Theory & Impro Minor harmony and m6. chords

In this case the minor seems to be the relative minor of F, the aeolian mode, i.e starting on the vi scale degree, and so has a Bb. So if this was an E (aeolian) then the relative major scale would be G, no C#, if it was dorian then the relative major scale would be D, so F# and C#, if it was phrygian then the major scale would be C. Look at the key and the related dominant or major to tell you which.
 
Last edited:
I'm self taught and have limited knowledge. I'm willing to be re educated. My understanding is that E minor is the relative of G major. No C#.
Have I missed something?
Yes, you have.

By convention, in a m6 chord, the 6 is major. So Em6 has a C# in it. It might be silly but that's the convention.

The chord you want to describe, with the C natural, would be Emb6 but that's quite unusual. Presumably so because it sounds a bit weird in root position with a B and a C clashing at the top there. The normal first extension for a VI chord would be the seventh so Em7 is much more common. This time, of course the 7th would be minor.
 
I'm self taught and have limited knowledge. I'm willing to be re educated. My understanding is that E minor is the relative of G major. No C#.
Have I missed something?

Yes, you have.

By convention, in a m6 chord, the 6 is major. So Em6 has a C# in it. It might be silly but that's the convention.

The chord you want to describe, with the C natural, would be Emb6 but that's quite unusual. Presumably so because it sounds a bit weird in root position with a B and a C clashing at the top there. The normal first extension for a VI chord would be the seventh so Em7 is much more common. This time, of course the 7th would be minor.
To expand on this a bit - Colin you are right, the key signature of E minor has only F#, it’s the relative minor of G. Dibbs, you are right about the spelling of a minor 6th chord, it uses the major 6th interval.

How to resolve this seemingly inconsistent set of facts? Answer - consider the melodic minor scale. Remember that most chord extensions in use in jazz (and in romantic / classical music) come from melodic considerations. Dominant 13th chords, major 7th chords, added ninths - you get the picture. This is just more of the same, a note that sounds good over a chord being tacked on as an extension.

The flatted 6th is really more of a tension note, since it leads strongly down to the 5th. It would be the b9 of a V7 chord (B7 in this case), where it naturally resolves down to the note below. The raised (or major) 6th doesn’t have that tendency.
 
Just when you think you're beginning to get it...

So a scale of Em has a C but the chord Em6 has a C#. So to my thinking Em6 isn't in Em it's in Bm.

I was beginning to think the letters were like assembly instructions and described the chord. I'll stick to playing by ear I think.

BiaB must have auto correct.
 
E melodic minor scale: E - F# - G - A - B - C# - D# - E.

It’s called “melodic” because melodies are made using it, but it’s still E minor. That’s where the C# comes from.

Strictly speaking, that’s the ascending melodic minor scale; when melodies descend, they use D natural and C natural. It’s because tones in any scale have direction - that is, they want to move to a neighbor note above or below.

The little side discussion about romantic harmony is because chord extensions (the 6th is an extension) often came about because of melodic usage.
 
I need have another more intensive look at minor theory.
It is complicated

I don't think I'll ever get my head round mode theory.
Unfortunately to understand minor harmony you need to know a bit about modes because (in jazz at least) minor harmony “borrows” extensively from modes (and uses modal interchange.)

It’s a bit simpler in folk and early forms of jazz.
 
Last edited:
To expand on this a bit - Colin you are right, the key signature of E minor has only F#, it’s the relative minor of G. Dibbs, you are right about the spelling of a minor 6th chord, it uses the major 6th interval.

How to resolve this seemingly inconsistent set of facts? Answer - consider the melodic minor scale. Remember that most chord extensions in use in jazz (and in romantic / classical music) come from melodic considerations. Dominant 13th chords, major 7th chords, added ninths - you get the picture. This is just more of the same, a note that sounds good over a chord being tacked on as an extension.

...

Maybe, but trying to pretend it's all logical doesn't ultimately work. Yes, the C# in Em6 might come from the melodic minor but if so why does Em7 have a D natural? They both come from dorian mode perhaps? Not really. Why on earth would that be? They are just conventions that we have to learn and live with.
 
minor but if so why does Em7 have a D natural?
It depends how it is functioning.

  • If it is in D major it is chord II and the 7 is D natural based on the D natural in the key of D major.
  • If it is in C major it is chord III and the 7 is D natural based on the D natural in C major.
  • If it is in G major it is chord VI and the 7 is D natural based on the D natural in G major.
  • if it is in E minor then the 7 is D natural based on the E aeolian or E dorian mode.
 
Last edited:
Minor Harmony Part I - from Bach to Bebop

In traditional harmony, triads only, a 2-5-I looks like this in E minor (one sharp, relative of G major).

2: F# dim, F# - A - C
5: B or B7, B - D# - F# - A
1: E min, E - G - B

These notes show how the harmonic minor scale is derived. When making chords, in traditional harmony, we use the flatted or minor 6th and major, or raised, 7th.

Starting in the romantic period, composers started using extensions or “color” notes in some of the chords. Romantic style harmony got used by popular music in the early and mid 20th century, so swing and bebop adopted those same approaches. In “jazz“ harmony a 2-5-1 in E minor is;

2: F# min7 (b5)
5: B7 (b9)
1: E min 6 (or E min (maj 7)

The 1 chord is derived from the ascending melodic minor scale, where the others are from the harmonic minor scale. Additionally, people often use other scales when improvising, such as the altered scale or the diminished scale, especially over dominant chords.

This is the bottom of the rabbit hole, at least where traditional harmony is concerned. Minor is complicated.
 
Last edited:
Minor Harmony Part 2 - modes

Starting in about 1958 or so (with the composition of So What), jazz started to embrace modal harmony. This reflected practice in hard bop playing that started to arise in that time. It also drew from the Romantic tradition of composition (think Debussy), where there are extended sections of music without traditional harmonic movement, but only chords and melodies based on a single scale or mode.

In jazz, the concept of modes began to be applied to traditional harmony, so instead of a 2-5-1 being derived from a single scale, people started to say things like “Minor 7th means Dorain, dominant 7th means Mixolydian, major 7th means Ionian (or Lydian)”.

This I think leads to a lot of confusion in beginning or casual improvisers. If you apply this to a major 2-5-1, say, in C, you get D Dorian, G Mixolydian and C Ionian. In other words, the C major scale. In minor, this kind of approach does not work as well, especially when you begin to introduce scales like the altered scale or the diminished scale. In reality it does not work because minor harmony requires at least two underlying scales.

What many jazz musicians actually do, rather than using the chord-scale approach, is to “think modally” over minor harmony. So you get people playing the whole first 8 bars of Softly as in a Morning Sunrise using the C Dorian mode, instead of trying to outline the harmony directly. This allows the improviser to think melodically using a single scale, rather than trying to catch every chord. Maybe they throw in a few alternate notes to help outlining the turnaround harmony, but return immediately to C Dorian at the top.

In contrast, when “playing the changes”, improvisers go to great lengths to outline the harmonic movement, making sure they catch the thirds of the secondary dominants, and pay attention to voice leading on 3rds and 7ths especially. They also use substitute chords such as tritone subs, or the “Coltrane turnaround” to add melodic interest. Many skilled improvisers will often mix approaches, doing one chorus modally, and another playing the changes.

This is all very complicated, and it’s no surprise that people get confused. I’ve been studying this for more than 50 years, and still learn new stuff all the time. The best thing is to concentrate on one approach at a time, and when you learn something new, try to explore it and slowly incorporate it into your playing; eventually you will have an arsenal of approaches you can use when improvising.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,428
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom