Playing the saxophone Major scales

I feel that learning should always have an element of challenge in it. One way to add a little challenge is to mix up the order of things - circle of 5ths, 4ths, chromatic, diatonic, ii V, and other cadences, following the changes of a tune. etc.
But also, an exercise that's solid can be used to work on other things like timing, variations in articulation or whatever.
 
View: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=aUuYsB6uCiU


This looks like a great way of building technique..Would the scales be played in alphabetical order.. with the flats directly after there namesake.. or as laid out in the circle of fiths i.e cgdaebf followed by the flats
He starts on D, goes up and down the scale then goes up a half step to the next scale Eb and so on.
 
View: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=aUuYsB6uCiU


This looks like a great way of building technique..Would the scales be played in alphabetical order.. with the flats directly after there namesake.. or as laid out in the circle of fiths i.e cgdaebf followed by the flats
I like the challenges at the end to play to 2 and 4 on the metronome and the tonguing change up and down
 
Trying to rip through scales at a speed you can't play is just a good way to set in stone all your finger bobbles, out of tune notes, and unevenness of time.

Far better to play slowly with a metronome and make sure that each and every note change is as instantaneous as you can make it, with no fingering slop, maintaining a constant pitch and tone quality.

Practice slow to play fast!
 
Like a lot of his videos the title might be click-baity but I think his advice is sound, he does emphasize proper technique, building up to the goal in stages, etc.

However I think I prefer a different video I saw from Ray Smith which is how I'm practicing scales at the moment.

View: https://youtu.be/GDY8VuXPFH0?t=315

I don't know about 90 bpm though, I'm practicing on the 2 and 4 at 30 bpm :doh:

He says an interesting thing there about how a lot of people talk about the circle of 5ths, but what you should really practice is the cycle of dominants (i.e. going the other way around, the circle of 4ths), because then as you practice scales and especially arpeggios you're resolving from the V chord to the I. So you start on C, then next is F, because C is the V chord of F.

Not to say practicing scales chromatically isn't good too of course.
 
Like a lot of his videos the title might be click-baity but I think his advice is sound, he does emphasize proper technique, building up to the goal in stages, etc.

However I think I prefer a different video I saw from Ray Smith which is how I'm practicing scales at the moment.

View: https://youtu.be/GDY8VuXPFH0?t=315

I don't know about 90 bpm though, I'm practicing on the 2 and 4 at 30 bpm :doh:

He says an interesting thing there about how a lot of people talk about the circle of 5ths, but what you should really practice is the cycle of dominants (i.e. going the other way around, the circle of 4ths), because then as you practice scales and especially arpeggios you're resolving from the V chord to the I. So you start on C, then next is F, because C is the V chord of F.

Not to say practicing scales chromatically isn't good too of course.
It's a good point; while of course one can use the circle of (ascending) fifths to move away from the tonic, what I see more often is using a single jump away from the tonic (most typically to the 3rd or 6th) and then progression around the circle of (ascending) fourths to resolve back to the tonic. So I'd agree that in the playing of real world tunes the circle of (ascending) fourths is seen more often. It's also going to be important to capture minors as well as majors (the ii V7 I pattern is just a movement by ascending fourths, but the first one is minor and the second one a dominant 7, so that the same note collection covers all three chords).
 
He says an interesting thing there about how a lot of people talk about the circle of 5ths, but what you should really practice is the cycle of dominants (i.e. going the other way around, the circle of 4ths), because then as you practice scales and especially arpeggios you're resolving from the V chord to the I. So you start on C, then next is F, because C is the V chord of F.
I have always seen the circle (or cycle) of 5ths as what you call the cycle of dominants, ie down a 5th. C F Bb Eb....This is the way I've heard most people talk about it, e.g. like the song All the things You Are, or the middle 8 of I Got Rhythm.

It's also how Jerry Coker refers to it in his very nice book Improvising Jazz.
 
Last edited:
Life was simple back in the '50s. 🎶
Major and relative Minors were practiced with a metronome. Each week you played the assigned scales at a given BPM.
The following week, the scales that were practiced, got the BPM up a bit, and the new scales at the slower BPM.
1. No sharps or flats.
2. One sharp and flat.
3. Two sharps and flats. Etc etc.
This was accomplished while reading and then from memory.
One octave, then two, etc etc.
Etudes and tunes, went along with the scale work.
Arpeggios as well.
Slow is smooth, smooth becomes fast,
The kids that learned to do this correctly, and then practiced, got work.

I might add, that once you finished your daily lesson work, you were free to do whatever you wanted.
 
Life was simple back in the '50s. 🎶
Major and relative Minors were practiced with a metronome. Each week you played the assigned scales at a given BPM.
The following week, the scales that were practiced, got the BPM up a bit, and the new scales at the slower BPM.
1. No sharps or flats.
2. One sharp and flat.
3. Two sharps and flats. Etc etc.
This was accomplished while reading and then from memory.
One octave, then two, etc etc.
Etudes and tunes, went along with the scale work.
Arpeggios as well.
Slow is smooth, smooth becomes fast,
The kids that learned to do this correctly, and then practiced, got work.

I might add, that once you finished your daily lesson work, you were free to do whatever you wanted.
Yes, it wasn't much different in the mid 1960's. The books then carried on a similar method. One book, a rather thick one by H. Closé for clarinet started one off in similar fashion, had increasingly difficult scales, minor scales, intervals, etudes and duets.

Wanting to learn jazz interpretation, one book I purchased was basically a study in jazz scales and intervals. It didn't didn't teach me jazz as it alluded to, but instead were the "nuts and bolts" to give a background that could be used in playing jazz.

To learn jazz, I learned the only way to do, is to do. I made plenty of mistakes trying, but as I practised utilising both Jamey Aebersold and Hal Leonard Jazz Play-Along books with backing track CD (and later downloadables) with a plethora of songs in various genres, I got better at it as time went on.

As Yoda said, “Do or do not. There is no try.” :mrcool
 
Life was simple back in the '50s. 🎶
Major and relative Minors were practiced with a metronome. Each week you played the assigned scales at a given BPM.
The following week, the scales that were practiced, got the BPM up a bit, and the new scales at the slower BPM.
1. No sharps or flats.
2. One sharp and flat.
3. Two sharps and flats. Etc etc.
This was accomplished while reading and then from memory.
One octave, then two, etc etc.
Etudes and tunes, went along with the scale work.
Arpeggios as well.
Slow is smooth, smooth becomes fast,
The kids that learned to do this correctly, and then practiced, got work.

I might add, that once you finished your daily lesson work, you were free to do whatever you wanted.
Apart from the metronome, this was the way I learned to read and play sax music in the late '90's too. And not just maj/min scales: note values, dynamics and other music notation were just as important. IMHO 'technique' also includes things like embouchure, breathing, voicing, articulation, upward/downward slurs, etc. And 'fluency of playing' too.

I've never been much good at 'technique' in the sense of 'being able to play fast runs' (scales or otherwise). TBH, I've never really needed or wanted to have 'fast technique'. Except for what specific sections of specific scores demand. So my 'technique exercises' are generally on a 'need to play' basis.

IHMO (as an amateur playing in local Big Bands), some sax players with much faster 'technique' than me can be tempted to overdo their 'technique' on solos to the detriment of 'musicality'. At least, that's my excuse 😉.

IHMO, the choice of sax practice exercises depends largely on factors such as:
- the current level of your reading/playing ability
- the kind of music that you often play (or would like to play)
- the keys that you often play in (or would like to play in)
- the suggestions of any tutor that you might have (or - alternatively -any helpful suggestions you might request from cafe members

The exercises in the OP's video (however useful) wouldn't be for me (even 30 years ago!). At that time, my (Dutch) 'ability to play in a band' level B diploma (there are also levels C and D) required me to recognize and play common musical notations (keys, dynamics, repeat, etc). The keys were limited to major and (mel/harm) minor keys that had 1-3 'sharps' and 1-3 'flats'. Speed was not a real issue. 'Fluency' (including timing) was.

For 95% of my amateur playing career over 30 years, my 'B diploma' was sufficient. Thankfully my general 'playing ability' has developed since then. Mostly through experience and also thanks to the many tips and resources that I've discovered via the cafe. Whenever 1 or 2 'extra' sharps appeared in a key signature, I would explicitly note any 'unusual' notes in my score.

It's only in the past year that I've needed to upgrade my reading/playing ability to the equivalent of (Dutch) 'level C/D' by learning to play in keys such as E,B and F# (4, 5 and 6 'sharps') and A-flat, D-flat and G-flat (4, 5 and 6 flats). Again on a 'need to play' basis.

So to summarise, the OP's posted video wouldn't have suited me at all. Because:
- the ability to quickly play all major keys so quickly would not have helped me develop much; I only needed to know the maj/min keys that I usually play in; IMHO 'technique (speed) ' can be practiced just as well on these
- the exercise doesn't cover any 'intervals' in any key; IMHO 'technique' includes the knowledge and ability to play 'common intervals' in different keys: running up and down arpeggio's is relatively 'easy', dropping a note down/up an octave takes more skill, as does dropping down/up to a different interval
- choose an exercise (preferably guided by a tutor) that suits you
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,408
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom