I found the tonguing instruction quite interesting. I have never hear anyone advocate using the underside of the tongue at the tip to contact the reed.
I would think this is true for most players.
As someone who never even thought about doing it this way, as it's so counter-intuitive, I thought I'd give it a go. What can I say - I'm always open to new ideas.
🙂
Hmm...
I guess if it works for you then it works for you (the royal
you) but I found it a horrible way to tongue. It felt slow and laborious, plus the underside of the tongue is much more sensitive than the top, which made it physically uncomfortable, too.
As someone who has different levels of tongued attack (I guess like most people), I found this impossible using this technique. In very simple terms, some phrases I play are all
Ta Ta Ta while others are
Ta-Dah - I found this impossible with this technique.
I tried this technique on a couple of songs that I play with my R&B band as they have phrases that must be tongued solidly: Take Me To The River
(Al Green), (Hold On) I'm Coming
(Sam & Dave) and Big Bird
(Eddie Floyd).
Compared to the 'normal' way of doing it, I found using the underside to be incredibly hard work for, what for me at least, was a vastly inferior effect.
Although I couldn't put this technique through a live show, I have found that at the end of two and a half hours of playing at volume with a raucous band, your embouchure can get really tired and your tonguing can get a little less controlled that leads to your tongue hitting the reed edge rather harder than you planned when playing faster passages. This can be uncomfortable when it's the top of your tongue - I don't really want to think what it would feel like using the underside.
I'm wondering if I've misunderstood the video because, quite honestly, using the underside of your tongue makes no sense to me (theoretically or in practice) and the claim that using the 'normal' tonguing technique creates a 'thuddy' sound is simply wrong.