Saxophones Lucky me!

I’ve had a total of one on my bench. That was only to make a replacement pillar for cloth guard. All lacquered brass finish. Wasn’t dropped off with crook included. Never played it..
I do remember this being of good solid metal and craftsmanship. Also that the lacquer was practically flammable.
Part of it are solid - certainly the keywork - but the body seems to be quite thin. Had a few surprises when leveling some of the toneholes.
 
Finished up the Couesnon - and despite saying I wasn't going to polish it I ended up giving it a bit of a clean. But not a polish, right?
Used Goddard's Silver Dip - brushed it on the body. Did a nice job. Cleaned the keys by hand.

I've taken lots of photos, so will update the original review as and when I get the time - have a few more observations to add to the existing one. But in terms of how it plays - it's just as nice as the others I've seen.

shwwind_couesnon_monople_alto bell_cf.webp
 
Finished up the Couesnon - and despite saying I wasn't going to polish it I ended up giving it a bit of a clean. But not a polish, right?
Used Goddard's Silver Dip - brushed it on the body. Did a nice job. Cleaned the keys by hand.

I've taken lots of photos, so will update the original review as and when I get the time - have a few more observations to add to the existing one. But in terms of how it plays - it's just as nice as the others I've seen.

View attachment 38732

who gives a **** Stephen - did you play it ? ? ? ?
 
Finished up the Couesnon - and despite saying I wasn't going to polish it I ended up giving it a bit of a clean. But not a polish, right?
Used Goddard's Silver Dip - brushed it on the body. Did a nice job. Cleaned the keys by hand.

I've taken lots of photos, so will update the original review as and when I get the time - have a few more observations to add to the existing one. But in terms of how it plays - it's just as nice as the others I've seen.

View attachment 38732
That's beautiful! Are there any Couesnon show and tell threads around?
 
Part of it are solid - certainly the keywork - but the body seems to be quite thin. Had a few surprises when leveling some of the toneholes.
Reflecting on this comment. I can completely relate. Isn’t it odd how some makers have keywork tough as nails and body’s like soft like mashed potatoes 🤔. Then different years have completely different characteristics in the metals.
Some makers more extreme than others. IMHO, Saxophone metallurgy is a subject to be respected.
 
Reflecting on this comment. I can completely relate. Isn’t it odd how some makers have keywork tough as nails and body’s like soft like mashed potatoes 🤔. Then different years have completely different characteristics in the metals.
Some makers more extreme than others. IMHO, Saxophone metallurgy is a subject to be respected.
Thing is, the horn comes in at almost exactly the same weight as a MkVI alto - and with more or less similar keywork for the most part it doesn't indicate a particularly thin-walled body. So it has to be down to how the body tube was annealed.
In the end it's no big deal - there are pros and cons which balance out.

I noticed on the saxpics website that they say the Monopole wasn't as well-built as the Buffet saxes of the period. I think I'll have a few things to say about that...
 
Annealing isn't going to affect modulus of elasticity, only yield strength. So if you're saying it seems to flex more, that's not metallurgy or heat treatment. ( All the common brasses will also have about the same modulus.). If you're saying it dents easily, that's yield strength and is definitely related to material composition and heat treatment.
 
I noticed on the saxpics website that they say the Monopole wasn't as well-built as the Buffet saxes of the period. I think I'll have a few things to say about that...
I love Pete H. and that site has long been a remarkable resource, but he did play fast and loose mixing opinion and lore within the specs and overview.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,341
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom