Saxophones I found this really interesting

I love knocking their socks off with my startone baritone and then watching their face when I tell them what I paid for it.

With anything manufactured, the expense is in the details. The details may make only a small difference but it is there.

In the world of motor racing, taking a standard road bike and blueprinting the engine and tweaking the suspension, will cost many man hours and on a hack round the lake District on a Sunday afternoon may not make a noticeable difference, but on the track a second can be the difference between a win and no points.

It all depends on the situation. If the whole ensemble has that little extra something, you'll need it too. If you're playing with your friends in the pub, then not so much.
 
This is why I have been playing a relatively cheap baritone although I could afford a more expensive one. Seems to sound just as good but without the status.
Me too. I like playing bari, but don't play it all that often, and I struggled with the idea of spending a lot on a bari. I play tenor most days, so it was easier to justify spending quite a lot more for a nice tenor compared to a cheapy.
 
Is £825 cheap? The Bettersax alto is not $650 as shown in the video (maybe this was a launch price), if you consider the YAS 280 sells at £890 in the same store, is the Bettersax such a good buy?
It may be just me, but that is already a significant investment in a musical instrument, compared to say the cost of a guitar or a bass.
The £6K solid silver/gold plated/rhodium glazed, engraved to death, etc. instrument is just an "over and above" what a professional instrument should be: the "basic" pro features will all be there are several £Ks below that price.
From my experience, there is a huge difference between an "inexpensive" saxophone and a professional level one, so far the only exception (IMO) would be the Yamaha base models (in keywork feel, not tone!).
Good point. I just assumed that when it was stated it was $650, it cost $650, not $899/£829 For that money, if I was buying new, I'd take a Yamaha YAS280 for a little more.

If the salesman if 38% out on the price, it casts doubt on the credibility of his other claims. It's a bit off to run marketing on the basis of extravagant loss-leader prices rather than the real price.
 
it is based on seeing the instrument and comparing with one I could have bought at that price from what I think may be the same factory

I should add that this does go against what I have said in the past, that just because two instruments look identical does not mean they are made in the same factory or to the same standards.

This is often because they are made to a common template which I believe happens a lot both in China and Taiwan so can indeed look identical but made with different quality materials and different skill level and tolerances. But I think sometimes there may be some small detail that does imply the same exact place of origin.

Even so the factory costs in China are often quite consistent across factories/agents and the examples I mentioned above would still have huge mark up given that the instruments being of Chinese origin.

But again I must emphasise there can be some added value if the importer does a set up or adds something as happened with the sadly discontinued bauhaus which in some cases some keywork was actually replaced with better fitting tubes or rods as opposed to just being set up.
 
When I was hoping to produce a "Cafe" Saxophone - a project scuppered by Brexit and Covid - I was discussing with two intermediaries (one in UK one in Europe) who would help with the importing of instruments and/or parts. The plan was to provide a boutique instrument whose basic parts were made in China or Taiwan but with some considerable custom design to be fitted either at factory or in the EU.

Note before you ask these were business dealings that never came to fruition and I don't feel comfortable discussing the details of who they are.

Looking at a couple of factories, what they did according to their usual methods and QC was great, but we also needed to be confident that was the same with the custom parts of the design. They may have worked out better (and even less expensive) if made in Europe and added afterwards. That's because we know the factories are good at what they are used to doing every day, and although they can also provide custom stuff, they may be less able to offer competitive price and QC may be an unknown on those aspects.

Long story short we may have ended up with a body of a saxophone made in China (the higher end not the £100 or £200 end) but also with a lot of work that differentiated it from your typical import either at source or in the EU.

You also take a huge risk when importing because if something is not up to par, you may then be in an argument with a supplier who does not speak English and is not prepared to take a return and accept your proof of what was wrong.

All of that must be factored into your business model along with recouping research and development, shipping, insurance, stock costs, final QC, and enough profit to make it all worthwhile.

For those reasons a "Cafe" saxophone would probably have cost more than a Yamaha student model, but we could have done a more standard one with fewer custom bits and pieces. Along with a deluxe one with special, engraving and the carbon fibre rework I was considering. I hadn't got as far as thinking whether there may be different models but the same body - it requires some skilful hype (and honesty) to tell people they all sound the same, e.g. this one has a swivelly neck tenon and that one has French springs.
 
Last edited:
For me it's important to buy a sax is contributing to a better world. So I judge a sax from where, how and who is manufacturing the saxes. I've just owned one sax made in PRC. But when I was young I played/owned saxes made in East-Germany and Czechoslovakia. I didn't care so much back then.

I play saxes that I've bought used. Less money for interesting and good saxes.

To make new saxes in Europe is no big problem: You need a dedicated leader, money and knowhow/-ledge. Skånegripen (UMI, Nogales, King, Conn Armstrong) could be a new manufacture in Scandinavia?

We talk about reteurnpolicy on another place on CS. I just buy books, CD, T-shirts, socks ...... on- line. Today some of the returned stuff goes to a country in EU. So an on-line bought sax can be returned to another company? It's important for me to know who I make business with.
 
There are many experienced and accomplished players who are well qualified to judge a saxophone on it's looks, it's feel, it's tone and intonation. Theirs are superficial reviews at best. To understand the meaning of that comment, one only needs to read several reviews of saxophones on Stephen Howard's website. Saxophone Reviews
I don't think that's fair to say. Feel, tone, and intonation might be the 3 most important elements for a player. I appreciate that a player might not have a mechanical understanding, but that shouldn't render their opinion superficial. (or maybe I misinterpreted your comment... 🙂 )
 
I don't think that's fair to say. Feel, tone, and intonation might be the 3 most important elements for a player. I appreciate that a player might not have a mechanical understanding, but that shouldn't render their opinion superficial.
Feel and tone are subjective as is intonation (up to a point) so I’d say somewhat superficial in that subjectivity is not so useful in a review.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,672
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom