Tech/maintenance Is it rust red , or red rot?..

Brasso and Dezincification Risk
Brasso contains ammonium hydroxide. Ammonia is a substance that can cause stress corrosion cracking and may contribute to dezincification in susceptible brasses, particularly the common CuZn30 alloy used in many applications, including musical instruments.….this from a quick AI search.

Dezincification is a common concern in treatment of brass objects in museums, visually it can result in pink coloration as the alloy surface moves to a higher relative copper content.
That is correct.
Season cracking - Wikipedia

Cleaning cymbals with Brasso is the worst.
 

Attachments

Cleaning cymbals with Brasso is the worst.
Is it? There is quite a bit of discussion on these drum forums. One can draw their own conclusions from it.

For my purposes it does me fine, but then all my older instruments with brass patina where lacquer is gone are not museum pieces. Plus, I don't use the stuff but maybe once every couple years or longer.
 
Would be interesting to see the results of those fifteen and seventeen year old posts. Those who didn’t heed the warnings not to use the product.
If they are still alive. >:)

Both you and I know that when one uses chemicals and abrasives, the good stuff is of course dangerous or damaging if not used properly, and thus used relatively sparingly. There is a place, time, and amount to use. The trick is to know when and how to use it, when not to, and when to stop using it.
drill screws are great and convenient, but they also can easily circumvent the protective 1/16 inch thick (1.6 mm) thick steel nailer plates used in house construction to protect plastic sheathed electrical wiring passing through wood studs and electrical conduit pipe in commercial construction. (Idea of the nailer plate was a barrier, so when a carpenter was nailing, the plate stopped him cold to warn him not to nail any further.)

There are the consumer grade rust removers, but overall, a fav of mine has been so diluted by the manufacturer over the years to make it safer, that it no longer does the job it did back in the 1960's.

Muriatic acid does a great job in quickly removing rust from steel or iron, but it can do its share of damage if one is not careful, plus, one must used extra caution in handling due to its potential health dangers. I soaked a heavily rusted and pitted steel motorcycle package rack in it. But it had sufficient rust spots throughout that ruining the chrome wasn't a concern. I primed and painted it black and re-installed it.
 
Is it? There is quite a bit of discussion on these drum forums. One can draw their own conclusions from it.

For my purposes it does me fine, but then all my older instruments with brass patina where lacquer is gone are not museum pieces. Plus, I don't use the stuff but maybe once every couple years or longer.
There might be discussion, but I used to deal in vintage cymbals for well over a decade, was on about 3 or 4 cymbal/drummer chat boards...nobody in my day there suggested using Brasso on cymbals, it was usually discouraged.

BTW - Cymbals are Bronze, not Brass...those are two different alloys altogether...only the cheapest student cymbals are brass alloy.

There are a good half dozen cymbal cleaners that are better than Brasso. I DO BELIEVE people Brasso their cymbals, but anyone who researches cymbal cleaners just for 10 minutes will find a far more appropriate product.
 
Are suggesting Alka-Selzer as a brass cleaning solution??????

(Sorry, leaving now…)
You’re not far off, Steve. We used to use “bug juice” in the navy for cleaning verdigris-laden brass pipes, fittings, etc. It is a non-branded commercial-grade alternative for Kool-Aid. I don’t recall many people that actually drank the stuff.
 
You’re not far off, Steve. We used to use “bug juice” in the navy for cleaning verdigris-laden brass pipes, fittings, etc. It is a non-branded commercial-grade alternative for Kool-Aid. I don’t recall many people that actually drank the stuff.
Haha, what happened behind closed doors stays behind closed doors... commenting for a friend
 
Brasso and Dezincification Risk
Brasso contains ammonium hydroxide. Ammonia is a substance that can cause stress corrosion cracking and may contribute to dezincification in susceptible brasses, particularly the common CuZn30 alloy used in many applications, including musical instruments.….this from a quick AI search.

Dezincification is a common concern in treatment of brass objects in museums, visually it can result in pink coloration as the alloy surface moves to a higher relative copper content.
Stress corrosion cracking? Seriously? In a saxophone?

NOPE. Let's get a grip, and stop using AI garbage to spread fear and uncertainty. While Brasso may be a coarser abrasive than desired for that mirror finish on your saxophone, you WILL NOT induce stress corrosion cracking in a saxophone if you give it a polish with Brasso.
 
Sorry, us ramen eaters don't ever see the good stuff. 😉
As a sorrta non-sequitir....surely you have heard of this Selmer, France Myth.....

"their saxes were SO great post-ww2 because the metal they used was actually melted down from church bells of churches which had been destroyed during the war"

I wish I had made that up (I don't actually, I never would have, it's too asinine ) but this was/is a story floating around for far too long.

Churchbells.... are typically B20 bronze....most decent cymbals are B20 bronze, and have been since like, forever....although some were introduced since the 70's of different alloys - B8 for student cymbals, B10, B12, B15 some others. The % indicating the percentage of tin in the tin-copper mix.

Brass, as we know....is copper + zinc......

Try making a sax body out of true Bronze...see what'll happen. It would be a disaster. (Nobody get me going on the sax mfr's today who call the body metal on some models "bronze"...just don't. Because it isn't really....)
 
You’re not far off, Steve. We used to use “bug juice” in the navy for cleaning verdigris-laden brass pipes, fittings, etc. It is a non-branded commercial-grade alternative for Kool-Aid. I don’t recall many people that actually drank the stuff.
I ingested enough of that at summer music camp for 3 seasons....😵
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,057
Messages
578,198
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom