My brain hurts...
After I gaily polished my ebonite mouthpiece with the G3 scratch remover I got drawn into researching the composition of ebonite and what might reverse the ageing process which causes the discolouration.
The first thing I found was that there's a lot more information on this relating to pipe stems, also often made of ebonite, than there is for mouthpieces. Reading a few threads on ebonite pipe stems I found that there are a number of ebonite deoxidising liquids in which you soak the item for an hour or a day and it comes out free of any discoloration and back to black. Here's a review of one of the popular ones:
A Review – Before & After Pipe Stem Deoxidizer and Fine and Extra Fine Polishes
Looks great, if expensive, yes?
However, reading on about these solutions I found some dissent amongst the pipe community in that the discolouration often returned fairly soon after the treatment, or didn't do a thorough job. Others reported that the dip resulted in a rough and/or dull surface on the stem, surmising that this is due to matter being taken away from the hard rubber.
Those in favour of the solution often commented that after use the liquid had retained brown streaks in it where the pipe stem had given up its oxidisation, or that it had just turned brown. This made sense as, apparently, ebonite is porous and so whatever is in this treatment presumably soaks in and pulls out the unwanted brown stuff.
So... I gave up on that route.
In amongst this chatter, on various pipe forums, Carnauba wax would sometimes be suggested by someone but then they'd get shot down by others in that it shouldn't be ingested. A little worried, I looked up what I'd used and found the safety date sheet:
https://www.farecla.com/files/3466/download?language=en
It reads: "First-aid measures after ingestion : Call a poison center or a doctor if you feel unwell. Rinse mouth out with water. Do notinduce vomiting. Never give anything by mouth to an unconscious person."
I later read Pigsquealer's article (many thanks) and seeing as one of his polishes was carnauba wax I looked up the safety data sheet for that also:
https://manage.semproducts.com/public/content/msds/Mothers_05500_MPUSSDS_USA.pdf
It reads: "Ingestion • IF SWALLOWED: Immediately call a POISON CENTER or doctor/physician. •Do NOT induce vomiting.
So... I'm not sure whether my MP should be regarded as scrap seeing as I've injected it with a poison. Remember, ebonite is porous. Oxidisation goes in but can come out with deoxidiser. What if poison goes in and comes out with... saliva? Or am I being overly cautious? I'm unsure that washing the MP after reconditioning it will prevent the future seepage of poison back out of it? Maybe a stabiliser to block the pores and keep the poison inside the ebonite. But what would that be when it too needs to be safe?
Anyhow, the research continued. Some sand their pipe stems but this is generally frowned upon as logos and other markings can be obliterated. I'd had this thought even when just using the scratch remover as I wanted to retain the logo, model number, and tip opening on my MP.
Many say sanding is the only way to remove the oxidisation but my other thought is that if the MP is left to oxidise again in the future more material has to be sanded off. The MP may get slimmer over time.
So... I'm trying to find an answer which avoids sanding (and poison!).
Then I read a question which mentioned stains, dyes, and pipe stems, here:
Stains, Oils, Dyes, Where do I start? - pipemakersforum.com
It didn't really apply to the ebonite stems after all but it got me thinking that if ebonite is porous it might suck in a dye in the same way that my wooden gunstocks suck in the CCL oil I apply.
"An alcohol based dye" was mentioned and looked to be the answer so off I went trying to find a food safe dye. Hmmm... tricky. There are "meat markers" which look, on the face of it, to be food safe but reading the data sheets doesn't confirm this. Otherwise it seems general purpose dyes are, once again, poisonous.
How about the really obvious answer of black food colouring? Well it's not alcohol based but it might work? Here's one I found:
Extra Strong Black Food Colour Gel - Food Colours | Dr. Oetker
At £1.50 I'll get some and give it a go. Let you know the results... don't wait up!
So... in summary:
- Deoxidising solutions may work for a while but may just give a temporary improvement.
- Polishes and waxes may introduce a minute amount of poison into the porous ebonite.
- Sanding works, but future oxidisation may mean more sanding and loss of logos, etc.
- Most alcohol based dyes and stains are not food safe.
- Food colouring is safe and might work, but it might leach out again when saliva'd.
Finally, what's your take on the poison danger? Pigsquealer offers the disclaimer "Nothing is food grade and I don’t care. I’ll wash it before use" and so I'd say it's down to the individual to decide.
Personally I think the risk is small, but a small risk of what... temporary illness... cancer?
It's odd isn't it. A mouthpiece I haven't played and probably won't like has taken so much of my day.
The S2 could have been overhauled in the same time!