Saxophone beginners Is it normal

I will forever remember the positive words that my first teacher often used to say to us:

"Animals! You are all animals!!! That B was supposed to be bloody flat! Check the key signature, animals!"

But this was the old school....
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The same happens to me every week, I practice my "homework" and when I play in the next lesson lesson I find it's nowhere near as good as it was at home...it's just been nervous playing in front of someone, I still do after 4 years of learning!
 
IMHO and IME a teacher should NEVER criticize you - if they do, get rid of them.
I don't ever feel humbled by my teacher, she is wonderful at getting me to change or try something different without ever telling me that what I did was wrong.
As I always say to my husband when I get back from my lesson - another lesson of ego-boosting - I always come back from my lessons on cloud 9.


I agree Mandy but just to clarify it is not my tutor criticizing at all, he is great and very patient the problem lies in me.

Jx
 
I agree Mandy but just to clarify it is not my tutor criticizing at all, he is great and very patient the problem lies in me.

Jx
Don't be self deprecating.

As a form of self punishment for my previous posts, I have been practicing Giant Steps on alto.
 
I always praise the positive and then add at the end how they can improve the bits that went wrong, but I
never use the words wrong, I'll just say something along the lines of "this can sound more dynamic if you....." etc
 
Maybe he was teaching biology at the same time.

Multi-disciplinary

I find positive thinking disgusting.
If someone tells me "interesting solo" I think that maybe they don't like it but they must be positive.

I prefer "your solo was ****!" "why?" "because on the 5th bar the B was supposed to be flat!"

Then i can decide if the B was natural on purpose or if I simply plaid the wrong notes.

Criticism makes you improve.
 
Whether people like it straight or not is not the point, people react better to encouragement than discouragement, some "teachers" regret that corporal punishment is banned, unless it is being paid for. >:)

If a teacher leaves a client with so little self confidence that they are depressed, they should be struck off. Unfortunately anyone can list themselves as a music teacher for adults, might be an idea to have to have them undergo training before being allowed to call themselves Music Teachers.

The aim of coaching and modern teaching techniques, is to guide the client into making the correct decisions, as if they own that decision, it is far more convincing than being told it is incorrect.

I admit to having been the World's best and worst teacher in my speciality but coaching made me think of how best to help my clients, rather than considering them as revenue sources.
 
or makes you want to slit your wrists!

It depends on how it is worded and how the student copes with that.
IME daily criticism of ther negative kind will never make you want to improve, it will just erode your self confidence to the point that you wonder why you bother breathing.

Some teachers are unfortunately failed musicians;
do you want to leave them sad and lonely in their misery or can you allow them to perpetuate the breed?
 
As in the old saying:
Those that can, do; those that can't, teach.
Which should wind up a few people.

Actually in my life I found excellent teachers that were not incredible musicians.
Teaching should be a pleasure and for me it is, if not I encourage the student to find a different teacher.
If teaching is a frustrated second choice, the teacher is usually bad.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,679
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom