Playing the saxophone How to tongue

Maybe I quoted Eric wrong and he said "Sound produced when the tongue leaves the reed." I understood what I meant to say, but apparently didn't say it 🙂
That makes more sense. Yes sound is produced when the tongue leaves the reed. To make that sound staccato you have to subsequently put the tongue back on the reed. I saw an Eric Marienthal video on tonguing and can understand why people would be a bit confused. I'm sure he said that the tongue is placed to create the staccto (shortness of note or space following the note) but it wasn't totally clear.

I can't imagine any teacher actually saying that staccato is produced by the tongue leaving the reed as opposed to being placed on the reed.
 
Not to beat yourself up @apinter - nor your original teacher either - if I have a mouthpiece stuck in my face, I can't say "ta-da" without my tongue making contact with the mouthpiece/reed - maybe you have a roomy jaw, or maybe you only had a tiny bit of mouthpiece in on your early/first lesson. Never too late for the uncomfortable truth.
btw flute and brass players don't have anything protruding into their mouths, so have to make do....
And:
ps please somebody more authoritative than me make the "turn the garden hose/tap on first" analogy re preparing airstream before sounding a note - I found it v helpful.
 
I can't imagine any teacher actually saying that staccato is produced by the tongue leaving the reed as opposed to being placed on the reed.
I understood with no confusion that the sound of staccato note is produced when the reed can vibrate, the tongue no longer stopping it. In his lesson on muted tonguing, I found it very confusing to close half the reed. I admit to not practicing that one.

I have to keep going back to the lesson. He compared tonguing to the brake of a car.

"The sound of the note is not the sound of your tongue hitting the reed, it's the opposite, it's the sound of the tongue releasing the reed, allowing it to vibrate, and then 'BAM!', you put that break right back on."

Perfectly clear; I obviously paraphrased that poorly or maybe backwards.

Apologies to @apinter et al.
 
Not to beat yourself up @apinter - ps please somebody more authoritative than me make the "turn the garden hose/tap on first" analogy re preparing airstream before sounding a note - I found it v helpful.
I used to use this analogy a lot in teaching. It’s to make sure that the air is not let go and that the reed will vibrate as soon as your tongue releases it. My analogy includes having your thumb over the end of the hose pipe. The tap is always on, therefore releasing the thumb has an instant jet of water at the pressure that the tap is opened to. This is opposed to turning the tap off and then on again. Pressure ie air support is ready and waiting.
 
The tap is always on, therefore releasing the thumb has an instant jet of water at the pressure that the tap is opened to. This is opposed to turning the tap off and then on again. Pressure ie air support is ready and waiting.
Yes, I also like the tap analogy, it's what I tell people. You think of that water pressure as air from your lungs. and the tongue is a tap/valve at the end.

So if you think of a graden hose water pressure is suppied at pne end by a tap from the water main which is aon to supply pressure into the hose.

At the other end you have put your thumb over to stop the water. Releasing your thumb causes the pressurised water out. Putting it back on stops the flow.

So this is like your tongue action, it is a negative causing a positive - take tongue away - sound starts. And all the time there is constant pressure from your lungs.

But the other ways to stop the flow would be to

  • Stand on the hose - analogous to pinching the supply off with your throat - not so good
  • Turn off the mains tap to stop the flow into the hose -analogous to dropping the air pressure in your lungs - also not so good.
 
@zungwang

To be honest, I don’t know how I did but I took more mouthpiece before than now, in my first attempts to tongue well.

The thing is not as tragic as I thought, after a couple of hours I am beginning to not think where to place my tongue and how to move it, which absorbed at first all my power to play anything.

I’ll for sure will have to exercise on articulation to get back some fluidity. At this first day my biggest problem is the tone, totally changed, I guess for the internal shape of mouth. I liked my old one much better... Sooner or later I’ll do better. Maybe I myst also learn ti get more mouthpiece without messing with new position of tongue.

On the good side. I start the notes better (sometimes) and my sense to be in rhythm seems to be safer, maybe.
 
Having said all of this about “correct” technique, there are always exceptions, but they really are just this, exceptions.
Most people that attain a good “amateur “ standard will have parts of their technique that are “incorrect” but they have become very good at it. On one occasion I inherited a student and I could tell that something was not quite right with their tonguing. He’d not been picked up on it before so didn’t realise the problem and diagnosis was difficult as their “poor” technique was very good - almost good enough, but it wasn’t. Trouble was that it was maxed-out, that technique wasn’t going to ever sound ultra clean , certainly not for all types of articulation - so it had to be re-worked.
Problems with tonguing, air support and embouchure/throat/voicing will show up on everything whether slow or fast. Finger problems don’t always show up in certain pieces, phrases, keys etc.
 
I found the tonguing instruction quite interesting. I have never hear anyone advocate using the underside of the tongue at the tip to contact the reed.

I would think this is true for most players.

As someone who never even thought about doing it this way, as it's so counter-intuitive, I thought I'd give it a go. What can I say - I'm always open to new ideas. 🙂

Hmm...

I guess if it works for you then it works for you (the royal you) but I found it a horrible way to tongue. It felt slow and laborious, plus the underside of the tongue is much more sensitive than the top, which made it physically uncomfortable, too.

As someone who has different levels of tongued attack (I guess like most people), I found this impossible using this technique. In very simple terms, some phrases I play are all Ta Ta Ta while others are Ta-Dah - I found this impossible with this technique.

I tried this technique on a couple of songs that I play with my R&B band as they have phrases that must be tongued solidly: Take Me To The River (Al Green), (Hold On) I'm Coming (Sam & Dave) and Big Bird (Eddie Floyd).

tongue.webp


Compared to the 'normal' way of doing it, I found using the underside to be incredibly hard work for, what for me at least, was a vastly inferior effect.

Although I couldn't put this technique through a live show, I have found that at the end of two and a half hours of playing at volume with a raucous band, your embouchure can get really tired and your tonguing can get a little less controlled that leads to your tongue hitting the reed edge rather harder than you planned when playing faster passages. This can be uncomfortable when it's the top of your tongue - I don't really want to think what it would feel like using the underside.

I'm wondering if I've misunderstood the video because, quite honestly, using the underside of your tongue makes no sense to me (theoretically or in practice) and the claim that using the 'normal' tonguing technique creates a 'thuddy' sound is simply wrong.
 
As somebody who is changing his tonguing right in this moment, I can say that every new approach is incredibly hard and laborious 🙂.

Past tonguing, for how wrong it was, always will seem more natural.

What seem to work best for me in right tonguing is tongue under the reed and touch the bottom end of reed with the part immediately after the tip. To touch with tip I seem to have more contorsions to do.
 
I can't offer any expertise, but I favour very slightly the bottom edge of the tip of my tongue on the tip of the reed. I can also tongue quite comfortably with the top of the tip of my tongue against the end of the reed. That's about as good a description as I can go with my particular not very trained technique. I tend to take very little mouthpiece, which seems to suit my gob (and tone concept) quite well
No doubt there are text book answers and technically correct approaches and techniques that are more likely to achieve the best results and right or wrong ways and some variations in between. If only we could see inside the mouths of the greats to see what's going on (actually, on second thoughts)..
 
As somebody who is changing his tonguing right in this moment, I can say that every new approach is incredibly hard and laborious 🙂.

Past tonguing, for how wrong it was, always will seem more natural.

What seem to work best for me in right tonguing is tongue under the reed and touch the bottom end of reed with the part immediately after the tip. To touch with tip I seem to have more contorsions to do.
The only thing I can say is that it won’t feel natural, because it isn’t. Because of the mouthpiece being in your mouth your tongue can’t be where it naturally wants to be at the front of your mouth, it has to fold somewhat. Try talking with the tongue moved back, it isn’t normal.
Tonguing and embouchure changes typically take 1-3 months. Occasionally people nail it a lot quicker but the longer you’ve been playing the harder it will no doubt be. You can’t evaluate your old technique to a new one based upon a few hours or days, you commit to making an improvement and that takes time and diligent practice.
 
Last edited:
What seem to work best for me in right tonguing is tongue under the reed and touch the bottom end of reed with the part immediately after the tip.
I also do it this way. It feels comfortable and natural and I can articulate in any way that I need to. I take quite a bit of mouthpiece. It gives me a big sound and I'm so used to it, I have better control.
 
I can't offer any expertise, but I favour very slightly the bottom edge of the tip of my tongue on the tip of the reed. I can also tongue quite comfortably with the top of the tip of my tongue against the end of the reed. That's about as good a description as I can go with my particular not very trained technique. I tend to take very little mouthpiece, which seems to suit my gob (and tone concept) quite well
No doubt there are text book answers and technically correct approaches and techniques that are more likely to achieve the best results and right or wrong ways and some variations in between. If only we could see inside the mouths of the greats to see what's going on (actually, on second thoughts)..
The point about the tip of the tongue used - upper tip, tip or lower tip just needs to feel relaxed. The most relaxed position is correct as the tongue, muscle as it is, works best when relaxed and this is also helped by not drawing the tongue too far back from the reed when going back and forth.
Too far from the reed will result in a slower action (further to travel) and also a heavier action which is undesirable as it could result in audible contact with the reed.
 
The only thing I can say is that it won’t feel natural, because it isn’t. Because of the mouthpiece being in your mouth your tongue can’t be where it naturally wants to be at the front of your mouth, it has to fold somewhat. Try talking with the tongue moved back, it isn’t normal.
Tonguing and embouchure changes typically take 1-3 months. Occasionally people nail it a lot quicker but the longer you’ve been playing the harder it will no doubt be. You can’t evaluate your old technique to a new one based upon a few hours or days, you commit to making an improvement and that takes time and diligent practice.

Of course.
I just said that something wrong and not natural you did for long, seems to be more natural at beginning than the right thing.

I try as much as I can to forget the old, not even use to compare, because I want to speed the process.

It is tough. I sound squeekier and it costs me a lot of effort. Maybe (not sure) I also raised my pitch (probably for the tension). 10 minutes became long.

On the other end, all goes much better than yesterday. I can actually doing it and play something

I’d like the speed of transition would keep up this pace!
 
Yes, I also like the tap analogy, it's what I tell people. You think of that water pressure as air from your lungs. and the tongue is a tap/valve at the end.

So if you think of a graden hose water pressure is suppied at pne end by a tap from the water main which is on to supply pressure into the hose.

At the other end you have put your thumb over to stop the water. Releasing your thumb causes the pressurised water out. Putting it back on stops the flow.

So this is like your tongue action, it is a negative causing a positive - take tongue away - sound starts. And all the time there is constant pressure from your lungs.

I agree. One of the methods I use to convey to beginning players the concept and feeling of blowing with constant air pressure while the tongue stops and starts the flow is to imitate a "rainbird sprinkler" saying tst tst tst tst. I don't know if they have those in the UK, but it is a rotating nozzle that turns about 180° which doubles the speed of the "spurts" as it reverses direction.

1579880085652.png
 
Last edited:
I agree. One of the methods I use to convey to beginning players the concept and feeling of blowing with constant air pressure while the tongue stops and starts the flow is to imitate a "rainbird sprinkler" saying tst tst tst tst. I don't know if they have those in the UK, but it is a rotating nozzle that turns about 180° which doubles the speed of the "spurts" as it reverses direction.

View attachment 13983

Great analogy.
I am using it to understand a little bit better what to do now.
 
I have found this thread very instructive - for years I have been tonguing as the flautists do, but the comments above prompted me to try tonguing the reed itself. What a revelation! I now have an additional sound available to me. Well worth renewing my Cafe subscription next week.
 
While we are discussing the different ways to tongue, a technique used a lot by jazz players to "ghost" or muffle notes in order to make the top note of a phrase stand out more is sometimes called "half tonguing". You can read a description and hear a demonstration done by the cafe's "Chief of Stuff" here: Saxophone Dooden Tonguing

If you listen carefully to the "double time" figures in Charlie Parker's solos you will hear this used a lot.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,673
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom