Playing the saxophone Left thumb pain

this pain is making me think that perhaps playing the saxophone is not for me
Hold on there, Bald Eagle. It is easy to be disheartened...

If your thumbs are useless for other tasks due to joint issues, like eating with a spoon, then, maybe, your instinct is correct

Otherwise, there are workarounds...

See if what @Colin the Bear said helps. It looks like premium advice to me
I would much rather stick to the tenor
Me too

Play the sax you want to play, and position it to suit your hands


I have been paying A LOT of attention to stay relaxed. This seemed to have taken the "edge" of the pain off, but the discomfort and lingering pain is still there, even if it's lesser.
The good news is, you are already finding ways to get past the issue, so keep it up
 
Thanks for the advice everybody!

I don't have any finger issues that I know of except for the saxophone and I didn't really develop any of these issues until maybe 18 months into my saxophone journey...

What I'm not quite clear on is how can the saxophone be balanced, especially if the bell is on the right thigh, either inside or especially outside. Does that position not automatically put it into an unbalanced position, making it want to tip over?

I can more or less balance the saxophone if I really try to have it centered, but then my right wrist feels squished against my right leg and it doesn't feel too comfortable... So my right wrist and hand feels the most comfortable if the bell is on the center of the right thigh, but then I feel even more pressure on the left thumb 🙁

My reed and mouthpiece hasn't changed for quite some time and I actually ended up going down in size and strength, currently playing on JJ DV NY 6 with Vandoren ZZ 2.5 reeds, which feels quite comfortable to me.

I've been half thinking about getting one of these: Relieve Back & Neck Pain with Sax Support Sax Stand.. however I don't really want to have to lug this thing around and having to rely on it. It'll also change the position of the mouthpiece in my mouth, which will throw everything out of whack if I take it away (similar to my current struggles of trying to play while sitting down).

Do most of your play sitting down or standing up? Have many of you had finger or other joint pain while/after playing? I've been considering going back to playing sitting down to see if that makes it better, however trying it out a few times after playing exclusively standing up for most of the time felt really awkward and everything was out of wack.
 
From the way you're describing things I'm assuming you're a short person.
I'm 5'11" and the tenor bell is on my hip.

If the bell is on your inner thigh, between your legs, then the weight is in your thumbs. This is fine for posing for photos or grandstanding on stage for a moment or two, but for extended practice or play it's going to cause problems. Problems like you describe.

The most comfortable position is with the horn across your body.
Some vintage horns have the sling ring in a position that leaves the horn a little unbalanced.
Having said that it should still be playable no thumbs.

Hang it on the sling across your body and adjust the sling so that you can reach the mouthpiece no hands.
With just fingers tip the horn into playing position. Play it there.

Without thumbs you can't hold the weight or grip.

This works standing or sitting.
For playing in a sitting position, a suitable chair is essential.

I told my doctor "It hurts when I do this"
He said "Well don't do it then"
Words of wisdom from Tommy Cooper.
 
So, I did an experiment.
Held the tenor as per Colin's description - works (even though I don't have a paunch). Held it like that with just enough thumb pressure to stabilize the horn, and held it up straight in front... And the amount of thumb pressure hardly increased (the strap doing, literally, the heavy lifting). A little more pressure on the lower/ right; almost none on the upper/left.

It may be a good exercise, @GRoss , to do an exercise like that, ensuring you don't tense up anywhere?
 
Last edited:
Over the course of a rehearsal or gig, for comfort I'll pretty much go through every possible option - standing with horn to the side, standing with horn out front, sitting with horn to the side, sitting with horn between legs, etc. If you let the horn hang from your neckstrap, with no thumb pressure, the natural position is at an angle to the side. Any other position means you're pushing it in some other direction with your thumb. That's perfectly ok for a few minutes at a time. But you need to return to a relaxed position frequently or you'll get fatigue/pain. I think as long as you spend a significant amount of time relaxed (let the horn hang with no thumb pressure), you'll be fine.

Another thing to consider is whether you're using upward force, as you would with a soprano or clarinet, or lateral force as you would just pushing the horn forward in front of you (not up). The latter is much less stress on the thumb and can be maintained for a long time without pain or fatigue. What you want to avoid is supporting the weight of the horn by pushing upward with the side of your thumb. So adjust your strap find the right angle with the horn at your side so your embouchure is still comfortable.

I've been playing sop, alto, tenor, bari, etc. for 40+ years, sometimes 4+ hours per gig and never had any chronic thumb pain that couldn't be fixed by relaxing.

See how everybody in the section lets the horn rest to the side. None are putting any stress on the thumb. That should be your goal.
8d13223r-300x241.jpg
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,611
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom