videoandfideo
New Member
- Messages
- 1
- Location
- US
I hear every beginner should play 2.5 or less, but the I only have access to 3s right now. Is it still okay for me to start learning with these or should I just buy the lower ones?
Yes it can but I'd be wary of relying on a hard reed to do this. I used to do that but now rely on embouchure to be able to get those notes with a soft reed. The plus side to that is you have more flexibility over the whole range, hard reeds can cause problems with pianissimo low notes in my experience.A firmer reed will help one to attain the notes in the upper register,
Yes it can but I'd be wary of relying on a hard reed to do this. I used to do that but now rely on embouchure to be able to get those notes with a soft reed. The plus side to that is you have more flexibility over the whole range, hard reeds can cause problems with pianissimo low notes in my experience.A firmer reed will help one to attain the notes in the upper register,
Yes it can but I'd be wary of relying on a hard reed to do this. I used to do that but now rely on embouchure to be able to get those notes with a soft reed. The plus side to that is you have more flexibility over the whole range, hard reeds can cause problems with pianissimo low notes in my experience.
As mentioned I went from 4 down to 2 or 2.5 and those are plenty hard enough for me after many many years as a pro.
Hard reeds can be good for some people, just saying that it's not necessary to think as you progress you play harder reeds
I was as shocked as you, but I just tried it, and it is possible to jam a clarinet mouthpiece onto the very end of an alto sax neck. The person who did this saw a picture of a sax (among other woodwinds) on the box and clicked the buy button, apparently without reading the description.How is that even possible?![]()
How is that even possible?![]()

It’s very possible. I knew a great soprano player who used a clarinet mouthpiece.How is that even possible?![]()
Navy! Don't say another word. At sea you have to make do with anything you have. I was not in the Navy, but my dad was and I've been sailing enough to get an idea of what it takes... 😉 😛There was a certain amount of tutelage from my school instructors, but it was a burley Navy Chief Lani (he played Bari in the staff band) who really helped me along on Clarinet as my private instructor at the US Naval School of Music in the early 1970's.
I can see that possibly working ok. But this was a soprano clarinet mouthpiece on an alto sax.It’s very possible. I knew a great soprano player who used a clarinet mouthpiece.
In this case, I have to. 😉 I was in the shallow water component called Army.Navy! Don't say another word. At sea you have to make do with anything you have. I was not in the Navy, but my dad was and I've been sailing enough to get an idea of what it takes... 😉 😛
However in Hawaii (was a member of the "Army Band of the Pacific", tough job but someone has to do it) 😎 we played ceremonies once a month for the Navy. A Skipjack class submarine with all hands on deck from its WESTPAC cruise would come to dock with Navy top brass in dress whites, wives and children in the bleachers, and an Army Band in khaki uniforms playing Anchors Aweigh. 
