Mouthpieces Mouthpiece GAS -Alto

The 4c can easily give a great Desmond and Grover Washington sound, but yes it is quite close - do you need more volume?

According to the internet, a 7C would be more or less the equal to Desmond's Gregory 4A-18M mouthpiece @ .079" vs .081.

Does anyone know better - this seems awfully open for Desmond, not sure I believe it.
Morgan make the Dry Martini which is supposed to based on the Gregory with the following tip openings
18-4 = .063, 18-5=.070 and 18-6=.075 but I don't know if they are accurate to the Gregory sizes.
 
Last edited:
Morgan make the Dry Martini which is supposed to based on the Gregory with the following tip openings
18-4 = .063, 18-5=.070 and 18-6=.075 but I don't know if they accurate to the Gregory sizes.
That seems far more accurate to me - the .063 for Desmond. That would seemingly have it alongside a Seller S80 C, not the slightly bigger C*.
 
I'm getting all I want, at present, on alto, from a Selmer Soloist with a D opening.

I've always liked a close tipped mouthpiece and chased that Desmond sound, but lately with the stuff I'm playing, and moving to Yamaha horns, I was looking for a little, certain something and settled on the Soloist.
Easy blow and surprisingly flexible when pushed.
Worth a try.

It might be worth having any new mouthpiece checked and dressed to remove any minor imperfections.

A wide selection of reeds is advised when looking for a change of mouthpiece. A change of brand and cut can make something dull, sing.
 
The 4c can easily give a great Desmond and Grover Washington sound, but yes it is quite close - do you need more volume?

According to the internet, a 7C would be more or less the equal to Desmond's Gregory 4A-18M mouthpiece @ .079" vs .081.

Does anyone know better - this seems awfully open for Desmond, not sure I believe it.
OPPS!
Looks like I'm late to the party (which is what sometimes happens when I reply to seeing a notification instead of browsing the the thread.
But I'll leave what I typed below anyway.

The Morgan Dry Martini 4-18 which is their take on the MC Gregory Model A has 0.063" referenced as the size. But thats all I have except to say the Dry Martini 5-18 is referenced as 0.070" and so on.
My Model A is a 5A-16 and measures 0.069 IIRC.
 
I'm not adverse to the Yamaha I went from a 4C to a 7C on tenor and felt it was only a slight difference but it's the piece I'm happy playing for now.

On alto it seems to be missing something. I just don't feel the same way as I did regarding my previous sax / mouthpiece combination. The Theo Wanne Water ART is a relatively cheap plastic piece that really transformed my playing, but it just doesn't work with the new sax the same as it did with the old one. Perhaps it's me (it usually is) and I've moved on or changed. I'd be prepared to listen to an expert if they were to watch me playing and they determined that a Yamaha was best mouthpiece for me at my level etc.

I could even come to the same conclusion myself after trying a few. For me it's not about the money or the brand.
I wouldn't reccomend switching to another Yamaha piece, especially if you really want a metal piece. Another really good and well priced metal piece is the Yanagisawa. Yanagisawa Metal - Alto Saxophone Mouthpiece

I've been through that process over 45 years but luckily realised early on that tip opening was the key. I'll quite happily listen to your sound if you can get a sound bite to me or us. You need to play low and mid tones in relatively calm passages, maybe just running over minor pentatonics, but it won't provbide the information necessary to transfer onto other mouthpieces. Only you can do the trial and error process. Maybe play Take Five! How long have you been playing? Do you do Soundcloud? Be good to see your emouchure as well but mobile phone sound bites can be dreadeful!

Oh, and your sound on tenor is never going to be the same on alto ... and YOUR sound will be unique. People often allude to 'vintage' sound and it is completely undefined and arbtrary ... what is different is the way they phrased in days gone by. The classic 40s sound for example is down to legato playing. Try playing 'In The Mood'.
 
Last edited:
My preference for alto is a vintage short-shank Selmer Soloist. I wouldn’t call it “dark”, more “smooth”.
I can now confirm this is true. I have one. This is used solely on an Alto G1 neck from a YAS-62 II.

as I said before, I haven't played on the OP's brand of horn.

Tenor is totally different again.
 
Is @Pete Thomas passing comment on this thread? 😂
Screenshot_20240327-151350.webp
 
There is the option of contacting Ed Pillinger

My experience of buying an alto mouthpiece from him was:
1. A discussion about which of his mouthpiece styles might suit the sort of sound I was after
2. A discussion about the optimum tip opening
4. He sent out two different styles with the option to send one/both back, try an alternative tip opening or style (total flexibility in other words)

I ended up liking and keeping both he sent. The louder brassier one is my current go-to for playing in a band

His mouthpieces are not eye-wateringly expensive and you have the added pleasure of playing a hand made mouthpiece that will play as intended

(I don't have any affiliation or conflict of interest)
 
This has been on Ebay for a while, it's one of the older versions which has a different baffle to the newer ones.
These older ones are great but a bit brighter than the newer versions, I have one of these but it's in excellent condition but if you are after dark the new versions would be better for you.
Are you talking about the Meyer/G Gregory 'G' Rubber Alto Saxophone Mouthpiece - Howarth of London. If you can't sound like Paul Desmond on this Greenstripe, then maybe you won't get to that destination with the gear ... ... you also have the new old style Brilharts Brilhart Ebolin Carlsbad Alto Saxophone Mouthpiece. Theo Wanne explains the relationship between Meyer, Gregory and Brilhart in his history section.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't reccomend switching to another Yamaha piece, especially if you really want a metal piece. Another really good and well priced metal piece is the Yanagisawa. Yanagisawa Metal - Alto Saxophone Mouthpiece
I agree. For the last 15 years or so I've played a metal Yanagisawa on alto and although I've tried a couple of other pieces just out of curiosity, I've never felt the urge to change from the Yanagisawa. Mine is a 7, and I find it to be incredibly flexible in tone and very controllable.
 
Are you talking about the Meyer/G Gregory 'G' Rubber Alto Saxophone Mouthpiece - Howarth of London. If you can't sound like Paul Desmond on this Greenstripe, then maybe you won't get to that destination with the gear ... ... you also have the new old style Brilharts Brilhart Ebolin Carlsbad Alto Saxophone Mouthpiece. Theo Wanne explains the relationship between Meyer, Gregory and Brilhart in his history section.
No, I was commenting on the Brancher mouthpiece that was pictured in post 12
 
There is a Brancher J21 on eBay going for £90 or Best Offer but it's really grotty and I'm not sure I could bring myself to even offer half of that. Apologies if the seller is on here what are people's thoughts?

There is a Brancher J21 on eBay going for £90 or Best Offer but it's really grotty and I'm not sure I could bring myself to even offer half of that. Apologies if the seller is on here what are people's thoughts?

I wouldn't. Seller says "Needs a bit of a clean but plays great." Looks more like the plating has given up and verdigri set in on the underlying metal. If it just needed a clean surely the seller would have done it?
 
No one's said anything bad about Brancher -Woodwind and Reed have a J21, I've ordered it and if I don't like it I can return it but pay a £15 Demo charge.

I'm chasing down some of the others.

Windblowers have a used Jody Jazz DV NY and New Yanagisawa metal- I've booked in to try these in store Saturday.

Gear4music have some of the Theo Wanne but I fear the tip openings they have in stock might be too big for me, Sax.co.uk do have so enquiring about thier returns policy.They also stock 10mfan.

Curly Woodwind have the Aizen GR which is supposed to be very close the MC Gregory -still not sure about this
 
Not tried the wood one's but the metal alto J series are good, although I'm favouring my Runyoun Quantum delrin 10 on alto at the moment.

I agree. For the last 15 years or so I've played a metal Yanagisawa on alto and although I've tried a couple of other pieces just out of curiosity, I've never felt the urge to change from the Yanagisawa. Mine is a 7, and I find it to be incredibly flexible in tone and very controllable.
Like you, I never felt the need to switch from my metal Brilharts until they were no longer available and now I'm the same with my Lawton Bronze's on SAT, but I do like the Yani metals. I play a Dukoff Silverite D9 on bari.
1711583572164.webp
 
I've been to Windblowers in Nottingham today and tried the following:

Yanagisawa metal 5
Jody Jazz DV NY 6

I couldn't get on with the Yanagisawa at all - it did have some damage to the rails towards the table on the start of the facing curve, but I suspect even it had been 100% I wouldn't have got on with it as it seemed quite bright.

I was expecting the Jody Jazz to be too big for me in a 6 (it's used and they're not a Jody Jazz stockist) but I think I'll soon be able to adjust to it, it seems a really easy going piece: I've got it on a week's home trial.

The Brancher J21 turned up in the post while I was in Nottingham. It seems a too open for me right now and too bright so will be hard work and won't do my embouchure any favours, but I will give it a few more goes.

What I am struggling with is my neck cork is going to need sanding down. The Yamaha clearly has a bigger internal diameter than these metal pieces.

I've ordered myself one of the Valentino synthetic cork kits should it all go pear shaped

I'm In negotiation with Sax.co.uk about whether or not they'll let me try the Theo Wanne Lakshmi. I'm simply not prepared to spend that amount of money on something that might not be right for me without the option to return, even if I have to pay small restocking fee. Travelling down to central London isn't really an option for me currently. The only other stockist that have it is Thomann in Germany.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,509
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom