Jazz I Should Care. Looking for favourite rendition

I thought you where looking for a duet between Hawk and Benny Carter on tenor (in the first post of this thread)?

In the latest post you're mentioning a duet between Hawk and Ben Webster.
My memories were muddled up with the duet and my first album. I had many albums within this genre and others too. I had completely forgotten about the first album. It's a huge reveal and a big deal to me.

When your a strong willed independent minded youth. You don't want to bow to peer pressure or to be caught-up in some musical genre trap (picking one genre as superior over all others). When your thirsty for a bit of everything, young and inexperienced in life. You only know how to consume and put things aside for later consumption without making any contingencies for their preservation. A youth digests one thing, has its fill, burps and then goes off on a tangent exploring another musical rabbit hole. It forgets about what was left behind. The folly of youth. How much stuff do we have that's subconsciously tucked away within the depths of our minds? Stuff that can get triggered by any of our fives senses and the mind. A smell, a taste, a visual cue, a partial sound clip, an emotional stimulus, a thought, etc. You never know when and what will activate and unlock a neurological memory vault. As you age these memories become more and more fuddy duddy. As you journey through life's vicissitudes. Situations make greedy demands on your memory. Our memories are physiologically finite. Their not infinite wells of well organised data like some singularity hard drive ( Think physics. Think black holes ). It's messy. Things get displaced to make room for more memory space. Please appreciate this was over two and half decades ago. One experiences and forgets a lot over a time period of this length. Memories get mixed up. Sometimes it takes whole lot of interconnected, distantly related, memory triggers to retrieve a memory stubbornly clinging to the depths of your mind. Even then it can become blurred and reveal completely new unrelated memories that you had forgotten about entirely.

The CD arrived today (Friday 15th). It's not that duet but my FIRST album in this genre of music. Don't you think that's significant?

I want to fully absorb the experience and reveal the album to rhysonsax in this post when I've recovered from a roll-a-coaster flood of emotional memories that this has triggered. Because of rhysonsax's love for this music genre, he will understand what it means to find a piece of music that feels like a long lost friend that you've completely forgotten about and finally found again through sheer serendipity. It was an important time in the past. I'm extremely grateful to rhysonsax for keeping this thread alive, rallying together wonderful people like yourself and offering leads that indirectly lead to the discovery of this FIRST album which is just as important as that duet. This genre is a massive arena full of many gold nuggets. These here, are just of two them. Important to me because of the sentimental value in addition to being great peices of music.

Please allow me some time and thank you for your help in the search. It's very much appreciated.
 
This thread has introduced me to a new jazz standard and several excellent recordings.

Whilst waiting for the big reveal, maybe the rest of us could run a sweepstake of how many of the original five clues turn out to be right:
  • Song = I Should Care
  • Two tenor saxophone recording
  • Artist 1 = Coleman Hawkins
  • Artist 2 = Benny Carter
  • LP sleeve has watercolour picture of two tenor saxophonists in action
Rhys
Its not the DUET but my FIRST album in this genre. I assumed the duet would be part of this FIRST album. 25 years is a long time, rhysonsax.

I'm super excited about it. I want to upload scanned copies of the CD Front, CD back and information booklet inside it. Is it okay from a copyright perspective to do this? I don't want the good people hosting this forum site to incur any copyright issues. Album info:

TITLE: Coleman Hawkins - Ben Webster - Benny Carter. Three Great Swing Saxophones
CD no: ND90405
COMPANY: 1989 BMG MUsic.

The LP Sleeve is a water color picture of all three of them holding saxophones.

Tracks 1 - 8 Coleman Hawkins
Tracks 9 - 15 Ben Webster
Tracks 16 - 22 Benny Carter

The first track by Coleman Hawkins is ONE HOUR ( If I Could Be With You One Hour Tonight )

One of your YT leads got me to two versions of ONE HOUR (1929 and 1952). YT Links below.

Upon hearing them they sent goosebumps through me. I couldn't understand why because the title didn't match up with 'I should care' or variations on it like 'I could care' so jumped to conclusion that 'I Could Be' in If I Could Be With You One Hour Tonight had to be that duet. I assumed it was just my muddled up memory. Wanted to make sure when it arrived.
It wasn't the duet. I had by sheer serendipity discovered my FIRST album in genre. It was a VERY happy accident. Did I commit a crime?

So using this new song title (If I Could Be With You One Hour Tonight) resulted in no album matches on YT or search engine. I did an image search and found images of Three Great Swing Saxophones. The image triggered a memory response and lead to a vendor that deals only with online purchases. The last in stock. How lucky was I?

Coleman Hawkins - If I Could Be With You One Hour Tonight (1929)
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5rZXI5M5-R0


Coleman Hawkins - If I Could Be With You (One Hour Tonight) (1952)
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QRYTBgWaeLY


A very special thanks to you rhynsonsax.
 
Thanks to everyone who contributed to the search.

I will find that Duet album myself. Whether its an single LP or Album. Whether its hawk and carter or someone else. Whether it's a water colour or not. Whether it has the words 'I should care' or 'I could care' or some other words. I would rather not be treated like a criminal because the fog of time has caused me to forget the specifics of that amazing duet.

It's got to be out there somewhere. You people have gone above and beyond my expectations. There is no need to continue the search further.

Many, many thanks to all of you! Wish you the best in life.
 
Thanks for the extra clarifications @TenorVibes and no worries about memories mixing up.

I know how strong the love for ones first steps into a new musical genre can be. I started listening to jazz on my own (without the input of others) at a very young age in the early 70's. We had in those times some fantastic Dutch radio programs handling the complete history of jazz music and I was lucky to catch the start of that and got introduced to all stuff from the 20's and further on. That triggered my love for especially the big toned tenor sax players of the early times, like Coleman Hawkins and Ben Webster (and later-on others).

That listening experience also triggered me bying jazz records (LP's in those times) and my first one (bought in the late 70's) was 'Ben Webster and Friends', having Ben, Hawk and Budd Johnson on tenor and Roy Eldridge on trumpet (recorded in 1959). That's still one of the best albums ever for me, so I know how strong those early experiences can be and feel, even many years later.

So enjoy your further search and please keep us informed. 🙂
 
mrpeebee

Thank you for your understanding. I'm going to leave it to serendipity. There have been many new discoveries made during this search. There will be many more made as search for more gems ensues.

At this moment in my sax development journey listening to all genre has become an important part of study and practice. There is a lot to be learnt from prominent artists of this era. Not just saxophonists but bassists, clarinetists, pianists, trombonists, trumpeters, all instrumentalist involved in these works of art.

It's no longer just a passive leisurely exercise for pleasure but one for learning and study. It would be very useful if a more senior and experienced member of this community could, if possible, start a separate thread to archive these works. It would be a meaningful and constructive endeavour for the benefit of all here and future new members. For pleasure and study.

Lets move away from this thread and take some of these gems with us into that new thread.

Another artist I admired was Art Tatum. What an amazing pianist.
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4pFAEbJwKjE

​

 
That sounds like a good idea TenorVibes. 🙂

But it's a very wide topic, so posting a thread on a forum can result in a chaotic overview without being historically accurate.

A good starting point can be to watch the TV documentaries about 'Jazz' made by Ken Burns in 2001:

Some of those episodes can be watched free-of-charge on YouTube:

Good luck with your further search. 🙂
 
I transcribed one of Julie London's vocals last year and was amazed at how accurate her pitch was, unlike some other singers I have tried to transcribe. That was also with the guitar of Barney Kessel who provided very sensitive accompaniment to the vocal.

Since then I have found that a guitarist on YouTube has been posting his transcriptions of the guitar line and also providing the PDF (TAB and notation) free of charge. He has done I Should Care:
View: https://youtu.be/sdKnK2VDWok?si=ROodtNt3O5PL8I9O


Rhys
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,438
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom