[ADMIN EDIT: moved these posts about m6 and minor harmony to its own thread]
Em6 is C# surely, not the b6.Em6. EGBC
Last edited by a moderator:
Em6 is C# surely, not the b6.Em6. EGBC
Yes, you have.I'm self taught and have limited knowledge. I'm willing to be re educated. My understanding is that E minor is the relative of G major. No C#.
Have I missed something?
I'm self taught and have limited knowledge. I'm willing to be re educated. My understanding is that E minor is the relative of G major. No C#.
Have I missed something?
To expand on this a bit - Colin you are right, the key signature of E minor has only F#, it’s the relative minor of G. Dibbs, you are right about the spelling of a minor 6th chord, it uses the major 6th interval.Yes, you have.
By convention, in a m6 chord, the 6 is major. So Em6 has a C# in it. It might be silly but that's the convention.
The chord you want to describe, with the C natural, would be Emb6 but that's quite unusual. Presumably so because it sounds a bit weird in root position with a B and a C clashing at the top there. The normal first extension for a VI chord would be the seventh so Em7 is much more common. This time, of course the 7th would be minor.
It can be in both.So to my thinking Em6 isn't in Em it's in Bm.
It is complicatedI need have another more intensive look at minor theory.
Unfortunately to understand minor harmony you need to know a bit about modes because (in jazz at least) minor harmony “borrows” extensively from modes (and uses modal interchange.)I don't think I'll ever get my head round mode theory.
To expand on this a bit - Colin you are right, the key signature of E minor has only F#, it’s the relative minor of G. Dibbs, you are right about the spelling of a minor 6th chord, it uses the major 6th interval.
How to resolve this seemingly inconsistent set of facts? Answer - consider the melodic minor scale. Remember that most chord extensions in use in jazz (and in romantic / classical music) come from melodic considerations. Dominant 13th chords, major 7th chords, added ninths - you get the picture. This is just more of the same, a note that sounds good over a chord being tacked on as an extension.
...
It depends how it is functioning.minor but if so why does Em7 have a D natural?
Yes I think that is correct, although it is more correct probably to say a minor 7 (interval)Wow! I got that. I thought all seven chords had a flat seven unless otherwise stated.
