Reeds Is it okay to use a strength 3 reed as an absolute beginner?

videoandfideo

New Member
Messages
1
Location
US
I hear every beginner should play 2.5 or less, but the I only have access to 3s right now. Is it still okay for me to start learning with these or should I just buy the lower ones?
 
Solution
A firmer reed will help one to attain the notes in the upper register,
Yes it can but I'd be wary of relying on a hard reed to do this. I used to do that but now rely on embouchure to be able to get those notes with a soft reed. The plus side to that is you have more flexibility over the whole range, hard reeds can cause problems with pianissimo low notes in my experience.

As mentioned I went from 4 down to 2 or 2.5 and those are plenty hard enough for me after many many years as a pro.

Hard reeds can be good for some people, just saying that it's not necessary to think as you progress you play harder reeds
It might be OK if you can okay every note if the instrument quietly, but it might cause bad habits that could be very difficult to break. You need to ask a good teacher.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
What Pete says! With perhaps a nuance related to the type of sax you play and the mouthpiece.

I think 3 feels harder on alto than on tenor for the same kind of mouthpiece tip opening.

I never really managed 3s on alto while it was fine on tenor. That was with classical mouthpieces like Vandoren AL3 or T20/25.

I would get 2.5 if I were you. IMHO.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I’m biased because I like to use as soft a reed as possible as I think it is good to train your embouchure to be able to play soft reeds effectively. I find I can be more versatile although maybe that is less important for a beginner.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
You could try to soften the reeds you have perhaps by simple methods such as flexing it for a couple of minutes or while on the mouthpiece pushing it in a a few times with your thumb.
Or you can start doing more drastic treatments such as sanding or shaving it down.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
If you don’t have any prior experience with reed instruments, starting on hard reeds is a very bad idea and will not only be far more difficult, but also create very bad habits. I imagine your horn was quite expensive, so why is the cost of a few reeds a big deal?
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Using #3 reeds as a starting player is not a good idea. Your embouchure muscles in your mouth need to be developed. Like in any weight lifting activity to build physical strength, you start off with lighter weights and lower repititions. As your embouchure muscle gain strength and your playing duration increases without tiring, over time you can increase the strength of the reed.

Otherwise, a harder reed will cause your embouchure muscles to tire more quickly. The tendency then is to make up for this by biting down on the reed, which then can cut the inside of your lower lip with your teeth.

It is more important for you to be able to obtain a good tone first. A firmer reed will help one to attain the notes in the upper register, but as a beginner, you will not be playing in that range. That will come later.

Personally I would start out with #1.5 to #2. Buy a good reed clipper. If reed is too soft, end can be trimmed to increase its strength.

Also, I would avoid buying the Internet auction bargain reeds from the Far East. In general, reputable on-line and brick & mortar stores prescreen what they sell, buy from them. Out of curiosity, I have bought some of those bargain reeds and the quality was inconsistent and in some cases bad enough that I threw away most of the reeds in a box.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
A firmer reed will help one to attain the notes in the upper register,
Yes it can but I'd be wary of relying on a hard reed to do this. I used to do that but now rely on embouchure to be able to get those notes with a soft reed. The plus side to that is you have more flexibility over the whole range, hard reeds can cause problems with pianissimo low notes in my experience.

As mentioned I went from 4 down to 2 or 2.5 and those are plenty hard enough for me after many many years as a pro.

Hard reeds can be good for some people, just saying that it's not necessary to think as you progress you play harder reeds
 
Vote:
Upvote 1
Solution
I had worked my way up to a 3.5 and enjoyed the sound it created until one day at our rehearsal, my mouth suddenly felt like I had sucked on a lemon after playing for an hour or so. After some very sage advice from the forum, I went back down to a 2.5 and now I'm even using the 2.0's again. If you are looking to experiment, perhaps it could be with different brands (Vandoren vs. Rico, for example) and/or types (American vs. French) to see if that makes any difference.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Yes it can but I'd be wary of relying on a hard reed to do this. I used to do that but now rely on embouchure to be able to get those notes with a soft reed. The plus side to that is you have more flexibility over the whole range, hard reeds can cause problems with pianissimo low notes in my experience.

As mentioned I went from 4 down to 2 or 2.5 and those are plenty hard enough for me after many many years as a pro.

Hard reeds can be good for some people, just saying that it's not necessary to think as you progress you play harder reeds

This I understand, Pete, and quite frankly, I am using softer reeds on my bari's, because of the mouthpieces I am using with wider tip gaps, #2's. I have no problems hitting falsetto as well as the bottom end.

However, there seems to be a smaller number who insist on using harder reeds. I gather that they are probably using mouthpieces with a narrower tip gap. More power to them. I am definitely not using #3's on any of my saxes nor clarinets, but that is due to the mouthpieces I am using.

And, a problem with communication in a forum versus in person is that one obtains further feedback up front to clarify what the true issue is. Writing does sometime leaves to interpretation, which at times I have seen taken a direction that wasn't ever the intent of the one with a question or the one in reply.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Remember, we're talking about absolute beginners here on closed mouthpieces, not experienced players on open mouthpieces. All beginners, assuming they've never played a reed instrument before, start with zero embouchure strength and zero control. A soft reed is critical for success at this stage. No matter how extraordinary or musically talented you might be, muscle strength and the associated control take some amount of time to develop in all human beings. There is no way to shortcut this due to our biology.

With a hard reed, a beginner will naturally use the strongest muscle they've got, the jaw, in order to make the reed speak. However, this is the wrong muscle to use in the long run and results in never developing an embouchure. Once you develop embouchure strength and control, you can then move up to stiffer reeds (or down) for better tone, volume and response as desired, using whatever strength works best for you and your equipment, whether that's a 1.5 or a 5. But as a novice, start soft like everybody else has for hundreds of years.

I'm very glad the OP asked since many self taught beginners will unwittingly go down the wrong path. In another forum post I read recently, a novice alto sax player was having issues with the low end response. Turns out he was using a clarinet mouthpiece on his sax. So I always encourage beginners to seek advice when in doubt.
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0
How is that even possible? :confused2:
I was as shocked as you, but I just tried it, and it is possible to jam a clarinet mouthpiece onto the very end of an alto sax neck. The person who did this saw a picture of a sax (among other woodwinds) on the box and clicked the buy button, apparently without reading the description.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
If possible, it is always better to have an experienced tutor help the beginner along. There was a certain amount of tutelage from my school instructors, but it was a burley Navy Chief Lani (he played Bari in the staff band) who really helped me along on Clarinet as my private instructor at the US Naval School of Music in the early 1970's.

How is that even possible? :confused2:

I suppose regarding mouthpieces, anything is possible. :banana:

View: https://youtu.be/1I8xmT2FNfU?t=49


My apologies, @lydian . 🙂 You have a valid point, life is too short without some humour. :thumbs:
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
There was a certain amount of tutelage from my school instructors, but it was a burley Navy Chief Lani (he played Bari in the staff band) who really helped me along on Clarinet as my private instructor at the US Naval School of Music in the early 1970's.
Navy! Don't say another word. At sea you have to make do with anything you have. I was not in the Navy, but my dad was and I've been sailing enough to get an idea of what it takes... 😉 😛
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Navy! Don't say another word. At sea you have to make do with anything you have. I was not in the Navy, but my dad was and I've been sailing enough to get an idea of what it takes... 😉 😛
In this case, I have to. 😉 I was in the shallow water component called Army. :rofl: However in Hawaii (was a member of the "Army Band of the Pacific", tough job but someone has to do it) 😎 we played ceremonies once a month for the Navy. A Skipjack class submarine with all hands on deck from its WESTPAC cruise would come to dock with Navy top brass in dress whites, wives and children in the bleachers, and an Army Band in khaki uniforms playing Anchors Aweigh. :clapping:
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,574
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom