Playing the saxophone Me playing Take 5

Er, Bb is the 7th of the home key
Bb is the 3rd of the G minor chord in that bar. When I hear the bass playing a G (alto key), it's the major 3rd that made me wince. Definitely doesn't function as a 7th in the harmony in that bar.

I honestly didn't intend for the whole thread to be about one wrong note. Just something that jumped out at me. No need to keep going down the music theory rabbit hole.
 
Last edited:
Bb is the 3rd of the G minor chord in that bar. When I hear the bass playing a G (alto key), it's the major 3rd that made me wince. Definitely doesn't function as a 7th in the harmony in that bar.

I honestly didn't intend for the whole thread to be about one wrong note. Just something that jumped out at me. No need to keep going down the music theory rabbit hole.
Music theory isn't a rabbit hole. In the case of Take 5 it's more of a 'heard' vamp on the C minor, with the Gm7 providing interest. G - Bb - C sounds to me like a typical bass line movement - like C Bb C Eb C Bb C.
Desmond doesn't play B natural in his solo, but he does play an Eb over the Gm7...
 
Context. Not a Desmond-type sound harmonically, but Brecker wouldn't have had any trouble making it sound great.
Wouldn't sound great to me, even coming from Brecker (whom I worship and have transcribed extensively). I just tried it. I don’t like the tonality shift. Sounds like a mistake no matter what enclosure I wrap around it. I don't understand why we're trying to shoehorn a mistake into an enhancement. It just doesn't work. But feel free to post a recording to the contrary.

We hear things very differently. The Bb sounds like a 3rd to me, not the 7th of a root that's not even there.
 
Great Forum!
I say have a listen to this amateur touting a Martin sound while half trashing a favourite tune, and we get majors, minors, other members version, Brecker, harmonic concepts, stupidity (that would be me then), SOTM.
Maybe there's more to come?

I know on some threads that going off topic is a pain in the rear but it really doesn't matter to me at least on this particular thread. Interesting views and experiences.
 
Wouldn't sound great to me, even coming from Brecker (whom I worship and have transcribed extensively). I just tried it. I don’t like the tonality shift. Sounds like a mistake no matter what enclosure I wrap around it. I don't understand why we're trying to shoehorn a mistake into an enhancement. It just doesn't work. But feel free to post a recording to the contrary.

We hear things very differently. The Bb sounds like a 3rd to me, not the 7th of a root that's not even there.
Surely.

Found this straight away on Youtube. It's a bit of a "dry" analysis, but it is on the topic in question, and we're not talking about a mere passing note. If you look at around 2'30" you'll see and hear something that Brecker (and probably many others) did a fair amount.

View: https://youtu.be/5trtn84HN_g


There's also this posting on the subject:


You say that the Bb sounds like a minor 3rd to you over the Gm. Yes it is, over Gm. But in his solo, Desmond plays an Eb quite a bit over the Gm. So, and this is my point: is Desmond playing a b6 over the Gm or is he playing in the home key vamp - Cm?

That's my point. Sometimes improvisation is very vertical and the player is playing very much over the harmony at that very point in the music. Use of substitutes like tritone subs are still vertical. Superimposing chords is another tool used to get away from purely diatonic-based playing. Other times, the player is in transition from one harmonic sound to another, or just playing a melodic line. Often, this is stopped from sounding merely like random notes by the use of patterns. Other times it's just that the melodic line is so powerful that the ear accepts it. Brecker's solos are full of it.

Of course, the context is entirely king. It probably wouldn't be a choice of mine if playing on Take 5 in the original style. Nor music that came before it. Having said that, Desmond might well have played it himself if you take into account his playing where he starts on I'm In A Dancing Mood, with the Brubeck Quartet.
 
Last edited:
Bb is the 3rd of the G minor chord in that bar. When I hear the bass playing a G (alto key), it's the major 3rd that made me wince. Definitely doesn't function as a 7th in the harmony in that bar.
In no universe does a major 3rd on a minor chord NOT change the tonality from minor to major. The flat 3rd is the very definition of minor, and the major 3rd the very definition of major.

But in this case (unless we are listening to different recordings) there is no backing. No bass no chords. I would agree that if we were hearing a G minor chord at that point maybe I would have winced.

However given those links @Pete Effamy supplied, there is obviously a precedent for major 3rd over minor chord. And I mean as a strong note not as passing note (for which I don't think there is any dispute it is not technically "wrong" at all, and in fact is very common and accepted generally)

While the B is not a note as written by Desmond, it still works for me, and as a melody it works especially due to it being a leading note. Having said that it obviously doesn't work from the perspective of needing to hear the original melody as composed by Desmond.
is Desmond playing a b6 over the Gm or is he playing in the home key vamp - Cm?
I can't speak for Desmond, but I approach anything like that vamp as modal, hence no need to structure a solo specifically around the changes as they happen. I'd go so far as to say anyone who did that would sound contrived. I imagine though he is just thinking melodically around a Cm (Dorian)

The point to me of modal jazz to me is the melodic freedom of not being bound by changes so I would just be thinking C minor (dorian). But I've noticed (years ago so nothing to do with this thread) that when I improvise in a dorian, it is very common for me to use notes outside the dorian scale and especially a major 7 quite regularly. But not a major 3rd outside of a passing note - probably because I'm not as clever as Mr Brecker.
 
Surely.

Found this straight away on Youtube. It's a bit of a "dry" analysis, but it is on the topic in question, and we're not talking about a mere passing note. If you look at around 2'30" you'll see and hear something that Brecker (and probably many others) did a fair amount.

View: https://youtu.be/5trtn84HN_g


There's also this posting on the subject:


You say that the Bb sounds like a minor 3rd to you over the Gm. Yes it is, over Gm. But in his solo, Desmond plays an Eb quite a bit over the Gm. So, and this is my point: is Desmond playing a b6 over the Gm or is he playing in the home key vamp - Cm?

That's my point. Sometimes improvisation is very vertical and the player is playing very much over the harmony at that very point in the music. Use of substitutes like tritone subs are still vertical. Superimposing chords is another tool used to get away from purely diatonic-based playing. Other times, the player is in transition from one harmonic sound to another, or just playing a melodic line. Often, this is stopped from sounding merely like random notes by the use of patterns. Other times it's just that the melodic line is so powerful that the ear accepts it. Brecker's solos are full of it.

Of course, the context is entirely king. It probably wouldn't be a choice of mine if playing on Take 5 in the original style. Nor music that came before it. Having said that, Desmond might well have played it himself if you take into account his playing where he starts on I'm In A Dancing Mood, with the Brubeck Quartet.
That’s a great example and analysis. But in that case his use of the maj 3rd over minor in the blues context forces a dominant tonality to my ear, just as you would freely move from maj to minor 3rd in any other blues context. In Take 5 this is like substituting G7 for Gm. I admit it sounds cool, but still changes the tonality in a way I don’t like and sounds outside.

I also accept that the G in the bass could function as simply playing the 5th without changing from the Cm as you would in a 2 beat bass line. But that reinforces the dominant tonality idea with the implied F in the harmony functioning as a sus. This is all just what I’m hearing. I have no idea if it fits theory correctly or not.

Interesting discussion nonetheless.
 
That’s a great example and analysis. But in that case his use of the maj 3rd over minor in the blues context forces a dominant tonality to my ear, just as you would freely move from maj to minor 3rd in any other blues context. In Take 5 this is like substituting G7 for Gm. I admit it sounds cool, but still changes the tonality in a way I don’t like and sounds outside.

I also accept that the G in the bass could function as simply playing the 5th without changing from the Cm as you would in a 2 beat bass line. But that reinforces the dominant tonality idea with the implied F in the harmony functioning as a sus. This is all just what I’m hearing. I have no idea if it fits theory correctly or not.

Interesting discussion nonetheless.
Good place to agree - what sounds right to your ear.

I’m with Pete as hearing the whole as a Cm vamp, and the Gm just sitting on top of the bass playing the dominant. The keys can’t just vamp entirely on Cm, it has to move about.
 
Good place to agree - what sounds right to your ear.

I’m with Pete as hearing the whole as a Cm vamp, and the Gm just sitting on top of the bass playing the dominant. The keys can’t just vamp entirely on Cm, it has to move about.
Yes it's a bit like the Tequila vamp which is the same idea but mixolydian (as mentioned previously). You don't actually need to follow the changes when soling just play in the mode or a blues scale licks
 
Is it me or does that rhythm sound backwards.
I feel/hear that clip 12312 whereas the original I hear 12123.
Interesting on a sop. Completely different timbre. Nicely played though.

Playing it on a diatonic harmonica does emphasise the Dorian aspect of it.
 
Last edited:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,572
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom