Saxophones Looking for an alto under $2,000

6441

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,846
I know I can search posts, but these things are also time-dependent, that is a recommendation from 2016 may not be as good as one from right now. I am very new to the saxophone, but I have tested some veery good ones, and I doubt I could justify buying a $3,500+ horn at my level. After a come to Jesus discussion with the boss love of my life, we determined that we're ready to go up to about $2k. I know there are some Yamahas in that range, what are your experiences, your recommendations, etc. As I am in France, unless an instrument in excellent shape is within an easy train ride with an amazing deal, it's not a good plan for me to buy used. As a matter of fact, I bought one used, and I see now I was in no position to judge its condition. I will ask around here, but the market is very tight.

So, in a new instrument, what would you say would be a good choice?

YAS-280(S) and YAS-480(S) are in that range. What else? S is silver? I see no other difference The S are significantly more expensive, yet more people have bought them on Thomann. (I'd buy locally for servicing reasons.)

All three Jupiter models are under $1,000. The Jupiter JAS700Q-SCS appears to be the most recent. (Is that good or bad?) Are the Yamaha so much better as to be 50-100% higher?

What are your thoughts on these or alternatives?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yep, S stands for silver. If you're not a fan of having to polish a horn, you might want to stick with the lacquered version.

If you have the cash, I'd recommend the Yamaha 480. The TJ SR is worth a look, but perhaps not so available where you are - and the Yamaha 280 is still hard to beat.
I haven't seen the newer Jupiters as yet, but based on what they used to build I'd tend to steer clear unless you're really tight on your budget.
 
I have serviced a couple of the newer Jupe 1100 models, their top offering...they are pretty darn good. Nothing struck me as 'hmmmm'.
While their retail prices tend to be around 2500, display models/open box/blems can be had for around $2g.


Given your price window and insistence on new...quite honestly I see only a few big-name models which fit that:

the Yamas
a possible Jupe 1100 (if one is to stay clear of the 700's)
Buffet 100's or 400's
Selmer USA La Voix or AS400
Mauriat 57GC


On SOTW there are fans of the boutique-brands Barone and Kessler, FWIW.
Cannot say more than that, personally ...this is not a vouch....as I have never had one on my bench.


Then we get into stuff like Allora and Jean Baptiste, probably best to avoid.

Not gonna give you the "more bang for buck = used" lecture because you stated your decision on that (other than to say if you build in $400-ish of tech work to the equation at the start, you will end up with a far better horn in the end).

Best of luck.
 
I totally understand the logic behind used, especially since we have a good tech. But the logistics are tough, as I don't have a car. If my trusted contacts (teacher and store) know of an instrument. I'll definitely check. There is currently a Yanagisawa curved soprano used for 2k€ through the store. Sounds like a good price if it's in perfect shape, but that's not what I'm looking for. When kids start, it's almost always on alto, so there's lots of rentals. They become available for sale, but they're the cheapest Jupiters. I rented one and wasn't particularly impressed with it. (But what do I know?) It's funny, the soprano I'm renting was rented for three months to a kid. He gave it up after that. It's actually pretty hard to play compared to the alto. It's like a toy, they're Taiwanese, about 530€ new. I do like the idea of a curved soprano, though. as a second instrument.
 
IMHO Jupiters are variable. The ones made in their first decade or so weren't very good, but they began hitting their stride in around 2000. I have worked up several dating from '99-'10-ish, various models, and they were acrtaull pretty well made, albeit some a bit light in the body metal.

I have refurbed a few which IMHO were very good, the Artist 8XX series (silver) I actually have a warm spot for. I like those horns, their sound and blowing response is actually quite 'on'. But they discontinued the model.

I have NOT serviced any which were made after around '12....besides the aforementioned newer 1100's...so I dunno what the ones from that era are like.

I understand completely your new-used compass. Which is why I didn't pursue it much.

But it really looks like choices are fairly limited given your parameters - I actually expected to dig up more alternatives than there seem to be.

Godspeed....
 
OP has already stated he wants a new horn. So isn't the thread is about "what (reputable) new Altos are available in the $2000 range ?"

As opposed to being a thread about 'new vs. used'. Unless OP chooses to segue it into that, I suppose.
I think Randulo has considered the argument of 'more bang for buck' before deciding he wanted to see how much new horn he could buy, is all I am saying.


So am not sure if links to used horns is particularly helpful to OP in this instance (yes, understanding that they may well have been set up very nicely and the sellers being honest blokes as well).
 
OP has already stated he wants a new horn.
So am not sure if links to used horns is particularly helpful to OP in this instance (yes, understanding that they may well have been set up very nicely and the sellers being honest blokes as well).
Yes, nice gesture but I did say clearly, that unless it's a very short train ride (no car) I couldn't see it. That listing says clearly NO SHIP outside UK. Even if it could, you can't buy an instrument without seeing it, really, except new, knowing they'll change the setup, usually free if it isn't excessive. I totally get that it's a better deal to buy a used instrulment. You can sell it for almost what you paid rather than losing at least half its value right away. It's guaranteed. Suppose I did travel to the uK or Germany or USA, how would that guarantee work?

Yamaha seems a safe choice within the budget, but I highly value up to date appreciations of these things.

Thanks everyone past and future who contributes their experience playing and setting up repairing these machines!
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,679
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom