Playing the saxophone How much practice is needed for soprano?

The conversation included the fact that playing very softly on an open mouthpiece makes it more difficult to accurately control intonation.
This is interesting because it makes total sense in one way but begs the question what if you compensated for open mouthpiece by using a softer reed?

We should also consider that an open tip with a short facing is very different to the same tip with a long facing. But for the sake of argument let’s assume medium and I would agree that a wider tip without going down in reed strength can make intonation control more difficult.

But it’s also worth considering that it’s a good idea to use softer reeds. But then there’s another argument I’ve heard that hard reeds make intonation easier/better.

I would dispute that because while it may have some truth if the horn itself is as reasonably in tune as you can expect from a saxophone, if it is a bit quirky then the softer reed (and wide tip) can make it easier to manipulate (lip in) certain notes.
 
Just found a thread about harder reeds for better intonation:

 
Like @Pete Thomas , I vote for softer reeds to play quietly. I can play whisper quiet on my soprano with a 2.5 Rico on a Runyon 8. Lovely sound. Years ago, I played a lot of cocktail bar gigs on soprano, not so much anymore.
 
The conversation included the fact that playing very softly on an open mouthpiece makes it more difficult to accurately control intonation.

Can it be done? Yeah, but it's a lot of work. I tried it one time with my classical quartet (I play tenor). I played an entire rehearsal on my Lamberson J8 (0.120") instead of my usual Morgan 6C (0.090"). It was exhausting.
Yes, it is physically harder to play soft, thanks for confirming.
 
This is interesting because it makes total sense in one way but begs the question what if you compensated for open mouthpiece by using a softer reed?

We should also consider that an open tip with a short facing is very different to the same tip with a long facing. But for the sake of argument let’s assume medium and I would agree that a wider tip without going down in reed strength can make intonation control more difficult.

But it’s also worth considering that it’s a good idea to use softer reeds. But then there’s another argument I’ve heard that hard reeds make intonation easier/better.

I would dispute that because while it may have some truth if the horn itself is as reasonably in tune as you can expect from a saxophone, if it is a bit quirky then the softer reed (and wide tip) can make it easier to manipulate (lip in) certain notes.
If I have a reed that works well, meaning good response, good "tone" and intonation and switch to something else, it'll entail another adjustment period to get the quirks under control. On tenor I don't need a different setup, I can play in whisper mode and stay in tune (yes it is more work) and that was my only point in the beginning. There is this mental misconception that a smaller instrument may inherently play softer and I found the opposite to be the case. That's why, after a few years of "fighting" the soprano in the above mentioned situation I switched to tenor, which makes it just much more enjoyable, for me and the other bandmembers.

And enjoying the playing is, at least for me, an important aspect.
 
But if you can't play from pp to ff, it's either the wrong mp/reed, or lack of skill.
This is true. Besides, what happens when one drops their prized hard rubber mouthpiece and it shatters?

One plays out with their "beginner" mouthpiece in their case.

It is all about control.
 
This is true. Besides, what happens when one drops their prized hard rubber mouthpiece and it shatters?

One plays out with their "beginner" mouthpiece in their case.

It is all about control.
Why not drop the beginner mouthpiece and play the prized HR one? 😉

Choices.

Seriously, tho’. Consider some risk management. If you think there exists a probability that you may drop your mouthpiece, then lessen the possibilities of it falling by putting it on the neck before applying the reed (this is what I do) or mitigate circumstances so it cannot hit the floor. In over 50 years of playing, I have dropped a mouthpiece on the floor exactly once. It was a Morgan 3C and landed on the tip. P.S. HR does not shatter unless extremely cold.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,331
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom