Playing the saxophone It's shocking how few saxophonists can do this basic thing...

I only play tenor sax in 2 amateur Big Bands with a few improvised solos. So I don't play in jam sessions or need to play in unfamiliar keys 'on the spot'. I completely agree that practicing in different Major, Minor, Pentatonic & Blues keys across the whole range of the sax is essential.

One of the requirements to get my 'basic band playing' certificate was being able to play Major and Melodic/Harmonic Minor scales in keys that had up to 3 flats or sharps in the key signature. Since then (25 years ago) I've very rarely needed to go beyond that, occasionally playing with 4 sharps/flats.

So for me personally, I don't think practicing scales in all 12 major (and minor, ...) keys would add much value. Knowing where the 'blue notes' are in each key I play in and how they would sound, does. As does knowing how certain intervals sound.
 
Yeah, it's' a game they have to play with the algorithms to monetise the channel. We get free content and just need to put up with being told to 'smash that subscribe button' every video.
 
Last edited:
Me too. 30 secs how to fix the Focus wipers. 40 secs how to fix the fan. 90 seconds how to fix the telly.

I watched a youtube instructional video once. Thirty seconds to show how to replace the gas struts holding the car boot open.
I used to have a brush handle in the boot when mine gave up the ghost. Got some inquisitive looks.
 
Why should I as a "blues and rock woodshed honker" play scales in all 12 keys? I'm more interested in how and when to use the diffent scales out of style/genre. Borrow from other scales to make it more intersting.

"To play the blues scale in this R&B song is an absolute train wreck".

majorscales.JPG
 
Reminds me of the superold joke we have here when a professor at the conservatory asks the Boogie piano player at the entrance examination what the subdominant of F would be.

"What? F IS the subdominant..."
 
Just to be an advocate of the Devil and play about a bit; let’s not forget that many methodologies/ideas are rooted in classical “practices”.

There are many orchestral examples of big scalic runs, up and down, in one key/scale. In that case, it’s a must to know all scales extended across the range of your instrument, because it’s gonna come up. So be prepared.

Other than that, well it’s not essential, and while it could still be beneficial (any fluidity is?) - it would certainly take practice time away from something probably more useful.
 
Yes.

I also see the logic in not learning about carburettor overhauls and replacing piston rings when all you want to know is how to change a wheel and carry out an oil and filter service.

All good stuff is good stuff, but some of it is more relevant for some rather than others. It also depends on when you start learning and how much time you have/want to give to it.

Parker practised an awful lot, unsurprisingly. This was documented in this being put to him in an interview by Paul Desmond. So, even then, (1954) folklore had it going around that Parker just had the ability to play like he did.
 
Yes.

I also see the logic in not learning about carburettor overhauls and replacing piston rings when all you want to know is how to change a wheel and carry out an oil and filter service.

All good stuff is good stuff, but some of it is more relevant for some rather than others. It also depends on when you start learning and how much time you have/want to give to it.

Parker practised an awful lot, unsurprisingly. This was documented in this being put to him in an interview by Paul Desmond. So, even then, (1954) folklore had it going around that Parker just had the ability to play like he did.

We know Charlie was not a young jazz prodigy, because when he was practicing 12 hrs a day as a young kid, he visited a jazz session in his local town and asked to sit in. The result was very embarrassing for him as all the musicians laughed at his playing. I imagine that when Charlie followed his own advice, he must’ve thought……Well they’re not laughing now.
 
The result was very embarrassing for him as all the musicians laughed at his playing.
The story I know of is slightly different, ie he tried someone a bit innovative with double time and got a bit tied up - so they may have been laughing at his attempts to do something outside the norm as opposed to just being incompetent. If this was the situation where he had a cymbal thrown at him.
I imagine that when Charlie followed his own advice, he must’ve thought……Well they’re not laughing now.
Yes exactly.
 
The story I know of is slightly different, ie he tried someone a bit innovative with double time and got a bit tied up - so they may have been laughing at his attempts to do something outside the norm as opposed to just being incompetent. If this was the situation where he had a cymbal thrown at him.

Yes exactly.
Guys were double-timing even in '35 or '36 which is when the famous incident is supposed to have happened. What happened is that he wasn't up to snuff, lost the time, and got hooted off the stand (whether or not a cymbal was actually thrown I rather doubt - if it was Papa Jo, he wouldn't have been wanting to risk damaging expensive cymbals - it was probably something more like a "Gong Show" ending).
 
Why should I as a "blues and rock woodshed honker" play scales in all 12 keys? I'm more interested in how and when to use the diffent scales out of style/genre. Borrow from other scales to make it more intersting.

"To play the blues scale in this R&B song is an absolute train wreck".

View attachment 20058
Because even tunes you THINK are simple can go into different keys. You can't just slather a blues scale over everything.

If you're actually playing rock and roll on tenor, you're already playing in the keys of F#, B, C#, E, G#; so once you've got those down, F and Eb just aren't gonna be that tough.
 
Guys were double-timing even in '35 or '36 which is when the famous incident is supposed to have happened. What happened is that he wasn't up to snuff, lost the time, and got hooted off the stand (whether or not a cymbal was actually thrown I rather doubt - if it was Papa Jo, he wouldn't have been wanting to risk damaging expensive cymbals - it was probably something more like a "Gong Show" ending).

One night in 1937, a teenage musician called Charlie Parker joined a queue of players waiting to jam onstage at Kansas City's Reno Club. It was a special occasion. A star guest in the rhythm section was Jo Jones, drummer for Count Basie's Orchestra, one of the biggest swing bands in the US.

Charlie Parker thought his moment had come, 16 years old or not. He had been practising an improv method of his own, deploying keys rarely used in jazz tunes, and modulating between them to free up new ways of phrasing – and he'd bought a new Selmer saxophone.
Read full article...
 
:One night in 1937, a teenage musician called Charlie Parker joined a queue of players waiting to jam onstage at Kansas City's Reno Club. It was a special occasion. A star guest in the rhythm section was Jo Jones, drummer for Count Basie's Orchestra, one of the biggest swing bands in the US.

Charlie Parker thought his moment had come, 16 years old or not. He had been practising an improv method of his own, deploying keys rarely used in jazz tunes, and modulating between them to free up new ways of phrasing – and he'd bought a new Selmer saxophone. Read more."

The thing is, all versions of this story lead back to Ross Russell's book "Bird Lives", and the accuracy of that book's been heavily challenged a number of times, by people who were actually present at events Russell reports without having been there. I'm positive Russell was NOT at the Reno Club for the famous session (if that's even where it occurred - if it even did occur). So most likely what Russell wrote down was Bird's recounting of an event that had happened years before. And Bird was a world class bullsh!TT#er, and master of the put-on, so there's no telling how much he embellished, combined incidents, etc. to make his point. I think the underlying point - Bird was a boy obsessed with jazz and improvisation, and horned his way into sessions where he wasn't ready, and got humiliated, and took that as incentive to go practice more and get his stuff together - is undoubtedly accurate - but that it happened exactly THAT way? Much doubt has been cast on it. For one thing, do you really think Jo Jones would risk one of his expensive cymbals to throw it? Ever tried to undo a cymbal and throw it somewhere, from behind a drum set? Then he's got to get up go round and pick the thing up and put it back in place? I don't think Papa Jo (famously irascible as he was) would have bothered with all that stuff. If the incident ever even occurred rather than being a composite of many experiences, it's more likely he quit playing, everyone else quit playing, and he hit a big "Gong Show" type sendoff on the big ride cymbal, and probably said something like "get the F off my stage, kid!"
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,562
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom