Saxophones Lowest playable note on a tenor

This is the way I understand it. When I play an F# on my alto saxophone, the wavelength of the frequency sounded is determined by the distance to the first open tone hole and back. [Actually it is a bit more complicated than that, but this will work as an illustration.]

When the instrument is warmed up and the mouthpiece is accurately placed on the cork, the note sounded will be an "in tune" A = 440 vps.

The alto is an instrument that transposes DOWN. Lowest C on an alto (written Middle C, C4) is the Concert Eb at 155.56Hz. It's a convention to transpose UP from concert pitch, cos that's easier to do.

Please don't add to confusion by introducing non-standard terms like vbs.
 
Yes, but.... Wavelength is determined by the length of the tube. And is fixed by the length of the tube. So as the temperature of the air in the tube increases, the speed of sound increases, and the frequency increases. Which is why we tune a sax by adjusting the length of the tube (mouthpiece position).

Yes. I kind of thought that was what I was saying 😀.

But I would expect a piano to go down in pitch on a hot day as the strings expand and lose tension, and it would be by different amounts on different strings Don't know how hot or cold it would have to get for this to be noticable though.
 
No idea about the piano, I'd guess you're right, but remember the frame will expand as well, so it may be that the frame and string expansion complement each other.

My wife's guitar ensemble played for a hospice memorial service a couple of weeks ago. The Church was freezing, so the guitars were tuned for that temperature. Was OK. There were about a hunderd candels lit for the deceased, and that and the people in the church raised the temperature enough to put the guitars badly out of tune. And no way to retune without affecting the mood of the service.
 
lowest playable note depends on which tenor you have..




if you have this one its a low G:
brazil-low-g-tenor-1.jpg


🙂))
 
OK guys. Look, all I said is that the unsw article makes no direct connection between the written notes in its table for A#3 and the frequencies of the resonances. I agree that it does say that notes are the written pitch but it doesn't say which peak in the impedance spectrum corrisponds to A#3. But with your help I now know the answer. Thanks everyone.
 
The alto is an instrument that transposes DOWN. Lowest C on an alto (written Middle C, C4) is the Concert Eb at 155.56Hz. It's a convention to transpose UP from concert pitch, cos that's easier to do.

You are correct that the written low C (below the staff) on the alto sax is the same pitch as the Concert Eb (3rd space up in the bass clef) with a frequency of 155.56 Hz.

When given the printed music in concert pitch that has that bass clef Eb, one must transpose up a major 6th on the alto sax to get its written C below the staff that sounds the same pitch.

Please don't add to confusion by introducing non-standard terms like vbs.

Sorry to confuse. "VPS" or "vibrations per second" is used interchangeably with "hZ" or Hertz and means the same thing. "Cycles" or cycles per second can also used to refer to frequencies of sound and light waves.
 
The unsw article says that A#3 is the lowest note playable but it is referring to the written note, not its actual frequency. I now know that the frequency of A# written is 116 Hz because really it is A#2. But the article doesn't actually say this. It gives the impedance spectrum and there is a peak at 116 Hz but nowhere does it say that this peak is A#3 written. I take everyone's word for it that this is indeed true, and all I'm saying is that Professor Wolfe doesn't say so. I wonder why not. Any ideas ?
 
Wouldn't the written low Bb (A#) on the tenor sax be a concert Ab (G#) since it is a transposing instrument? What is interesting to me is that on the saxophone and other conical instruments for the lowest tones, the second and third harmonics have a stronger (taller) peak than the fundamental which is the sounding tone. I also wish that the spectrographs on the UNSW website gave the pitches of the harmonics.
 
The lowest peak in the impedance spectrum for written A#3/sounding Ab2 is 104Hz, not 116Hz - that would be A#2. If you look closely at the top left of the spectrum image, there's a staff with the note, note name and (approximate) frequency; confusingly, it's the frequency of the sounding note, not the written one.

If you read the site thoroughly, you can then infer the frequencies of the harmonics: for a saxophone they're f, 2f, 3f etc, so in this case 104, 208, 312 etc. (clarinets give you f, 3f, 5f and so on). You'll also find the consequence of the lower peak at the first fundamental - the low notes are harder to play...

Cheers

Jonathan
 
What is interesting to me is that on the saxophone and other conical instruments for the lowest tones, the second and third harmonics have a stronger (taller) peak than the fundamental which is the sounding tone.

Interesting and also very frustrating when you try to play said notes quietly :sax:
 
Interesting and also very frustrating when you try to play said notes quietly :sax:

A fun exercise is to play a low Bb forte and then begin a diminuendo. At a certain volume the 2nd harmonic will naturally take over the tone. Benade calls this the "octave sneak". It happens when the 1st and 3rd harmonics have lost all of their energy and the 2nd is still going strong.
 
A fun exercise is to play a low Bb forte and then begin a diminuendo. At a certain volume the 2nd harmonic will naturally take over the tone. Benade calls this the "octave sneak". It happens when the 1st and 3rd harmonics have lost all of their energy and the 2nd is still going strong.

You may think it's fun. I find it really annoying ;}.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,677
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom