Mouthpieces Larger tip opening (and maybe shorter curve) can be more versatile

Pete Thomas

Admin
Cafe Moderator
Messages
23,632
Location
London
Level
Retired professional
I know this makes most sense when you think about mouthpieces with high/medium baffles but I get the feeling it applies generally. Perhaps this should be a poll but maybe some discussion first would be good.

The point about baffles is that any mouthpiece that has a baffle and a small tip means the baffle itself is closer to the reed and so inherently brighter. And then not so easy to make less bright via embouchure. This is maybe over-generalising and the assumption is that baffles do not change relative to the tip opening.

OTOH if a baffle is relatively lower (further from reed) due to tip opening then it has less inherent brightness so easy enough for the player to add brightness - hence more versatile.
 
What technique(s) can the player use to "add brightness" other than changing to a brighter reed ?

Rhys
I use two things.

  • Put more mouthpiece in your mouth. Sound gets brighter. This is partly why I suggest not to do that all the time. Players who play Links tend to do this all the time in order just to stop that gaddam awful mouthpiece from sounding too bland.
  • The very slightest bit of growl - so you don't actually hear actually a growl but it's like a guitar adding a teeny bit of distortion. It has the effect of sounding brighter. I think both BenWebster and Coleman Hawkins did this.
 
Well, from my position in the bottom third of saxophonists, it seems to me like this:

- the high baffle piece when played with inadequate airstream support, sounds like a duck call - quacky, bright but not in a good way, and it doesn't project nearly as much out front as the player thinks.

- The moderate baffle piece when played with good airstream support can be played from bright to dark, depending on the needs of the moment, with a good rich sound.

- If you've a real good strong airstream, you can play a high baffle piece and get a wide range of expression out of it, brighter and more penetrating than you can get from the moderate baffle piece, and you won't be able, easily, to play as softly and smoothly as with the moderate baffle piece, but still a good range of expression - but you HAVE to learn to blow THROUGH the thing, not AT it.

Honestly, I don't find a big tip-opening dependency in quality of sound - I have a real high baffle piece with a relatively small tip (Level Air alto #4) and it still sounds like a high-baffle piece to me - I have a modest baffle piece with a very open tip (Otto Link hard rubber 10* (!) and honestly other than the difference in what it takes to get it to sound, it gives me about the same results as my #6 Otto Link rubber of very similar design.

From my seat, it seems that tip opening is more about comfort, the ability to stand up to a lot of air, and maybe a bit of additional flexibility, whereas the basic design of the mouthpiece baffle, chamber, bore, etc. is what really drives the sound quality.
 
Put more mouthpiece in your mouth. Sound gets brighter.
When I take more mouthpiece (open my jaws) my sound goes "darker or mellow". I don't play mouthpieces with low beaks. No duck bill or low comfort beaks. And I use some layers of mouthpiece patches as well. To play a baritone reed on tenor mouthpiece makes the sound less bright as well. More wood "dampens".

To add some buzz to your sound can make your sound brighter. The easiest way is to play plasticover reeds. You can also split the tip of the reed with a razorblades.

Most bright mouthpieces have some kind of baffle (roll over and/or step ev bullet baffle)to change the sound in what we define a bright mouthpiece. Other things that change the sound is also how the chamber is designed. My Rovers are dual chambers mouthpiece that are shaped in a V. IMO bright mouthpieces are not only high baffle and hard reeds. I use hard reeds because they don't get bent so easy. Keeps the gap between the tip of the reed and the tip of the mouthpiece better.

I don't get the baffle effect on high baffled mouthpieces that are under .115" tip opening.
 
I use two things.

  • Put more mouthpiece in your mouth. Sound gets brighter. This is partly why I suggest not to do that all the time. Players who play Links tend to do this all the time in order just to stop that gaddam awful mouthpiece from sounding too bland.
  • The very slightest bit of growl - so you don't actually hear actually a growl but it's like a guitar adding a teeny bit of distortion. It has the effect of sounding brighter. I think both BenWebster and Coleman Hawkins did this.

Interesting that you don't mention airflow / blowing technique.

Rhys
 
While technially that is possible its also possible to make a smaller tip with less bafle than the larger one. I know I make pretty dramatic changes between sizes.

Overall what you propose can work but its only going to work for some players. With the wrong player the some tips are going to sound unballanced.

To me it makes more sense to make a piece correctly within every tip size. Other methods are shortcuts that will make the player work harder to control the piece.

Thats my initial thoughts anyway.
 
To me it makes more sense to make a piece correctly within every tip size. Other methods are shortcuts that will make the player work harder to control the piece.
Exactly. And I assume that is why Dave Guardala just made one tip size although custom sizes were available. Of course it's easier from a manufacturing/production line and stocking POV.

But then if using CNC it shouldn't't be a problem for a baffle to be different based on tip size.
 
Yes, with CNC just find what works once and you are set. When making one by hand larger pieces right off the bat have more material for baffle in the tip rail so that helps account for that issue....if you are starting with a medium tip blank. If you go smaller you need to remove baffle or the piece will be excessively bright
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,516
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom