Original is Eb minor. Cm alto
@thomsax the transcript I have is Eb (3 flats).
Original is Eb minor. Cm alto
The clues for it being minor are the minor 3 in the melody, minor (tonic) chords, best clue being the last chord and note of the tune. In this case it is a Cm (alto) but the A section is actually in a Dorian mode as the 7th is always flattened. Although I think in your version it is B♮ which does work but not the original intention.Ah OK..It sounds minor and the first note (G) is the dominant of Cm. Are they the only clues?
Thank you!The clues for it being minor are the minor 3 in the melody, minor (tonic) chords, best clue being the last chord and note of the tune. In this case it is a Cm (alto) but the A section is actually in a Dorian mode as the 7th is always flattened. Although I think in your version it is B♮ which does work but not the original intention.
BTW sound is very nice, I would not have tonged so many of the notes but no big problem as the articulation is good.
It does have the chords C-7 and G-7 which translates into Cm7 and Gm7. That is a typical dorian mode vamp.Thank you!
There are no chords on my sheet its just the melody.
It does have the chords C-7 and G-7 which translates into Cm7 and Gm7. That is a typical dorian mode vamp.


Yes I hear those things.Well done, it’s a tricky thing to get every note in the right place.
The Desmond articulation in this is a fantastic study. Also the way in which he plays the opening phrase dynamically - almost appearing from subtone, with a crescendo through to the top of the phrase and back, and with a similar start to the “gliss” G - Bb etc. So much detail. Wonderful player. Quite underrated.
Thank you!
There are no chords on my sheet its just the melody.
I agree about the tonguing but I often sound lazy without it.
View attachment 23515
If you've ever played Tequila, then you have done modes. (Mixolydian)I don't do modes, well, not on purpose.
Have to disagree there Pete. It doesn't work. In no universe does a major 3rd on a minor chord NOT change the tonality from minor to major. The flat 3rd is the very definition of minor, and the major 3rd the very definition of major.... in your version it is B♮ which does work but not the original intention.
Exactly, but only for a moment. Next phrase brought it back. No harm, no foul, just an observation. But it does show how the ear can pick out even the tiniest differences even if they go by really quickly.I hear both of you as the same thing really.
Works but changes the original intention (Pete)
&
Changing the tonality from major to minor by not playing the flat 3rd (lydian umm.....or me rather)
Is what accidentally happened right?
Tequila is my favourite tune to sing at karaoke.If you've ever played Tequila, then you have done modes. (Mixolydian)
Er, Bb is the 7th of the home keyHave to disagree there Pete. It doesn't work. In no universe does a major 3rd on a minor chord NOT change the tonality from minor to major. The flat 3rd is the very definition of minor, and the major 3rd the very definition of major.
Of course you know this, so perhaps you were trying to make a different point? Is the point is that anybody can make any changes they want to a song to make it their own? Beethoven's 5th would definitely sound interesting in C major. So I guess that's ok until it becomes totally unrecognizable, at which point, why not just make up your own original song? Not the case here, just a simple mistake. I miss the key signature all the time, but I fix it the next time around. That's why I keep a pencil handy at every rehearsal.
We all started there didn’t we?However the chances of me smashing them out are a tall order.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WSN-nn0lLt0
I meant it subjectively, so me having no problem with it doesn’t in any way mean that others should not have a problem.Have to disagree there Pete. It doesn't work
But not if followed by a B flat.I meant it subjectively, so me having no problem with it doesn’t in any way mean that others should not have a problem.
I am totally aware that technically it is very wrong to play B natural on a Gm7.
