When we say "to play in tune" or "to play out of tune" is it just the pitch/tone height we are talking about? "To play in tune" does it involve timbre as well? I often heard that I play out of tune (sharp) but most of times I'm plyed in tune , had the right pitch/tone height.
"To play in tune"; right pitch/toneheight and with a suitable timbre that we need? They complained about my tone/sound when I was trying to play in a more "jazzy" way on my King Super 20 w a Berg Larsen ss 130/0 (high baffle). With blues and rock (horn section) bands there were less complains. And to be the only horn player I the didn't complain about my sound/tone.
Jimmy Vaughn about his brother; to play with Steve it was like the tuning on an old radio. The green staples (tuning) were almost conneted to each other. SRV tuned down his guitar .. the pitch was there but differnt timbre?
"To play in tune"; right pitch/toneheight and with a suitable timbre that we need? They complained about my tone/sound when I was trying to play in a more "jazzy" way on my King Super 20 w a Berg Larsen ss 130/0 (high baffle). With blues and rock (horn section) bands there were less complains. And to be the only horn player I the didn't complain about my sound/tone.
Jimmy Vaughn about his brother; to play with Steve it was like the tuning on an old radio. The green staples (tuning) were almost conneted to each other. SRV tuned down his guitar .. the pitch was there but differnt timbre?

Out of tune is out of tune, no "if", "and", or "but". Even listening to the pros play on various videos and when live, they played in tune.