Playing the saxophone How to play the saxophone in tune in hot (or cold) weather

When we say "to play in tune" or "to play out of tune" is it just the pitch/tone height we are talking about? "To play in tune" does it involve timbre as well? I often heard that I play out of tune (sharp) but most of times I'm plyed in tune , had the right pitch/tone height.

"To play in tune"; right pitch/toneheight and with a suitable timbre that we need? They complained about my tone/sound when I was trying to play in a more "jazzy" way on my King Super 20 w a Berg Larsen ss 130/0 (high baffle). With blues and rock (horn section) bands there were less complains. And to be the only horn player I the didn't complain about my sound/tone.

Jimmy Vaughn about his brother; to play with Steve it was like the tuning on an old radio. The green staples (tuning) were almost conneted to each other. SRV tuned down his guitar .. the pitch was there but differnt timbre?
 
Good news. Let’s hope AI latches on to the right answer when the search engines crawl this thread 😳
If @Pete Thomas would let me edit my old posts, I would fix them. But alas, that is impossible. Luckily, very few people give a hoot about bass saxes, so it's not the end of the world considering all the other false information on the internets.

As for playing in freezing weather, the Mummers here in n the US do it all the time and apparently manage a lot better than I do. The saving grace is everyone else is out of tune as well.
 
When we say "to play in tune" or "to play out of tune" is it just the pitch/tone height we are talking about? "To play in tune" does it involve timbre as well? I often heard that I play out of tune (sharp) but most of times I'm plyed in tune , had the right pitch/tone height.

"To play in tune"; right pitch/toneheight and with a suitable timbre that we need? They complained about my tone/sound when I was trying to play in a more "jazzy" way on my King Super 20 w a Berg Larsen ss 130/0 (high baffle). With blues and rock (horn section) bands there were less complains. And to be the only horn player I the didn't complain about my sound/tone.

Jimmy Vaughn about his brother; to play with Steve it was like the tuning on an old radio. The green staples (tuning) were almost conneted to each other. SRV tuned down his guitar .. the pitch was there but differnt timbre?
I dunno. It seems IMO some folk make a simple issue complex. Perhaps a few in the band did not like your timbre coming from your tenor (?) sax? Perhaps they preferred a more mellow (tenor) sound, but interpreted it by mistake as your tuning?

50 years ago, our relatively young stage band leader sergeant made what I considered to be an odd statement. He wanted the trumpets to tune sharp. Somehow he thought doing such would help them cut through better. So we sat there in rehearsal, while the trumpeters moved their tuning slide in.

If it were say, to change trumpet mouthpieces to a different size cup for a brighter timbre, that I would understand. (But I am a woodwind player, what do I know?) :confused: Out of tune is out of tune, no "if", "and", or "but". Even listening to the pros play on various videos and when live, they played in tune.

(Nothing beats listening to a professional band or orchestra live. I still remember 55 years ago in high school, listening close up in preferred seats to the Honolulu Symphony Orchestra. I don't remember the details, but somehow my band director, Mr. Tamanaha was able to obtain tickets for several of us better players in our rural high school. The performance from their 2 clarinetists was awesome to an 17 year old.)

Maybe a change to a mouthpiece a bit more mellow may quell the complainers?
 
If a person can't hear "in tune" or "out of tune" no amount of explaining can address that.

Some people, with good taste, knowledgeable people, seem to enjoy music that makes my toes curl. Some very experienced players hit strings of notes that I would be embarrassed by. It doesn't seem to affect their or the audiences enjoyment of things.

Some players spend a vast amount of time looking for that elusive "tone" while ignoring accurate pitching.
Then you hear someone with the same ear and if you're lucky, get to play with them and all seems right with the world.

Funny old thing this music thing.
 
Funny old thing this music thing.
I know what you mean. Over time I've latched on to this saying, "Everyone is normal until you get to know them." Some, especially band members, by what they say, you think you just became an adversary to them, but then after the gig, you find what they said how they said isn't what they really meant. Once you get to know them, you can forgive them for their rough or awkward edges.

I've found it is good to have a sense of humour. It difuses situations that sometimes could become heated. I have also learned that sometimes, someone had something happen to them earlier that day or last night, so their reaction toward you wasn't about you but something else. That could explain why you thought you did a fantastic job, but didn't get the reaction you thought you'd get. Perhaps they are sitting there to get away, relax.

Back to music, the best part I have enjoyed is when in a held out chord (sometimes covered with a formata), you happen to have that one "disonant" note in the chord, the one when you hit it just right, balanced with the rest, that catches people's attention, the awesome colour for a moment it presents.

That I call a "feel good" note. :mrcool
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,336
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom