Saxophone beginners Liebman mouthpiece exercises on clarinet?

Matteosax

Member
Messages
14
Location
Switzerland
Hello, I play tenor since about 25 years, trying to get into clarinet now. I was trying to play the clarinet mouthpiece only, like I did in my early saxophone days according to David Liebman/Joe Allard school of thought about developing control over the tone production with larynx / vocal box. I have a range of a bit more than an octave on a tenor hard rubber mouthpiece.
While on the tenor mouthpiece I seem to be able to control the pitch with larynx and tongue position, to extend the range with lower notes on clarinet mouthpiece I need to drastically alter the air speed and create a sort of a special resonance in my mouth, which I am struggling to control. I can hit those low notes maybe once every 2 minutes.
This necessity of altering the air speed makes me wonder about the usefulness of these exercises, the difference in air speed and mouth resonance between high and low notes on clarinet mouthpiece only is big, and I am wondering if this comes to fruition in real clarinet playing scenarios.
Sorry for the long description, and I would be curious to hear about the experience of seasoned and newer doublers.
Have a lovely day
Matteo
 
If you see the David Liebman/Joe Allard school of thought as a template which can be used for doubling instruments you are thinking in solutions. See it as a toolbox which you can use for the problems you want to solve. The first part is to find out which tools to use for which problems.
 
Clarinet embouchure is quite different to saxophone embouchure. Especially tenor.

Clarinet remains more or less tight and static throughout the range. No need to force out low notes. Low notes will speak more easily on clarinet.
The technical reason is related to the difference between cylindrical and conical bores.

Bb soprano clarinet covers the range of alto and soprano using an instrument smaller than both.

The range in the lower register sounds the same as alto saxophone although it's written differently.

It may help to think higher while playing low. All those ledger lines for low E make it look very low. The same note on alto would be written B one ledger line. On tenor it would be a written E bottom line of the staff.

Best advice is to treat clarinet as a completely different instrument. It's not a saxophone.

Clarinet players have less trouble learning saxophone than saxophone players have learning clarinet.
 
Clarinet remains more or less tight and static throughout the range. No need to force out low notes. Low notes will speak more easily on clarinet.
On the whole, I think the sinners (clarinet players) amongst us would agree with this. *

Mostly, clarinet tone is about having homogeneous registers - the same tone throughout, like a piano, just low through to high. As Colin says, the embouchure tends not to change much, including the jaw position. Higher notes are somewhat aided by the lower angle of the clarinet into the mouth - creating somewhat of a crowbar effect - essentially applying some pressure to the reed by way of pushing onto the lower lip, that is in turn pushed into the reed by the jaw being perhaps halfway (of the possible total movement) forward. Roughly, bottom teeth level with top teeth, unless your dentist has informed you that your teeth are somewhat "unique".

Eddie Daniels popularised an airy, West Coast type of thing on the clarinet, which can be achieved by using less pressure IMO, rather than anything else.

Classical clarinet tone has taken to being tighter in recent decades, less open. The higher angle of the clarinet utilised by "jazzers" is one of the first things that classical players tend to point out...



*Other clarinet solutions are available!
 
While on the tenor mouthpiece I seem to be able to control the pitch with larynx and tongue position,
I don't think you can change it by tongue position, you can change it by altering the pressure against the reed. IMHO that works better with a "high" tongue position that Allard describes to stabilize air pressure while lowering pressure against the reed.
Because the Tenor MPC has a much larger tip opening, and the air column is longer, it's easier to change pitch.
My personal opinion is that these exercises are pretty useless on clarinet.

I've been into that "change pitch with changing air speed" thing, but Dr. Mark Watkins' book "From the inside out" changed my mind.

Greetings, Guenne
 
Last edited:
Put the clarinet together and play it. Listen to your tone, and focus your sound.

Find a clarinet teacher when you hit a wall. Or find a clarinet teacher now if you’d rather ward off bad habits.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,524
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom