Miscellaneous Learning to improvise (again)

Messages
2,849
Location
Breda
Level
Amateur (for 30 years)
I've been playing tenor sax in amateur Big Bands for years. On a few tunes, I even get to improvise over (usually) 16-24 bars. I gave up trying to play written-out 'suggested solos' years ago. Not knowing much about jazz theory, I've pretty much just always improvised by ear, learning from rehearsals what 'seems to 'works' or not. I've picked up a couple of tips along the way such as 'telling a story', not overfilling a solo with 'notes', improvising on rhythm as well as on melody, incorporating breaks and 'dynamics' and trying to improvise in a way that somehow fits in with the mood and tempo of the song/tune.. My technical skills are crap so for solos I mainly rely on 'musicality' using the tips I've picked up.

My amateur Big Band solos are 'adequate' but somehow also in a rut in the sense that my approach to improv has stayed pretty much the same over the past years. So I've signed up for a 'Jazz Improvisation workshop'. Not (as I'd expected) for a day/weekend workshop but for a 13-week evening programme including theory, instruction and weekly practice (as a group).

The general format of the 'practice' seems to be a fairly simple tune that participants of all levels can play as 'backing' with repeating solos for individual participants. At the moment, it that the workshop participants include a drummer, bassist and a variety of sax, trumpet and trombone players, I'm looking forward to the first 'workshop' next monday. Anyone else have experience with 'Jazz Improvisation' workshops?

Mike

PS. I'm much too lazy to learn improvisation from 'the greats' through transcription or analysis! Or even from books or YouTube videos. The idea of 'learning together' appeals to me more
 
You and I sound very similar. I've been lead tenor in various big bands for years. I do my best but could never get to the point where I could really shred. My solos are on the simplistic side, but I think lyrical and musical because I really try to focus on voice leading at all costs. I'm interested to hear if the workshop helps. In my experience, they only help a little because I seem to have plateaued years ago. I'm still hoping for that big epiphany someday that takes me to the next level.
 
The thing about theory is not to apply the new knowledge directly to improvisation, but rather to use the music-theory relationships in your daily practice to explore new ways to improvise over changes, then develop those that work for you, then use those on the bandstand. Even a simple thing like side-slipping a half step (a form of the tritone substitution) when applied sparingly after you've practiced up on it at home, can add a lot of spice to an otherwise mundane solo, but the arbiter is always those things on the side of your head.
 
You and I sound very similar. I've been lead tenor in various big bands for years. I do my best but could never get to the point where I could really shred. My solos are on the simplistic side, but I think lyrical and musical because I really try to focus on voice leading at all costs. I'm interested to hear if the workshop helps. In my experience, they only help a little because I seem to have plateaued years ago. I'm still hoping for that big someday that takes me to the next level.
Yeah, I know what you mean! Let's be honest:, as long as your MD, fellow band members and audiences feel that you're doing well (or OK), then you're doing well (or OK). Same for me. I have no idea whether this workshop programme might lead me to some kind of an epiphany, but I'm hoping that it may at least expand my improv options. I always enjoy playing in ad-hoc bands and I'm looking forward to what kind of improvs that I and other participants come up with during the coming months.

I've watched a couple of 6-year old 'workshop' videos and TBH, they don't inspire me at all. But I'll keep you ((and others) posted on this thread on what I've learned (and on what was a waste of time) from these workshops.
 
Getting fresh ideas can always help. You may also find that following theory too closely is the antithesis of where you want to go. Technique (in terms of playing faster technically) is a poor substitute for the qualities you already possess. Audiences are not particularly enamored of soloists who are just technically "showing off". Learning riffs and arpeggios that are correct in terms of following the chart (playing the changes) can be novelties, but become far more "stale" the more you use them.

Take in ideas, but keep lots of what you already have and do. You may find that you are already in a place that is far advanced musically compared to those who espouse a whole lot of technical drivel. Academic knowledge is good, academic playing is generally not.
 
If I know that I'm going to play a solo in a given song and I also know how many bars and form (solo over verse + bridge ....) I used to take an empty note paper. Fill the first bar(s) so you have an idea how to start the solo. After that you fill the last bar(s) so you have an idea to end the solo. Then you can "fill" the rest. I use to cut up the solo in smaller pieces (four bars). Plan four bars at the time. Don't play too much leave some space so the listeners are "welcome in". Learn the chords so you hit the interesting tones. Play the key words or make up you own key words. Play some effects, growl, heavy shake/vibrato, alternative fingerings, the necessary repetition .... I was/is into Rock & Roll Saxophone and at very low level. I did some improvising but 75-80 % of the solos I played/learned was the same from time to time. If I was going play/learn to do a 12 bar solo I had 12 or 24 bars to put in if they wanted me to continue (happened just one or twice 😉) so don't blow off the steam too soon.

At the Andrew Clark RockSax workshops we spend some time to learn how to play a solo. Here is Andrew playing a long emotional solo. Pandemic, playing instead of his friend/mentor, .....
View: https://youtu.be/n-e2VXKRX7k
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,340
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom