Mouthpieces Mouthpiece for a Bass Saxophone?

Well...
I spoke to Thomann customer service and they said that the supplied mouthpieces have not been changed or upgraded, it's just that they are inconsistent, and that some are good an others are not.

Which of course makes me wonder how much would need doing to my bad one to make it as good as yours Lydian?
That’s too bad. But don’t fret. While my Thomann piece is pretty good, it’s not great. So I’m still searching for a better mpc as well. I have a Selmer bass piece, and while is was fantastic on another bass, it’s not so great on the Thomann. Much too bright and thin for my taste. I’m trying several different pieces as we speak. I’ll let you know what I settle on.

I’d love to try a Pillinger, but it’s probably pretty expensive and not on the website. @Pete Thomas , how would one get a price and place an order? Do you use yours on an American long wrap?
 
I bought the Pillinger NY model bass saxophone mouthpiece back in 2007. Ed Pillinger said that "the bass mouthpiece is NY style, i.e. large barrel chamber and throat and needs a bass sax reed. The bass sax requires a French bass clarinet size lig". At that time Pillinger bass saxophone mouthpieces cost the same as his baritone pieces, so £145 in Synthetic Hard Rubber or £160 in Bronzite.

At that time I play tested the Pillinger NY bass mouthpiece against several others which were a Zinner bass piece (with
added baffle), the Pillinger R model bari, a large chambered Buffet bari piece and a metal Lawton bari piece.

My conclusions (as an inexperienced bass player) at the time were as follows:
  • The bass mouthpieces seem to match the horn better, with good intonation and an even sound. The Zinner is quite a bit rougher/edgier (because of the baffle) and maybe a bit louder. The Pillinger can't fit onto the crook cork far enough to tune exactly right, but it seems to hold the tuning well. Both feel good in the mouth.
  • The three bari pieces generally sounded a bit more "baritone like" with a Fibracell bari reed - a lighter sound, but the tuning was generally about 20 cents sharp in the second octave, especially above G2. Using the Legere bass sax reed (actually a contrabass clarinet reed) added a good deal of weight and body to the sound and also a bit of edge that was nice. The different reed didn't seem to affect the tuning.
  • All the pieces played pretty well, but the two Pillingers seemed to have particularly good facings for easy blowing.
Ed told me "Jan Garbarek says that he finds the bass sax model perfect for big band or large ensemble work where the dark heavy tone is just what's required at the bottom of the harmony, in his opinion."

Rhys
 
I’d love to try a Pillinger, but it’s probably pretty expensive and not on the website. @Pete Thomas , how would one get a price and place an order?
I'd use the contact form on his website. Mention me of course.
Do you use yours on an American long wrap?
Yes, on a Buescher.
"the bass mouthpiece is NY style, i.e. large barrel chamber and throat and needs a bass sax reed. The bass sax requires a French bass clarinet size lig"
I don't think mine is NY, I'll need to ask Ed. He said works fine with bass or baritone reed which it does
 
I watched a Youtube video on these basses by a chap called Jared de Leon, and he makes a bass m/p which he plays on the video. Has anyone heard of or encountered these? He sells 'em at $160 dollars, which is about £140 - a LOT cheaper than a Selmer or Vandoren - although the Customs and Excise will no doubt firk more money out of a British purchaser in taxes. Adrian Rollini used a baritone m/p but I believe he had alterations made to the crook to improve the intonation. Unfortunately, I've mislaid the article in which he details what he did. Link to the de Leon m/p: Bass saxophone mouthpiece — JDWoodwinds | Custom clarinet accessories
 
Adrian Rollini used a baritone m/p but I believe he had alterations made to the crook to improve the intonation.
My bass was previously owned by Harry Gold who got it from Adrian Rollini when he was working in England. The mouthpiece with it is a Toots Mondello Swing Club New York baritone mouthpiece. Could be...
 
I watched a Youtube video on these basses by a chap called Jared de Leon, and he makes a bass m/p which he plays on the video. Has anyone heard of or encountered these? He sells 'em at $160 dollars, which is about £140 - a LOT cheaper than a Selmer or Vandoren - although the Customs and Excise will no doubt firk more money out of a British purchaser in taxes. Adrian Rollini used a baritone m/p but I believe he had alterations made to the crook to improve the intonation. Unfortunately, I've mislaid the article in which he details what he did. Link to the de Leon m/p: Bass saxophone mouthpiece — JDWoodwinds | Custom clarinet accessories
I bought one of these and returned it. It was even worse than the stock mouthpiece.
 
My bass was previously owned by Harry Gold who got it from Adrian Rollini when he was working in England. The mouthpiece with it is a Toots Mondello Swing Club New York baritone mouthpiece. Could be...
Rollini wrote a series of articles around 1929 for the Melody Maker, I think, on bass sax playing in which he talks about this. That m'p will date from a bit later , I think - Toots Mondello didn't become a big enough name to get it on a mouthpiece until the late '30s, after playing with Benny Goodman.
 
I watched a Youtube video on these basses by a chap called Jared de Leon, and he makes a bass m/p which he plays on the video. Has anyone heard of or encountered these? He sells 'em at $160 dollars, which is about £140 - a LOT cheaper than a Selmer or Vandoren - although the Customs and Excise will no doubt firk more money out of a British purchaser in taxes. Adrian Rollini used a baritone m/p but I believe he had alterations made to the crook to improve the intonation. Unfortunately, I've mislaid the article in which he details what he did. Link to the de Leon m/p: Bass saxophone mouthpiece — JDWoodwinds | Custom clarinet accessories
For me, it was essentially unplayable. It's far more open than a typical bass mouthpiece, requiring a huge amount of air. But he told me that he could do a custom tip that's smaller. So that might be worth a try. Selmer is still by far the best bass mouthpiece I've tried.
 
I think - Toots Mondello didn't become a big enough name to get it on a mouthpiece until the late '30s, after playing with Benny Goodman.
Yes well I was just wildly speculating and have no provenance anyway beyond Harry Gold telling me on the phone
 
Last edited:
My bass was previously owned by Harry Gold who got it from Adrian Rollini when he was working in England. The mouthpiece with it is a Toots Mondello Swing Club New York baritone mouthpiece. Could be...

Has the mouthpiece got that distinctive looking bevelled shank?

Harry Gold is featured in this great 1980's BBC documentary all about the bass saxophone! There is very fun scene around 9 minute mark where all the London bass players (including Harry Gold - the guest of honour) congregate in a London pub. Well worth watching - why don't they make TV like this anymore?!

View: https://youtu.be/CKdxiqkhq4I
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4105.webp
    IMG_4105.webp
    13.3 KB · : 154
You can see the double scroll shank very clearly at 15:29. Rollini lived in London from '27 to '30, presumably the time frame Harry bought the horn. What a treat it must be to own one of Rollini's and Harry's horns.
 
Update on bass mouthpieces.

I tried a Pillinger 6* bass mouthpiece. It's quite a bit more open than my Selmer. So to get the same response, I had to go down a bit in reed strength. At that point the sound is darker (duller) but not necessarily fuller as I had hoped. I think the facing is actually quite a bit too short to get the best bass sound. Plus the more open facing takes quite a bit more air. So I still rank Selmer significantly better in terms of tone and ease of playing, at least on my short wrap horn. But the Pillinger does have a nice, dark tone and excellent intonation, just too dark for my taste. It would probably make an ideal classical mouthpiece.

I've also been experimenting with the Thomann mouthpiece a little more. For best results it needs 0.5-1.0 higher strength reeds than my Selmer. With harder reeds, tone and response is nearly identical to my Selmer C*. I haven't measured the facing, but it must be more closed than the Selmer.
 
Well...
I spoke to Thomann customer service and they said that the supplied mouthpieces have not been changed or upgraded, it's just that they are inconsistent, and that some are good an others are not.

Which of course makes me wonder how much would need doing to my bad one to make it as good as yours Lydian?
Your friend and mine Michael Somerset got a Vandoren bass mouthpiece from us a few years ago- i notice these haven't come up in this chat yet...
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,560
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom