Tech/maintenance Martin C Melody Restoration

Saxoclese posted a neat method for keeping track of the springs on SOTW, i.e. taking a picture of the horns (or in this case, the keys, printing it out / mounting it on some soft spongy material and then sticking the springs into the spots on the picture that correspond to the location of origin.
Now that you mention that I do remember seeing it.
 
It's just a matter of leveling the pads.
I know what you mean, it is similar to rolled tone holes, a bigger seal is not always a better seal.
I have never liked the wide tops of toneholes on these old Martins”
I have no idea how I stuck these quotes together?
Anyhow are you guys got me thinking (over thinking again :rolleyes:)
What was the reason engineers wanted a larger seating face ?
my first guess was more contact. My next observation told me that thin chimneys could cut a pad. Like a die cutting circle. So with that aspect a wide brim makes sense. So why would modern pads be a troublesome fit ? The pads in this sax may offer some answers.

I laid the pads out and observed the differences. The original white pads have no cardboard backing. One stitch holding them together in the middle The leather is very soft and thick. Even at age 95 it will not tear.
The Tan pads that were installed as a service at some point I’ll head cardboard backing. Rivet in the middle. Installed with some funky hot melt animal glue.

At first glance the original white pads appear to have a better impression. They are very spongy and flexible. Lots of give. The tan pads were quite the opposite. The impression is not as pronounced and the pads themselves are very stiff. Confirmation as pad technology advanced The pad surface became more rigid for better sound reflection. Nothing new. However the additional stiffness reduced the “give” of the contact area. This I feel making the sealing contact more challenging.
0B55B3BB-EA6D-42E6-9D00-16B568DB8F3E.webp
7AA7F29D-4083-43A3-BD57-57525654165E.webp
 
Now this is where it gets interesting. I was curious what the actual hardness difference was. I have a type “A” durometer gauge for measuring mostly rubber. Adequate for this test.
The large white pads measured around 27 shore hardness.
The smaller pads were firmer measuring about 41.
All the tan pads measured were of middle/medium sizes. Measuring about 57.
The center of my thumb pushing as hard as possible measured 17.

For the engineers in the audience. No I did not use the 1Kg bob weight on top of the instrument. I was consistent as possible with the pressure applied. I couldn’t find the stupid weight.
1618199236066.webp

1618199275366.webp

1618199309496.webp

56233C82-AAA8-4218-8B38-2933ACEEB3DF.webp
 
So then I measured some new pads.
The 49.5mm is a Music Medic tan soft feel. Measurement was just shy of 63 shore hardness ! Soft ??
Anyone care to guess what a Roo pad measures ?
1618199874401.jpeg

1618199955034.jpeg

60 ! 3 Less than a soft tan. So the Roo pad – felt – cardboard combination makes the pad stiffer not necessarily harder ?
Regardless the modern pads I feel or are not what the original engineering was designed for. Although modern pads still work.

All measurements were taken from approximately the same area in the pad. Just inside where the wraparound would not disturb the measurement. If you look at the face of several pads. Visible is an impression from where the measurement was taken.
Consider this a crude test.
F05DE0C2-D674-4EC3-AEB1-0963529C786D.jpeg
 
What was the reason engineers wanted a larger seating face ?
my first guess was more contact. My next observation told me that thin chimneys could cut a pad. Like a die cutting circle. So with that aspect a wide brim makes sense. So why would modern pads be a troublesome fit ? The pads in this sax may offer some answers.
You can test how easily (or otherwise) a tonehole will cut into a leather pad by popping one under a bench press and pressing a .7mm wall thickness tube down onto it, having first smoothed off the rim to approximate a tonehole.

pressed pad.webp

My bench press has a 15x power factor. The upper test was the result of 20kgs on the press lever - so that's 300kg at the pad. The lower test was at 30kgs on the lever - 450kg at the pad. And this is an old pad.

Realistically, the only way a tonehole is going to be able to cut into a pad is if there's a burr or a sharp edge on it - and even then it's going to take a fair amount of force.
I think the notion that toneholes can cut into pads comes from people seeing old horns with ancient dried-up pads on them. The leather has long since gone brittle and has, essentially, cracked - typically around the seat impression. On newer pads you're most likely to see it on the palm key pads first, and the low Eb...all of which tend to go brittle and/or rot long before the rest of the pads.

So from a pad-longevity perspective a wider tonehole rim makes little sense - and I very much suspect that the reason we see such things as extra thick and rolled tonehole rims is that someone in the marketing department felt it would be a good selling point.
 
What was the reason engineers wanted a larger seating face ?
My conclusion on the Martin is that soldered on toneholes required thicker walls and the wider tops are a result of that. I don't think that was their goal, in fact they did taper the outside to some degree.
The 49.5mm is a Music Medic tan soft feel. Measurement was just shy of 63 shore hardness ! Soft ?? 60 ! 3 Less than a soft tan. So the Roo pad – felt – cardboard combination makes the pad stiffer not necessarily harder ?
I don't have any experience with the Music Medic soft feel pads so I can't comment on those. I do use the MM regular tan pads a great deal since they are my "stock pad" for play conditions and student instruments. They have a "firm" felt which makes the flatness of the tonehole and the key fit more important, but they do not feel "hard" or "percussive" when played. I also stock the white roos and have also used the chocolate roos on several repads. They have a firm felt as well requiring a good set up, but I believe the leather covering itself to have some "give" in it so the pads are not "noisy" when the keys close on the instrument. It may in fact be slightly thicker than the traditional covering on the tan pads.

I have not used the black roo pads, but I have heard complaints of how noisy they are compared to the white roos and other pads. I asked Curt about that at a clinic I attended and he swears they both are made with exactly the same felt. He guessed that the treatment the skins go through to get the black color makes the black leather a bit harder or firmer.
 
Maybe rigidity of the chimney itself was the engineering intention. A ton of work / expense was put into the technology development.
Although nobody can deny the sales department creativity.
The “Music Trade Review” in journals of the early 1900s may provide an answer. But that’s another project digging through those.https://mtr.arcade-museum.com/
 
Maybe rigidity of the chimney itself was the engineering intention. A ton of work / expense was put into the technology development.
Although nobody can deny the sales department creativity.
The “Music Trade Review” in journals of the early 1900s may provide an answer. But that’s another project digging through those.https://mtr.arcade-museum.com/
It might have been.
Soldered toneholes were nothing new - Adolphe's own horns had them, as did many earlier horns - but there was perhaps thought to be some sense in making the base as large as possible to limit the effects of SGC (though it probably made it worse).
 
@Stephen Howard , @jbtsax no doubt there is different technology amongst the pads available today. Would it be reasonably fair to say most last about the same ? That would be comparing the workhorse range. Not the high end makes. Also not all the variables of installation ease or adjustment stability. Just lifespan.
Good question. I dunno.
I suspect it's all down to the leather...and that doesn't mean the thickness of it.
There was a chap over here (1950s-60s) called Gordon Beeson whose pads were renowned by players because they seemed to last forever. I'm still fixing horns with Beeson pads on them that are in serviceable condition..
But then I repadded my YAS62 with standard Pisoni Mypads back in the 80's, and it's still going strong.

I think some players just eat pads, no matter what quality - and others seem to make them last, no matter how cheap 'n cheerful.
 
I suspect it's all down to the leather...and that doesn't mean the thickness of it.
I’m keeping the original white pads. May be useful for a museum grade restoration. They are that good of condition. Removing the stitch I could wash the felt and clean the leather. The only issue is smell and cosmetic. I guarantee you most of these would function just fine. For fun maybe I’ll clean them up after I’m done with the build.
 
I’m keeping the original white pads. May be useful for a museum grade restoration. They are that good of condition. Removing the stitch I could wash the felt and clean the leather. The only issue is smell and cosmetic. I guarantee you most of these would function just fine. For fun maybe I’ll clean them up after I’m done with the build.
I wouldn't bother.
I used to have to make them for original Adolphe sax restorations. They're just white kid and coarse felt. On earlier woodwinds the pads were 'stuffed' with loose wadding. Not so bad on a period clarinet - but when you had to make a stuffed pad for an opheclide you were dealing with a 'bag' three or four inches in diameter.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,514
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom