Playing the saxophone How to play the saxophone in tune in hot (or cold) weather

Here's my strategy. I live in Greece and it get quite hot during the summer. I put the sax in the case in an airconditioned environment and I always start to play with the sax being in a normal temperature. After that whatever is going to happen is going to happen.
In cold weather I try the same. I avoid playing a really cold instrument. It gets warmed up high and later low and tuning can be an issue. I try putting it in the back seat of my car with some heating or somewhere... and try to fight the cold while playing. After all our breath heats the instrument. It's so much better to try to maintain a normal temp rather than playing a really cold sax.
 
Hence when it gets warmer the saxophone is sharper.
Just to be clear.
The speed of sound increases with temperature

www.engineeringtoolbox.com/amp/air-speed-sound-d_603.html

speed = wavelength x frequency
The wavelength remains the same, given any change is length of the sax is somewhere between none and insignificant.
So frequency increases, sharper.

It all gets more complicated if there's a temp severe gradient along the horn...
 
What are you doing with your sax to tune your sax to tune A=432 Hz? Some old eurpean saxes can be used to play lower than A=440 Hz but 432 Hz .... .
Long story, and still a matter of much experimenting ...

I did purchase a 1930s G.H. Hüller tenor some time ago which had "870" stamped on it. Apparently that is to say that the upper register was originally tuned to 870 = 435 in the lower register. Which had me hoping that the horn would be comfortably close to 432 ... Not so. The thing was dead-on 440 when played. Not sure why, but I couldn't make out any difference in tuning.

The Hüller was nice, not dissimilar to a 10M in mechanics & sound. (And ergonomics too ....) I sold it on recently.

Still keeping an eye out for any low pitch tenors coming up, but haven't seen any for sale since embarking on this quest.

For the 432 jams, I just hang the mp on the edge of the cork, lip & voice it down as much as I can, and hope for the best. It's not ideal, but it's ok for a sprinkle of special fx.
 
Mr Anecdote again (he's been busy today)> I was doing a gig at the Pizza Express in Soho, famous for its nondescript pizzas, jazz and a very sharp piano back in the day.

A very esteemed guest, none other than tenor player Benny Waters, asked to sit in. I felt very honoured and so we called the tune Stomping at the Savoy which is generally Db. Benny played a beautiful fluid and lyrical solo but gave me a filthy look and reprimanded me afterwards for trying to catch him out by playing it in the key of D.

Then I told him we were actually in Db, just that the piano was closer to D. Oh how we laughed.
 
Did a quick test this morning, tuning the sax to itself (A=440) via overtone matching as suggested by @skeller047.

With the Link, it tuned to itself, but had to pull the mouthpiece out to the limit, just before wobble (and this link is crazy narrow).
The PPT stayed sharp on this admittedly-undersized-for-it cork, no matter where I put it. With quite a bit of length left on the neck, so a thicker cork would fix this, which will be done in the near future.

Then I thought, might as well push the PPT on more and see if I can get closer to A=432 a semi-tone up (didn't mind compressing the cork further as it needed changing anyway). The lower register didn't quite like it, still a bit sharp, and low C and bell keys didn't speak very well, but the upper register was pretty close. None of this is for tuning purists, but for my needs it's worth further experimentation.

This was at 11am and 26 degrees room temperature. I usually keep the tenor on its stand all the time and, after reading the contributions in this thread, will keep it in the case for now to see if that may help.

If anyone has a low pitch sax (of any kind) in their collection or sees one come up, I would love to hear about it.
 
If anyone has a low pitch sax (of any kind) in their collection or sees one come up, I would love to hear about it.
I have never seen a sax that was built/designed to play A = 342 Hz until I found this video. A Borgani Tenor Special Edition Sax 432hz. I have some old CZ, German and French saxes that are playing ok below A=440 Hz (InMO better below 440 hz than over). Not as low as A= 432 Hz. My friend is playing RockSax on American HP saxes. Just small bands with guitar bas and drums and tenorsax. Differnt timbre but the tone height is right.

View: https://youtu.be/zGVY1fXmBmM?feature=shared
 
Last edited:
Self amalgamating tape is a quick fix for different bore mouthpieces.

Not all mouthpieces play on all saxophones. If the horn won't tune to itself, it's not the right mouthpiece. It doesn't matter how boutique, expensive or big name it is, if it won't blow in tune, no amount of faffing will make it a match.

The mouthpiece is the interface between your embouchure and your horn. Embouchures vary as do saxophones. A mouthpiece that suits both is required.
 
I have never seen a sax that was built/designed to play A = 342 Hz until I found this video. A Borgani Tenor Special Edition Sax 432hz. I have some old CZ, German and French saxes that are playing ok below A=440 Hz (InMO better below 440 hz than over). Not as low as A= 432 Hz. My friend is playing RockSax on American HP saxes. Just small bands with guitar bas and drums and tenorsax. Differnt timbre but the tone height is right.

View: https://youtu.be/zGVY1fXmBmM?feature=shared
It just sounds out of tune to me. Annoyingly out of tune.
 
Why would they do that?
I don't know. Perhaps they want to be a part of the small movement that wants to perform and record at a lower pitch. Many years ago opera singers thought they should perform at a lower pitch. Birgit Nilson "La Nilsson" wanted a lower pitch so she could sing/ perform more.
 
So why not just learn to transpose and play in a different key?
Also seems pointless to me since it's a minuscule difference that virtually nobody would ever notice. 432 is only about 30 cents below 440. Given that a half step is 100 cents, that's only about an eighth tone flat. So transposing won't do it. But playing in a cold space would, like going from 25 to 15 C, a warm room to outside on a cool day.
 
I remember Christmas carolling on my Le Blanc Vito clarinet. The Naval School of Music leadership, the Navy side did a walk through the dormitories, recruited those interested (we had a combination of Army, Navy and Marine Corps students) who did not take holiday that December 24th night in early 1970's. We rendezvoused at the school, loaded our flip charts with march size Christmas music. Broke up into teams of about 8 - 10, then they bused us to various locations in the base's family quarters.

It was lightly snowing. One thing I noticed is that my clarinet was extra flat, could not raise pitch by embouchure. The barrel was fine at room temperature, but I did not have an extra shorter barrel. Nonetheless, the residents especially the children appreciated our playing.
 
Really struggling with your measurements here!

By my reckoning a bass should have a tube length of about 260cm. I found a reference which has a sub-contrabass coming in at 674.5cm, and that ought to be about twice as long as a bass, give or take. (There’s obviously some significant discrepancies in those numbers, I freely admit 🤔).

A half-step / semitone / 100 cent change is a 5.9% frequency change, so it’s hard to see how you’d get that from a 0.5% length change. Or even 1.5%, if my tube length is about right.

Plus, of course, moving the mouthpiece that dramatically will almost certainly wreck the intonation, as different notes (lengths to open tonehole) will have different percentage changes.
You're absolutely right. Good catch. I keep a chart and looked at the wavelength of the lowest note column instead of tube length, which is right beside it. It's actually 10', a bit over 3 m. I used the wavelength data to make my low A extension.

But the frequency thing is tricky since it's not linear. Percentages really don't work. Plus, as you know, the tone holes get much larger and farther apart the lower you go. At the top end, a small change in length has a much larger effect on pitch than at the low end. Anyone can easily prove that you can lower the pitch by a half step going from pushing in to the hilt vs hanging off the end, a few cm, yet to add a half step at the end takes at least 10% of the total length.

All I know is that's how much I had to move the mouthpiece to play at each extreme. Still had to do a ton of lipping. So yes, it absolutely wrecked the intonation. But a contract is a contract, and the show must go on. I did the best I could in a bad situation.

The whole point of my post was to show that the absolute worst case scenario was still manageable. So tenor in hot weather shouldn't be so bad. I only move the mouthpiece 1 cm or less in that case.
 
I have never seen a sax that was built/designed to play A = 342 Hz until I found this video. A Borgani Tenor Special Edition Sax 432hz. I have some old CZ, German and French saxes that are playing ok below A=440 Hz (InMO better below 440 hz than over). Not as low as A= 432 Hz. My friend is playing RockSax on American HP saxes. Just small bands with guitar bas and drums and tenorsax. Differnt timbre but the tone height is right.

View: https://youtu.be/zGVY1fXmBmM?feature=shared
Ironically, the intonation on this particular video seems inconsistent while leaning more towards 440, at least according to my tuner app.

Which again solidifies my suspicion that any horn can be tuned to whatever, but in the end that determines only partially what comes out of it. Which again can only mean one thing for my personal tuning quest - back to the shed ...


If anyone has a low pitch sax (of any kind) in their collection or sees one come up, I would love to hear about it.
Oops ... correction: *high pitch


My friend is playing RockSax on American HP saxes. Just small bands with guitar bas and drums and tenorsax. Differnt timbre but the tone height is right.
So his HP saxes play fine in a band that tunes to 440, did I understand that correctly?


Appreciate all the comments.
 
You're absolutely right. Good catch. I keep a chart and looked at the wavelength of the lowest note column instead of tube length, which is right beside it. It's actually 10', a bit over 3 m. I used the wavelength data to make my low A extension.
Good news. Let’s hope AI latches on to the right answer when the search engines crawl this thread 😳
But the frequency thing is tricky since it's not linear. Percentages really don't work. Plus, as you know, the tone holes get much larger and farther apart the lower you go.
Absolutely. The raw theory says each tonehole ought to be 5.9% further from the mouthpiece than the previous one, in geometric rather than arithmetic progression, so 2 holes are 12.1% apart instead of 11.8%, and you get to 100% further after 12 steps - 1.05912=2 - and there’s your octave. Of course, 5.9% of a long tube is longer than 5.9% of a short one, which explains the lower ones being further apart.

But then, as you say, in practice the toneholes need to get bigger, and are influenced by “downstream” ones that might or might not be closed, so the 5.9% isn’t going to be exact.
All I know is that's how much I had to move the mouthpiece to play at each extreme. Still had to do a ton of lipping. So yes, it absolutely wrecked the intonation. But a contract is a contract, and the show must go on. I did the best I could in a bad situation.
Sounds like a complete nightmare - colour me impressed for how you got through it :clapping:
 
So his HP saxes play fine in a band that tunes to 440, did I understand that correctly?
The drummer tuned the drums a little bit differnet. The bass player and guitar are tunning differnt (strings) as well. The HP tenor sax sounds good. When I say good I mean an interesting sound that fit the genre country -soul, -blues, rockabilly ...... Slide guitar and HP sax ...... . Many saxplayers says he is out of tune. I don't think so, it's the timbre that's differnt.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,328
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom