Saxophones It it worth getting a C melody sax?

I knew I liked the 20s style of what I call soft jazz, and all of these c melodys sound just like it. I never would have thought I was chasing the C melody sound (when I play jazz anyway, I'm mostly a classical player). Dispite most everyone saying getting a c is a bad idea, this thread has only made me want one more! πŸ˜›
 
Thanks @Justin Chune for that clip it was wonderful I have always fancied having a C melody and now I know why, they sound fabulous and now I must have one and I suppose if your lucky and you buy an old one it might come with its own old mpc. I've bought quite a few old saxes and most of them have had a few mpcs along with them in the box that only leaves you with the reed problem and apparently they are available too so whats to lose if it floats your boat why not I think there is a C Melody forum too
 
I knew I liked the 20s style of what I call soft jazz, and all of these c melodys sound just like it. I never would have thought I was chasing the C melody sound (when I play jazz anyway, I'm mostly a classical player). Dispite most everyone saying getting a c is a bad idea, this thread has only made me want one more! πŸ˜›

But will your teachers at college agree with you. I love that traditional jazz sound, but I doubt if it is what is taught at music colleges.
 
I knew I liked the 20s style of what I call soft jazz, and all of these c melodys sound just like it. I never would have thought I was chasing the C melody sound (when I play jazz anyway, I'm mostly a classical player). Dispite most everyone saying getting a c is a bad idea, this thread has only made me want one more! πŸ˜›

I never said getting a C-melody sax was a bad idea. You just need to be realistic about:-
  • how it sounds (range of tone-colours)
  • how it will advance your playing career (paying gigs? teaching?)
  • the opportunities for using it with other players (type of music)
The above 3 points probably wouldn't enter the equation if you were talking about soprano, alto, tenor or baritone horns. However, they do with a C-melody. Thing is, C-melody saxophones are very much a "niche" instrument.

I'm not a huge fan of C-melody horns, but that's just my personal view. Your mileage may vary. Some people absolutely love them, and who am I to judge? With that said, if I saw a really tasty example of one in mint condition at a bargain price, then chances are I'd buy it for my collection.

If the C-melody really appeals to you and would make you happy, then go for it. Life's too short. Just make sure you get a nice one.
 
Tim Price is playing a Vito (made in France). I think it's a C melody/tenor from c 1960. i think that the Vito sounds better tham my 1927 Conn. A C melody/tenor in the hands of a good player sounds realy cool.

I have a 1960s Vito C melody - mine sounds very close to the Conn C melody I also own and I wouldn't be surprised if the body tube is basically the same. The Vito's ergonomics are slightly more modern but not like the SBA or MK VI - wouldn't it be great to have one of them ?

Both my Conn and Vito have the "long alto" style neck, but you can see right at the end of the Tim Price clip that his Vito seems to have a tenor style neck.

I have C melody mouthpieces by Windcraft (plastic, OK), Morgan (hard rubber, excellent) and Pillinger (bronzite, also lovely). They all take tenor sax reeds. I never got on well with alto or tenor mouthpieces, but an old Selmer metal tenor piece came close for sound and tuning.

Scott Robinson made a whole album on C melody ("Melody from the Sky") that is great. I can't find any tracks from that on YouTube but here a live recording of Scott playing his C melody.

Rhys
 
Last edited:
A melody C must be a nightmare to transpose. I have enough trouble with my Bb instruments.. My Eb brain would blow a fuse trying to not transpose and play what's written :confused:

What really throws you (at first) is the fingering when compared to the sound. Obviously, the fingering on a C-Melody is identical to that of a alto/tenor - so that's not the problem. It's the notes that come out of the bell (which don't seem to "match" the fingering) that I'm talking about. You do get used to it, but the "sound mismatch" seems odd at first. Switching from alto to tenor and back feels pretty seamless by comparison, but switching from alto to C-Melody feels (to me at least) a bit strange. Anyone who's played a C-Melody will know what I'm talking about.
 
Last edited:
I couldn't play my C melody/tenor in same way/style as a play the Bb tenor. And I don't want to learn anything that makes me a worse tenor and bari honker. All old saxes are differnt. Modern saxes have ( in general) better intonation/even scale compared to saxes from the 20's. But that doesen't mean that old saxes are not playable. This it was I was told when I bouhgt my C soprano back in the mid 80's: "All C sopranos have different pitch characteristics. On yours, I find that the middle C (third space C), C#, and A are a bit flat. - pushing in the side Bb key, Bb and side C key and G# key respectively helps out a bit. High C and B are a little sharp (not too bad) and you might to adjust key heights for them." I just did some small adjustments on high C and B/H.
 
I have a 1960s Vito C melody - mine sounds very close to the Conn C melody I also own and I wouldn't be surprised if the body tube is basically the same. The Vito's ergonomics are slightly more modern but not like the SBA or MK VI - wouldn't it be great to have one of them ?

Both my Conn and Vito have the "long alto" style neck, but you can see right at the end of the Tim Price clip that his Vito seems to have a tenor style neck.

I have C melody mouthpieces by Windcraft (plastic, OK), Morgan (hard rubber, excellent) and Pillinger (bronzite, also lovely). They all take tenor sax reeds. I never got on well with alto or tenor mouthpieces, but an old Selmer metal tenor piece came close for sound and tuning.

Scott Robinson made a whole album on C melody ("Melody from the Sky") that is great. I can't find any tracks from that on YouTube but here a live recording of Scott playing his C melody.

Rhys

Looks like he's playing a Conn straight-necked C-melody.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,599
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom