Tech/maintenance Invisible leak. Tech can't find anything, but sax fails vacuum test

And yes, we can argue how to determine flatness, whether it is an absolute, and the degree to which pad compliance accommodates an imperfect tonehole.
Not really. The standard and most relevant test is to place a flat standard over the tonehole and see whether or not the rim deviates from it. Nothing much to argue about.
Pad compliance will tolerate quite a significant discrepancy...just not for very long.
 
Not really. The standard and most relevant test is to place a flat standard over the tonehole and see whether or not the rim deviates from it. Nothing much to argue about.
Pad compliance will tolerate quite a significant discrepancy...just not for very long.
I beg to differ.
There is always something to argue about. When is a flat not a flat? Is it concave or convex that makes more of a difference? Do you have to be able to rock your flat standard on the tone hole to determine a deviation from flatness? And what would Twiggy say?

And that pad compliance. Ach .... it sounds like Prince, er, sorry, King Charles speaking
 
I beg to differ.
There is always something to argue about. When is a flat not a flat? Is it concave or convex that makes more of a difference? Do you have to be able to rock your flat standard on the tone hole to determine a deviation from flatness? And what would Twiggy say?

And that pad compliance. Ach .... it sounds like Prince, er, sorry, King Charles speaking
Sure, you can argue about it - but what's the point? There used to be a chap on SOTW who was always comparing the precision of watchmaking with that of sax repair...at least until I pointed out that a sax was not a watch. Hence 'most relevant test'.
My own set of flat standards are probably way over-specced given that they're lapped. The precision afforded by a lathe or a mill would be plenty sufficient...but it's just nice to have posh tools.

Concave/convex makes no difference - it's the deviation from the highest point that counts.
And no, no need to rock the standard - a leaklight placed under it will show any deviation...though rocking the standard can be useful in determining the profile of a high spot in the finishing stages of levelling.
 
Damage around the the Eb rolled tonehole ...... I can't level rolled toneholes (not skilled enough) ...... just replaced the Eb pad and built up the with shellack .... and ready to make more noise on blues and rock jam!

Pad compliance will tolerate quite a significant discrepancy...just not for very long.
Yes, that's why I have to replace the Eb often? Rolled toneholes and hard thin pads is IMO not a good combo.

Here is two pictures of the sax before the diffucult Eb pad replacement operation (a Dörfler & Jörka stencil with rolled toneholes). Very visable leak?
D&Jett.JPG

D&Jtva.JPG
 
Damage around the the Eb rolled tonehole ...... I can't level rolled toneholes (not skilled enough) ...... just replaced the Eb pad and built up the with shellack .... and ready to make more noise on blues and rock jam!


Yes, that's why I have to replace the Eb often? Rolled toneholes and hard thin pads is IMO not a good combo.
Yep, if the tonehole isn't level, you're asking the pad to take up the discrepancies - and the firmer the pad, the less accommodating it's likely to be.
 
Sure, you can argue about it - but what's the point? There used to be a chap on SOTW who was always comparing the precision of watchmaking with that of sax repair...at least until I pointed out that a sax was not a watch. Hence 'most relevant test'.
My own set of flat standards are probably way over-specced given that they're lapped. The precision afforded by a lathe or a mill would be plenty sufficient...but it's just nice to have posh tools.

Concave/convex makes no difference - it's the deviation from the highest point that counts.
And no, no need to rock the standard - a leaklight placed under it will show any deviation...though rocking the standard can be useful in determining the profile of a high spot in the finishing stages of levelling.
Hey, I was just playing the Cafe / SOTW game: No good argument goes unpunished 🙂
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,679
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom