Playing the saxophone Is this Transcription accurate? Flat 1?

CliveMA

Senior Member
Messages
1,047
Location
Brisbane, QLD, Australia
1000026435.webp

This is bar 15 in transcription of Scott Hamilton playing Autumn leaves

Does the b1 make sense?

(I understand the rest of the line I think).
 
OK, so the first b1 (E7) is a flat 5 blues note (Am). That makes sense to me.

But should the later E triad be E flat or E natural? It is notated as flat but the triad should be E natural?
The later E is not notated as Eb, it’s an octave lower so the accidental doesn’t apply. If you play the line you’ll hear that an Eb there would sound awful.
As @skeller047 says, it’s a classic blues/minor line.
 
The later E is not notated as Eb, it’s an octave lower so the accidental doesn’t apply.
I've always been confused by that! OK, an accidental only applies to the same line or space not to an octave different. Gotcha.

I've been playing the E triad as E natural in that measure without knowing the correct accidental rule. Good to know my confusion was only about notation meaning.
 
I've always been confused by that! OK, an accidental only applies to the same line or space not to an octave different. Gotcha.

I've been playing the E triad as E natural without knowing the correct accidental rule. Good to know my confusion was only about notation meaning.
Yes, your ear has informed you well. An Eb, as you’ve probably tried already would sound really awful followed by the G# and B natural. It would work if followed by a D and C, like the octave above and carrying on the A blues theme.

A note on transcriptions - I’ve rarely come across a transcription that didn’t have a mistake. Pitch mistakes seem to be far more common than rhythm too.

So keep trusting those ears!
 
I've always been confused by that!
With big piano chords it does mean that there are accidentals all over the place, but it would be really confusing if this rule were not in place as for extended harmony you’d be second guessing everything.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,062
Messages
578,402
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom