Intonation Intonation Trouble Shooting

"Ne0Wolf7, "

Many thanks for the video links neowolf.. Thought provoking and very true.. Im including some of that in my practice. (I would hate to call it a regime BTW) Regards
 
I do seem to be creeping a bit sharper when tunes vs long tones
Yep, tension will do that, plus the fact that you've got more to think about. And when you start improvising, it gets even worse 🙂. Makes hearing a really good player all the more impressive. It's a long but interesting journey.
 
What apps (can’t afford to even think about a real ‘drone box’ or whatever they’re called) do people recommend? @jbtsax , @GCinCT

I use an app called "Real Tanpura". It uses digitized, high fidelity recordings of an actual tanpura. I really like it, because the tanpura produces rich overtones along with its fundamental. I close my eyes as I practice. I use the exercise recommended by @jbtsax, that of playing a scale over a single pitch.
 
Great advice here. Unless you use autotune you will never have a perfect needle on a sax.

..thats no excuse for always playing out of tune since that would suck...but music has movement and momentum, A needle cant interpret that.

Practice in ways described and record yourself with some backing tracks and listen.

Ears are what count...players 80 years ago didnt have a needle...that did not stop them and its likely that most of them did not have perfect pitch.
 
Great advice here. Unless you use autotune you will never have a perfect needle on a sax.

..thats no excuse for always playing out of tune since that would suck...but music has movement and momentum, A needle cant interpret that.

Practice in ways described and record yourself with some backing tracks and listen.

Ears are what count...players 80 years ago didnt have a needle...that did not stop them and its likely that most of them did not have perfect pitch.
Perfect pitch is not a godsend. Perfect pitch to what scale of measurement?
 
A friend told me about this tuning app that is only available for i phones, and I have found it quite useful. It is called AP Tuner and can be downloaded from the App Store. It allows you to play scales on your instrument and then shows you a graph of the pitch of each note you played. It is an excellent tool to "map" the intonation tendencies of your particular instrument so you know which notes you have to adjust and how much to bring them in tune. I don't recommend it as a tuner, but as a way to "learn" your instrument. I did this quick screen shot playing a C scale on my electronic piano to save myself the embarrassment of showing all of you how out of tune my playing is after not practicing for several weeks. 😵

tuning ap.webp
 
I have close enough pitch. It seems to work at its most critical when listening to other players 😉
The best and most useable sort. A friend of mine couldn't play a gig once because the piano wasn't A440. It was in tune with itself though and we all tuned down to it but his perfect pitch was a hindrance.
 
Perfect pitch is a strange thing.

My piano tuner told me he had a customer whose perfect pitch had "gone flat" and he had to tune her piano to her personal idea of A. If must be horrible to have the whole world sound out of tune except your own piano.

There are levels of it though. I was once at a jazz gig with a classical flute player who was starting to get interested in jazz. The band played Round Midnight and he commented that Ebm is an unusual key for jazz. I said "Oh, Have you got perfect pitch". He replied "No, but I was practicing earlier so I can remember". A pitch memory that persists for several hours like that would seem to give you the best of both worlds.
 
There are levels of it though. I was once at a jazz gig with a classical flute player who was starting to get interested in jazz. The band played Round Midnight and he commented that Ebm is an unusual key for jazz. I said "Oh, Have you got perfect pitch". He replied "No, but I was practicing earlier so I can remember". A pitch memory that persists for several hours like that would seem to give you the best of both worlds.
I have always thought perfect pitch is based on memory as opposed to any kind of "golden" or sensitive ears.

Sound Engineers ideally have both very sensitive ears as well as good memory - ie they need to be able to memorize what 4kHz sound like etc.

I believe I have often not had great intonation, although if I have Radio 4 on, and I hear the announcer say off down to Ambridge, I can start singing the Archers theme in the right key before it comes on the radio.
 
...
I believe I have often not had great intonation, although if I have Radio 4 on, and I hear the announcer say off down to Ambridge, I can start singing the Archers theme in the right key before it comes on the radio.

I just tried that. Sang it then went to you tube to find it. I got it right. Wow! I didn't know i could do that..
 
I have always thought perfect pitch is based on memory as opposed to any kind of "golden" or sensitive ears.

Sound Engineers ideally have both very sensitive ears as well as good memory - ie they need to be able to memorize what 4kHz sound like etc.

I believe I have often not had great intonation, although if I have Radio 4 on, and I hear the announcer say off down to Ambridge, I can start singing the Archers theme in the right key before it comes on the radio.
Yes I have this pitch memory too, but it isn’t perfect pitch.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,384
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom