Tech/maintenance Invisible leak. Tech can't find anything, but sax fails vacuum test

We have had discussions about "porous" pad coverings in the past and seem to have different opinions based upon our personal experiences. I don't want to rehash past arguments, but I believe Stephen was referring to air leaking under a resonator and out through the edge of the pad rather than going through the pad material itself. I have been playing on white roos in my SBA alto for over 20 years, and I have done several overhauls for some of the top players in my area with chocolate roos who were pleased with the sound and response. I have posted this recording before at the Cafe, and I am doing so again in this thread as evidence of why I don't believe white roo pads produce a "stuffy" or "muffled" sound. However, I am open to the idea that players with different tonal concepts and playing styles may have a different opinion.

View: https://soundcloud.com/jbtsax/ballade-alfred-reed-stereo?si=0b26553674084173bdedb5f641591570&utm_source=clipboard&utm_medium=text&utm_campaign=social_sharing
Yeah Stephen was referring to a leak through a rivet out the edge of the pad. Although I’m not sure why are you included a comment about Roo pads ? Yeah occasionally pads are porous.
 
Yep, I was. While pad porosity may be an issue, it'd be unlikely to result in the symptoms described.
A pertinent anecdote...
Did a tonehole job on a Keilwerth SX90R last week. Levelled all the toneholes and reset the pads.
Client played it - sounded wonderful. Then he got out his old 10M and sounded just as good.
While he was packing the Keilwerth away I took the opportunity to shove a leaklight down the 10M. It was worse than the SX90R was when it came in. But you wouldn't know it from listening to him playing.
 
Yep, I was. While pad porosity may be an issue, it'd be unlikely to result in the symptoms described.
A pertinent anecdote...
Did a tonehole job on a Keilwerth SX90R last week. Levelled all the toneholes and reset the pads.
Client played it - sounded wonderful. Then he got out his old 10M and sounded just as good.
While he was packing the Keilwerth away I took the opportunity to shove a leaklight down the 10M. It was worse than the SX90R was when it came in. But you wouldn't know it from listening to him playing.
That's why I love playing vintage horns (shhh, don't tell anybody!)
 
BTW, given the amount of leakage, I can't really see how a rivet leak could be responsible for the leak and it wouldn't cause a hissing noise either because the felt would dampen it.

Hissing noises are typically caused by cracks between hard surfaces.
Candidates are:

Disintegrated solder connections on soldered tone holes (probably n/a but manufacturer says they're soldered-on tonehole rings) or a crack in a drawn chimney or a bad solder job on the tonehole rings.

Neck tenon leak or a crack in the solder of the neck to the tenon.

Octave pip leak

Body-bow-bell connections (already checked??)

As @Dr G said, identifying the range where the stuffiness starts may give some good insights into the location of the leak but it is not necessarily conclusive, the lower register notes below D may be caused by a leak as far up as the body octave pip where every higher note still plays relatively okayish.

My suspicion is the rolled toneholes, they are notorious for not sealing properly, or else a bad solder between the ring and the tonehole chimney. Clear nail polish will permanently fix any such hair fissures.

But just get a second person to help and a stethoscope and it should not take more than a minute or two to find the problem area.
 
I just started to work on a stencil tenor saxophone, comparable to a Dearman new super. It has the name of a former local music store in Zeeland engraved in a open area on the bell. The engraving style of the name is different from the rest of the engraving.

As an illustration how bad a saxophone with rolled toneholes can leak that shows no leakages with light:

When using a thin sensor most pads are leaking. Still the saxophone is playable. All the pads have to be replaced. besides leaking the last tech didn't remove old glue in the key cups. Old and new glue together formed a sticky material that didn't solidify.

It sounds like a B&F, not to bad.
 
I just started to work on a stencil tenor saxophone, comparable to a Dearman new super. It has the name of a former local music store in Zeeland engraved in a open area on the bell. The engraving style of the name is different from the rest of the engraving.

As an illustration how bad a saxophone with rolled toneholes can leak that shows no leakages with light:

Is this issue the tone holes or the pads?

When using a thin sensor most pads are leaking. Still the saxophone is playable. All the pads have to be replaced. besides leaking the last tech didn't remove old glue in the key cups. Old and new glue together formed a sticky material that didn't solidify.

Ewwwww…
 
This was the toffee variant.
What flavor do you get mixing hot melt and tape ? This is new Eb mix to me.

:headscratch:
7E307C13-7342-4D73-9BE9-BD48C0E8CB56.webp
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Rolled toneholes can be made flat just like regular toneholes. It just takes more skill and time as well as a lot of care and patience. I believe they form an airtight seal with the pad covering sometimes even better that traditional toneholes due to the increased surface area contact. The only way I have found to get a completely accurate test for leaks with a light is in a dark room, with each pad at eye level, and a very light touch on the stack keys. Using a "mechanic's mirror" is helpful to see the back of key cups as well as the front without having to turn the sax around.
 
OK, so why wouldn’t that show with a leak light?
Pressure irregularities don’t always show with a leak light. The leather may be contacting the tone hole but not with enough pressure from the wool/felt behind it to seal the leak. This is where paper feeler gauges come in handy. You can actually feel the contact area pressure with the key closed.
 
Rolled toneholes can be made flat just like regular toneholes. It just takes more skill and time as well as a lot of care and patience. I believe they form an airtight seal with the pad covering sometimes even better that traditional toneholes due to the increased surface area contact. The only way I have found to get a completely accurate test for leaks with a light is in a dark room, with each pad at eye level, and a very light touch on the stack keys. Using a "mechanic's mirror" is helpful to see the back of key cups as well as the front without having to turn the sax around.
Exactly, that's why I use my windowless bathroom, even if it is very confined, along with one of these cheap dental hygiene mirrors. And yes, rolled tone holes are just a different variety that many shy away from because of preconceptions and the need to adjust / learn something different.
 
Pressure irregularities don’t always show with a leak light. The leather may be contacting the tone hole but not with enough pressure from the wool/felt behind it to seal the leak. This is where paper feeler gauges come in handy. You can actually feel the contact area pressure with the key closed.

I agree. I was contesting Woodpad’s statement that is was somehow an issue with rolled toneholes. Regardless of straight or rolled, a tonehole is flat or it is not. And yes, we can argue how to determine flatness, whether it is an absolute, and the degree to which pad compliance accommodates an imperfect tonehole. Bottom line: Rolled toneholes are not the issue (unless you don’t know how to level them).

I just started to work on a stencil tenor saxophone, comparable to a Dearman new super. It has the name of a former local music store in Zeeland engraved in a open area on the bell. The engraving style of the name is different from the rest of the engraving.

As an illustration how bad a saxophone with rolled toneholes can leak that shows no leakages with light:

When using a thin sensor most pads are leaking. Still the saxophone is playable. All the pads have to be replaced. besides leaking the last tech didn't remove old glue in the key cups. Old and new glue together formed a sticky material that didn't solidify.

It sounds like a B&F, not to bad.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,678
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom