Saxophones It it worth getting a C melody sax?

I think you need to try one for yourself and experiment with different mouthpieces. I just bought a Buescher C Melody to play in a worship band and I really like it. Not just because I dont have to transpose, but I think the horn blends in with vocals and modern worship better. If you want a saxophone that blends in and adds accompaniment while still able to have a few solo parts its great. Finding the right mouthpiece is a challenge. I have a Morgan and Caravan. The Morgan has good projection and the Caravan has better intonation.
 
Before it quickly deteriorated, due to never having been used, my Selmer Serie 1922 was a delight to play. It has a great tone and I won't hesitate spending the money on getting it thoroughly overhauled. Whilst it's not worth as much as a Mk VI it's a stunning instrument that works well with an Otto Link tenor mouthpiece.
 
Hello everyone, I'm in the process of buying a sax for college and during my internet searches keep finding failrly cheap, not bad looking C melody saxes, like this silver True Tone here. In curiosity, I went to wikipedia and discovered C melody (and mezzo sopranos) were intended for use in orchestras. I know that didn't work out, but if by some srange magic theres a sudden orchestral music revival with saxes in C and F it would become useful... A man can dream. Anyhow, what are your thoughts on buying a sax in C? I can definatly C 😉 it being useful as oposed to playing in a key like C#. I want to buy it and get it checked over (how much does that cost again? It would probably only need pads and adjustments), but right now thats based soley off of the fact that it looks really nice and true tone sounds familliar. Do you C it having any use beyond a collectors item? I'll stop using C wherever I can now, I got it out of my system.
Well, all other replies from the 'usual suspects' and no change in attitudes over the years (this question/topic has been asked before)

I really have always liked Melody C's... I've owned/played them for 50+ years.(back in the day when you all laughed… 😉 ) I missed the Aquila Sax re-manufacture episode but when Thomman took the plunge approx. 8 years ago I bought one of their first (silver plate) C's with modern keywork and with a metal 8* early tenor link/plasticover 3.5 it can be a 'demon and a sweet maiden'... it's been a great player and worn well(I play it almost every day) I also own Conn/Martin 'c's(all fully rebuilt) and although the actions are clunky I still get a decent sound, although not as good as the Thomman.


Caveat is if it will be the only horn you have I'd say no...however owning one will certainly improve your reading of flat keys (get ready for three as standard and often five) it will put you well above the G/D/A/E sharp(s) 'Infantry'...think of yourself as 'special forces'...I often play flute /oboe parts (obviously with range limitations) however I get some decent altissimo when required 😉 All have a nice da.y
 
Last edited:
I came really close to buying a C-melody a few years ago when I came upon one in a pawn shop in New Orleans for little money. My thinking at the time was I never play with arrangements with Eb or Bb charts, all my music and backing tracks are in C, if I play with others we all use the same head chart in C. At the time I was playing guitar in a jazz workshop, the leader/teacher would hand out the changes and teach us the head by ear. We rarely had horn players except for a trombone player. I really couldn't think of a reason NOT to have a key of C saxophone at the time.
 
Is says…..it’s in the north not reverb but crag lis
4F299C3B-3B01-4845-BB9B-52C79352C340.webp
Conn C Melody alto saxophone in near mint condition for an almost 100 year old sax. Needs nothing but a player. ….Sorry no “””””TRADE OR SHIPPING and …….SCAMMERS go elsewhere, I will not respond …cash only….If serious leave number
 
Hello everyone, I'm in the process of buying a sax for college and during my internet searches keep finding failrly cheap, not bad looking C melody saxes, like this silver True Tone here. In curiosity, I went to wikipedia and discovered C melody (and mezzo sopranos) were intended for use in orchestras. I know that didn't work out, but if by some srange magic theres a sudden orchestral music revival with saxes in C and F it would become useful... A man can dream. Anyhow, what are your thoughts on buying a sax in C? I can definatly C 😉 it being useful as oposed to playing in a key like C#. I want to buy it and get it checked over (how much does that cost again? It would probably only need pads and adjustments), but right now thats based soley off of the fact that it looks really nice and true tone sounds familliar. Do you C it having any use beyond a collectors item? I'll stop using C wherever I can now, I got it out of my system.
I overhauled a Conn C melody for a client, but he knew exactly what he was getting into--he leads a '20s style band and also plays Albert system clarinets, and answers only to himself. But almost no one would hire a player to play C melody, and if you buy one that doesn't play perfectly, you'll never recoup the cost of getting it into shape. Also, "straight-necked" Conns (they look more like a big alto than a small tenor) are, in my opinion, the only C melodies that are worth more than a couple hundred dollars in any condition. If you don't mind spending $200 to turn a $200 sax into a $225 sax, and don't mind noodling on a sax that no arrangement includes, they can be fun. I'd get a C melody before I'd get an alto clarinet.
 
I overhauled a Conn C melody for a client, but he knew exactly what he was getting into--he leads a '20s style band and also plays Albert system clarinets, and answers only to himself. But almost no one would hire a player to play C melody, and if you buy one that doesn't play perfectly, you'll never recoup the cost of getting it into shape. Also, "straight-necked" Conns (they look more like a big alto than a small tenor) are, in my opinion, the only C melodies that are worth more than a couple hundred dollars in any condition. If you don't mind spending $200 to turn a $200 sax into a $225 sax, and don't mind noodling on a sax that no arrangement includes, they can be fun. I'd get a C melody before I'd get an alto clarinet.
Well-said ! ... but in my experience, and I too have refurbed a fair # at a client's insistence, after giving them every caveat I could think up, lol....MOST C-Mels at the end of the day aren't gonna set you back just $400 worth of investment to get into good tack.
Meaning most which can be acquired FOR $200....need substantially more than 3 or 4 hours of tech work.

So it just becomes a money hole...and usually, I have found, a player is initially stoked but once the novelty wears off, the horn gets put in the closet or sold for a loss....
 
I overhauled a Conn C melody for a client, but he knew exactly what he was getting into--he leads a '20s style band and also plays Albert system clarinets, and answers only to himself. But almost no one would hire a player to play C melody, and if you buy one that doesn't play perfectly, you'll never recoup the cost of getting it into shape. Also, "straight-necked" Conns (they look more like a big alto than a small tenor) are, in my opinion, the only C melodies that are worth more than a couple hundred dollars in any condition. If you don't mind spending $200 to turn a $200 sax into a $225 sax, and don't mind noodling on a sax that no arrangement includes, they can be fun. I'd get a C melody before I'd get an alto clarinet.
"If you don't mind spending $200 to turn a $200 sax into a $225 sax"
I have(several times)...'Viva la Mancha'...😎
A C Mel is on my back burner radar along with other oddities.
Good man…!!..."we fight the good fight"...😎
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,598
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom