This is a really interesting thread! So many personal experiences and insights!
I don't personally suffer from 'Imposter Syndroom'. I naturally get nervous when joining a new band (can I play to their level?, can I learn their repertoire? can I play this section/ solo?). Which all boils down to 'can I meet their expectations of me'?
But after a while (weeks - and usually months), when I realize that I'm 'accepted' as a band member, even though there are tunes/sections that I can't yet play - and wonder if I ever will! - the fact that I'm 'accepted' always gives me a sense of relief. In the sense that other members implicitly say "OK, you're a newbie and you need to learn a lot. But we have confidence that you'll get there eventually. And we'll give you all the time you need to learn."
I'm also 'lucky' that my level of ambition for playing sax is low and I'm lazy. So I do just enough to continue playing reasonably well in my current Big Band. And in my 'new' pop/rock band too. That's not to say that I don't still practice to maintain my playing level and even improve. But my main motivation is (musically and socially) just 'playing in a band' and not being the 'best saxophonist' I could perhaps be. So I don't generally suffer from 'Imposter Syndrome'.
I have no idea whether this is relevant to this thread. 'Imposter Syndrome' is a much more complex topic. It just seems to me that things that might help are:
- avoid taking on 'challenges' that you don't (yet) feel comfortable with, until you are; in other words, avoid taking on steadily increasing 'challenges' (based on your ability) until you feel really comfortable with these.
- take enough time to (emotionally and mentally) let the positive feedback from your performances/rehearsals really sink in; as a counterweight to your internal feelings of 'not being good enough' or 'could have been better'
- see a psychotherapist to work out together how your internal 'negative' thoughts/feelings of 'being an imposter' relate to the external 'positive' affirmations of your talents and skills; there may not be a 'cure', but some sessions may give you more insight. Which in turn may help you better 'manage' your feelings of being an imposter.