune". If taken to extremes that leads you to trying to play high pitch horns. Nope. There is a scale length that depends on the complete bore design, and leads you to a mouthpiece position. The further the total sounding length deviates from that for which the scale was designed, the harder it is to play the horn in tune. The egregious example of this is all the Louis Lot flutes (and copies thereof) built at A = 435, then the head joints cut 3/8" to (sort of) play at A = 440, giving an excessive scale length, sharp high notes, flat low notes, and generating two generations of flute pedagogy where "they all do that" was the excuse and entire schools of playing were built around playing flutes at the wrong pitch.
 
Last edited:
I am just an amateur player, but I played on Martin saxes for a long time, mostly on my Committee III tenor. On that sax, I have played a Phil-Tone Eclipse for the past few years. Before that, I mostly played an OL Tone-Edge. Both of these had excellent intonation on my Martin, but I like the Phil-Tone better for other reasons.

Anyway, looking at my Martin alto and tenor, those are easily just as good in tune as any modern sax that I tried. Especially my tenor is excellent, in that regard.
However, I also played a Martin baritone, and that was a challenge (for me) to play in tune, even with vintage mouthpieces. That’s why I eventually sold it for a more modern bari.

Admittedly, I don’t play my Martin alto and tenor with a high baffle and/or small chamber mouthpiece, because I mostly look for the 50s and earlier bigband sound. But in my experience, those Martins (except for the bari) are just as easy to play as more modern saxes.
 
My knowledge on this is mostly hearsay with a bit of trial end error, but we often hear about "mouthpiece mismatches", especially when using modern mouthpieces on vintage instruments (Not the other way round - why?)

Someone correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe a big issue is that the saxophone always has to be a compromise acoustically. As it's conical, the perfect saxophone (acoustically speaking) should theoretically taper to a point. However it can't because there has to be a mouthpiece bunged on the neck. So therefore it is a truncated cone, and theoreticaly the mouthpiece volume should make up for the volume of the cone that has been cut off.

Back in the old days, mouthpieces tended to have a huge bore and the saxophone body/neck was designed accordingly. But these days saxophones are designed to use smaller bore mouthpieces for brighter sound or maybe more projection (even leaving aside the concept of a high baffle reducing the internal volume).

I've seen very little written about when this change was supposed to have occurred, whether it was gradual or what.

We hear of people adding neck extensions so that they can use modern (smaller chamber) mouthpieces on older instruments however I don't think this is ideal. It certainly increases the internal volume (of neck and mouthpiece) thus making up for some of the truncated cone, but I've also heard that the extra length would throw out the intonation - especially at the top - due to the length of tube not being optimal for the tone hole positioning.

That actually sounds like common sense and, to my non-scientific mind, is probably true.

So what is the ideal if you want to play a vintage instrument, but the old mouthpieces that are supposed to have the best intonation don't help you get a more modern tone? I remember especially, battling with an old Buescher alto, and the only way to get it tuning nicely was the original mouthpiece but I couldn't stop it sounding too mellow for most purposes or (at worst) a bit "tubby."
Benade writes that two conditions must be met for a saxophone to behave as if it had a completed cone at its end rather than a truncated one:
  • That the "effective volume" of the mouthpiece be a close match to the "calculated" volume of the missing cone.
  • That the played frequency (frs) of the mouthpiece + neck must be a close match to the natural resonant frequency of a cone the same length using the formula: frequency = speed of sound / 2x the length
The "effective volume" of a mouthpiece is greater than its measured geometric volume due to the effects of the reed travel and to a small degree the player's oral cavity. This would indicate that not only the chamber size, but the tip opening, lay, and reed strength also contribute to the "effective volume" as does how much mouthpiece is in the mouth and the tightness of the player's embouchure. Measurements by Benade and Gebler of a soprano mouthpiece being played showed the "effective volume" to be approximately 24% greater than the physical volume past the end of the neck.

In my playing and teaching, I have found that a played frequency of Ab concert on the mouthpiece and neck for the alto saxophone, and of E concert for the tenor saxophone to be useful guide posts. This is reinforced by the fact that a classical alto saxophonist playing A concert on the mouthpiece alone will tune with the mouthpiece in one location and a jazz player playing a step and 1/2 lower on the mouthpiece alone will push the mouthpiece on farther to tune and in both instances the note produced by the mouthpiece + neck will remain the same.
Really interesting, I have a Tenor, Dolnet Bel Air, no idea what the mouthpiece is that came with it 30 years ago but stamped .2, large chamber, short rolled shank, small opening, I can't get any other mouthpiece to play in tune with it, so frustrating as I would ideally like a spare but also use a mouthpiece with a larger opening, an SML 5 is close but not quite there and the sax really doesn't like it, you can forget any modern mouthpieces as they either squeak or sound so out of tune that all the local wildlife exits the area, any suggestions from anyone would be greatly appreciated
 
I most of the tuning issues is caused by the player. It doesn't matter if it's a sax from the 20's, 30's ..... or 80's 90's . It wasn't the saxes or the mouthpieces, it was me that was the weak link.

There were some long running sax models that didn't changed so much over the years. The were basically the same sax construction from the start to the end. Conn Artist 10M (mid 30's to 58 or 59 or to 74), King Super 20 (1945-1979), The Martin Tenor (1945- 1971). So an early The Martin Tenor needs a differnt mouthpiece? Or was it the music that changed?

Lots of wise guys says a vintage mouthpiece (big round chamber) is best mpc on a Martin Committee. I don't think so. I've played big round chambered mouthpieces on Martin Committees and they didn't fit me.

The guy who talked me in to Rovner (long, dual chamber, big window, heavy, tapered chamber .....) was a Swedish sax player called Bo Gustafsson. He is on a Conn Artist 10M with a Rovner mouthpiece. I he sounds good. He alsways seems to have a good time when he is playing and the audience are also having a good time! Maybe a vintage mouthpiece on his vintage sax would be better? A link with Bosse Gustafsson playing his 10M with a Rovner mpc.
View: https://youtu.be/H77omH2GETs
🙂 Just put a tuner on the video..Interesting result. 🙂..Thomsax is correct in my experience. A lot is down to the player..Now regarding modern mouthpieces on Vintage horns. A while ago I had the oportunity to try a range of Theo Wanne mouthpieces on my 1936 10m. Opened the sound and kept the mellow tone. Tried them on early Selmers both Tenor and Alto with the same result. it was a "Mantra" (no longer available I believe). However I quite fancy a 10m Fan Robusto!! Just been PMing Eddie!! Regards..🙂
 
Hey Andre could you be more specific? What do you mean out of tune?
Hey, when I use the original mouthpiece of unknown origin and I use a tuner on my phone to see if I'm hitting it correctly, it works, other mouthpieces with different reeds and ligatures are either too sharp or too flat even when adjusting where the mouthpiece sits on the cork. I read on here a while ago that vintage Saxophones can be problematic with tuning when using a different mouthpiece and particularly if it's a modern one. Any ideas?
 
you can forget any modern mouthpieces as they either squeak or sound so out of tune that all the local wildlife exits the area, any suggestions from anyone would be greatly appreciated
You can't have tried all modern mouthpieces surely? have you tried any sp[ecifically designed to work well with vintage instruments?
 
Hey, when I use the original mouthpiece of unknown origin and I use a tuner on my phone to see if I'm hitting it correctly, it works, other mouthpieces with different reeds and ligatures are either too sharp or too flat even when adjusting where the mouthpiece sits on the cork. I read on here a while ago that vintage Saxophones can be problematic with tuning when using a different mouthpiece and particularly if it's a modern one. Any ideas?
I see where your problem is. You are adjusting the MPC to a specific position on the cork instead of adjusting them to where they play in tune. Different MPCs have different shank lengths or bore depth and the chamber size also comes into play. that is, counterintuitively, a larger chamber will emulate a shorter cone "truncation" whereas a smaller chamber will result in an extended acoustic cone. There are no two MPCs that you can just take, use a marker on the cork for the first and then align the second one with the same marker and expect it to play in tune.

The myth of vintage saxes not playing in tune with modern MPCs is just that, a myth. Yes, there are a few vintage horns like the Conn 10M that require a long shank MPC in order to get them in tune, a short shank MPC will just not have enough hold on the neck, similar is true for some of the Buescher TTs but in either case, this shortfall may be at least ameliorated with a new neck cork that provides enough mechanical stability.

And, as always, there are a few exceptions to the rule but that's just the nature of the beast.
 
Adjust any mouthpiece so that overblown bell notes match natural fingerings. Sorted. Then it's up to the player.
That should definitely be the first step. However having done that the intonation should be correct but may still have an incorrect pitch tendency , e.g. all notes sharp or all notes flat. This may or may not be fixable by the player.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,505
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom