Tech/maintenance Low F sharp not easy to play

zebrafoot

Member
Messages
69
Location
Oxfordshire, UK
Hello everyone,

I'm a reasonably experienced bari/tenor player and I recently bought a very budget instrument on eBay. Described by the seller as "excellent condition", it is of course not, but I think with a bit of effort I can make it usable. As it was super-cheap, I'm not bothered about having a go to fix whatever needs doing.

I noticed a leak from the A key where a previous owner had stuck a big fat felt pad under the key where it touches the Bis Bb - this meant that the Bis Bb bottomed out before the A touched down properly - I've removed this, trimmed it and ironed it and reaffixed it so that there's no daylight any more. Similarly, there's an issue with the lever that seats the G# so that it doesn't quite get forced down enough, but I can see that that is caused by a groove worn in the cork on the G# and have work-arounds for it.

So after I've done the above fixes, I note that I'm able to play reasonably well down to C, assuming I use enough air support, but the F# is really dodgy. The F# above the stave is quite clean and clear, but the low one is quite horrible and difficult to hit. I'm not an alto player so I accept that it could be due to bad technique on my part. However, is there anything I should be looking for with respect to the F#? I have the Stephen Howard manual and I can't see any specific reference to this one being an issue.

Pete
 
Sounds like yet another leak.

It could be high up on the horn and acting like an octave vent. Your solution is going to be to shove a leak light down the thing and then take action against all the leaks you see. Or pay someone to do it, your choice.
 
Hi turf3. Thanks for the reply. Could be, although I'm not seeing one. I'll take another look when it's dark so I can see properly. I definitely don't want to pay anyone to do this - the horn is not worth the cost plus I like to learn stuff so it's fun to do it myself.
 
In my terminology the key cup below the G# is the F#. The keycup below that is the F, and the one below that is the E. When the E is closed and the F is open it should sound the note F#. You might check that closing the E closes the F# all the way.
 
Thank you jbtsax.

I don't use the side F# key very often (the one that opens a key cup on the player-side of the instrument) but I did just test this and noticed that the F# was much better than when playing in the "normal" manner. This does suggest that it's an issue with the E key as you suggest - perhaps due to compression of the cork that actuates what you're referring to as F# and G#. I'll test the air-tightness of the pads when playing F# each way and see if that sheds a bit more light on it.
 
OK, if the side F# plays fine then as noted it'll almost certainly be a stack adjustment.

The two most typical ways this could be wrong would be either the middle finger by itself doesn't sufficiently close that pad (it's a cork adjustment on the back side) or that one of the adjusting screws on the bridge between upper and lower stacks is screwed too far in. In the second case, either the bis Bb pad or the G# pad is bottoming out before the lower stack pad operated by the middle finger can close. In that case both the pad directly under the middle finger and the one two pads above it won't completely close. That's an adjusting screw adjustment (I assume we're talking about a modern el cheapo Selmer copy, not an old horn that used corks rather than adjusting screws on that bridge).

The first of these is what jbt above was describing.

It'll be less likely that an adjustment screw has been screwed in too far or that a piece of cork has gotten thicker. It'll be a lot more likely that the cork on the back side key foot or bar has either crushed down or fallen off.
 
The relationship between keys, regulation, can seem a little daunting at first. Take your time and look closely what moves when you press each key.
RH 123 are refered to as the lower stack. Any of them can be thrown out by either the Bis connection or the G# screws.
More likely there's some wear in the cork shimming on the bar round the back that connects them all. You may need to remove the trouser guard, two screws, to see whats happening and refit cork shims.
Yamaha copies have screws to adjust the regulation. Yanagisawa copies have height adjusting screws. Old horns and cheap chinese horns are all cork shims.

Take your time. Look carefully. If you decide you need to take anything off, take a photo, so you know how to put it back.
 
Thanks Colin! I'm very glad this particular instrument didn't go to a beginner, because although it wasn't quite unplayable when I got it, it was nearly that way and could've caused untold frustration.

Late last night I had a chance to put a light inside the horn and noticed that there was the tiniest, weeniest leak from the lowest right-hand palm key (the Bb). I've tweaked the spring that shuts this one and I think that stopped the leak satisfactorily. I couldn't see any further leaks, but I am suspicious of this F# behaviour, so I will investigate the cork shimming (it is cork, not a screw) that regulates the action at the bar at the back.
 
Right, so a small update.

I've had a fair old honk now that it's a less antisocial hour - the Bb palm key leak might have been fairly important, because the F# is sounding lovely and cleanly now, even using the "normal" keying. In my experimenting with the lower notes I have discovered that whoever did the "fixes" on the sax before has partially knackered the thread for the grub screw that holds the G# down, so that the grub screw wiggles up and down in the screw hole - not very helpful! A proper fix would maybe be to re-tap the hole and make or acquire a screw with a bigger thread , but actually it works ok with a thin strip of PTFE tape wrapped around. I'll worry about a more permanent fix when I've gone over the whole instrument.

I'm still not totally happy with the notes below D - perhaps the D cup is being held up a bit by a poorly adjusted G# screw, causing a slight leak? Otherwise, I'm getting some reasonable sounds out of it.
 
A leak at G# will affect bell notes and may not be noticeable in the lower stack.
If the ptfe tape works, I'd call that fixed.
Just to avoid confusion, Bb is a side key.
Palm keys are left hand.
Keep at it.
There's lots of spares on ebay if you know what they're called. Varying quality, fit and delivery times. 😉
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,709
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom