Playing the saxophone I'm not in the mood

Messages
144
Location
UK
I'm playing second alto in a big band, one of the pieces is in the mood. All should be simple enough.

I'm struggling with the main bit:

1701269357614.webp


We play it quite fast, and I can't play it cleanly even at slower tempos. The first part is the worse, slurring down from the D to F, it's glitchy and if I speed it up the F has a tendency to stay the octave up. I get in a horrible mess with my fingers falling over each other.

This has been on my music stand for longer than I care to mention. I've tried: Playing it really slow, slowly increasing tempo, practicing the hard transitions (D to F and back over and over), tried using the side key for D instead (awkward) and skipping the octave key and voicing the D up the octave. I'm still too slow and too messy.

Does anyone have any additional tips, or suggestions.

Thanks,

Richard
 
Solution
Play the D with the palm D and no octave key. If this pushes your hand too far out of position, either your hand position isn't right or you need to add a riser to that key (common).

Second four, play the Bb with bis.

Third four, you probably just have to flip fingers, but you might be able to make that E with the palm F (but probably will be too flat even at speed).
Play the D with the palm D and no octave key. If this pushes your hand too far out of position, either your hand position isn't right or you need to add a riser to that key (common).

Second four, play the Bb with bis.

Third four, you probably just have to flip fingers, but you might be able to make that E with the palm F (but probably will be too flat even at speed).
 
Vote:
Upvote 1
Solution
We were taught as kids that a slur mark means “no tongue”. In the real world and in cases like this, I would take that with a grain or two of salt. Just very lightly touch the reed on the F’s, like saying “la” instead of “ta”. You don’t actually stop the sound, just touch the tip of the reed.

Recently Jamie Anderson (Get Your Sax Together) has done a bunch of videos on phrasing and tongueing, and talks a lot about “half tongue” as a way to dampen notes. This is similar, except you don’t leave the tongue on the reed, just touch it enough to get the note to speak.

[EDIT] - using palm D is another option, but this is flat on alto. I have used the Eb palm key with the A key as a substitute, which may work in this case. (Like fingering C + the Eb palm key.) But you still have to get to the F cleanly, so you may still need to lightly brush the reed with your tongue.
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0
Ensure that you're parsing the phrasing by each set of three notes ascending to the accented note. To get from the top of each three back down to the next set of three, you have to drop your jaw a little. To be honest, despite how the sluring is indicated, I'd separate each at the accent mark. 3 + 3 + 3 + 3. Because it's a third higher, the lead alto part is easier since the drop doesn't descend as low and quite possibly the jaw drop may not be necessary. For practice, it might help if you played the lead alto part for each figure before dropping down and attempting to play the second alto part.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
We were taught as kids that a slur mark means “no tongue”. In the real world and in cases like this, I would take that with a grain or two of salt. Just very lightly touch the reed on the F’s, like saying “la” instead of “ta”. You don’t actually stop the sound, just touch the tip of the reed.
+1
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Assuming your horn is in working order, just practice the D to the lower F.
Super slow, half notes at 50bpm, and relax your mouth a wee bit when you drop down.
Make sure your mind is hearing what you want to play.
Do it hundreds of times so your fingers get under control along with your mouth and breath support.
Nice to have an accomplished player help you at a lesson or.....
Met an Alto sax player, older than me, blowing his horn outside the Miami VA hospital. He was making the same mistake over and over, so I gave him a quick lesson.
Will take my mouthpiece/reeds with me on my next visit to make sure his horn is tight.
Always carry a fife and harp.

Slow is smooth and smooth is fast. 😎
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
...using palm D is another option, but this is flat on alto. ...
Depends on the alto, mine is pretty much spot on. I played lead in a professional band for about 15 years and did all the cutoffs - so I learned left hand only fingerings for a lot of notes. On my alto D and Eb are just fine, you have to use all three left hand keys to get E.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
measures 8-16- play the whole thing in the lower register using palm key D only, and bis key for Bb.
measure 17- play the whole thing with the octave key down, and use bell keys Bb and C.

not without its challenges (tuning, timbre) but not insurmountable, depending on your chops and setup. Yes i also find dealing with those jumps from a high to low note one of the trickiest things to pull off.

(also, get your horn double checked for leaks!)

good luck!
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Just had a try. I had difficulty voicing the D. My embouchure and ear expect a C. Strange harmony. F6 or an inverted Dm7. I don't hear that in any other arrangement.
Sadistic or dyslexic arranger?
Play a C and see who notices 😉
Well, I just pulled the original Joe Garland stock out of the stash and the second alto part is exactly as shown in the OP. It looks like it's just a re-typesetting of the old stock that we've all played a zillion times.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Great solution provide the lead alto player is happy swapping parts, and you feel confident enough to lead the section.
And don't forget, in the Miller era, the lead player really LED the section. Are you prepared to do that? Do you have a lead alto mentality?

(I once subbed on lead in one band - can't remember the details, but I think it was one where the lead player was kind of unsatisfactory - and the director came up to me afterward and said "now THAT'S how a lead player plays! You understand what it is!" All those decades of listening to the Basie and Ellington and such bands, I guess)
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,430
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom