Playing the saxophone How much practice is needed for soprano?

Interesting that you choose that particular player and image, because I would say that Marsalis, in that instance was playing in what I would call a neutral position, neither acute nor straight out but right in between.

Anyway, I think we know what we both mean 🙂.
 
Interesting picture.

ive read that he plays a silver Mk6, and the left little finger table looks like a Mk6, but I see a curve at the top.

anyone know about this? Is it an original Selmer factory thing
 
Actually I never understood that "straight" thing about playing soprano. Very, very few play it with the sax coming straight into your embochoure. Sopranos without a bent neck would not be playable if that would be a prerequisite. If one drops the head sufficiently to blow straight into a non-bent soprano it would significantly restrict the airflow. My own soprano has a bent neck because it is much more comfortable to play without droping my head or holding out the soprano in front of me. A certain angle seems acceptable to me and it my vary from player to player.

Alphorn
 
But I'm not sure I do and as a sop player trying to improve tone and technique more pics would be useful. 🙂

I too thought the sax in the pic above had a curved neck which must make a difference?

Jx

The curved neck does make a difference. It allows the player to put the mouthpiece "straighter" into the mouth without tilting the head down as much, or lifting the bell of the horn as far. I know the Cannonball straight sopranos come with two necks---one straight, and one slightly curved so the player can choose.

Let me expound a bit on the mouthpiece angle. One of the most common poor playing habits I have dealt with as a teacher has been biting/playing too high on the pitch. Tilting the instrument and mouthpiece down has the tendency to use the top teeth as a fulcrum, and the mouthpiece as a lever to force the reed firmly down against the lip over the teeth.

This may seem at first to be a useful shortcut to a firmer embouchure and a more controlled tone, but it comes at a price. In the ideal (Teal) embouchure, the muscles around the mouth put pressure on all sides of the mouthpiece with the lower lip pushing up against the reed. There is the feeling of the jaw pulling down and away from the reed as the bottom lip pushes up to meet it. This results in just a small amount support of the lower lip coming from the jaw and teeth. When one substitutes the "lever" to firm up the embouchure, the ring of muscles around the mouth never develop. The result is a loss of flexibility and tonal control.
 
I do tend agree with David Roach with respect to the angle of the mouthpiece.
My sop has two necks - one straight and one curved. I'm far more comfortable with the curved neck as it relieves the stress on the right hand not having to push the horn out too far as well as putting my right hand into a better position for the right hand keys and keeping it slightly further away from the RH trill keys.
As far as the angle of the mouthpiece is concerned I find it helpful to have a little support from the lower jaw and as I've been playing for nigh on 50 years I'm fairly sure that my embouchure is well enough developed. I play tenor, alto and sop daily and although it varies from day to day it can run to many hours. I can understand jbt recommending the "straighter into the mouth" approach to his students but I do think that a more experienced player will know instinctively what the best angle/positon is.
In fact that little extra support from the lower jaw actually enables me an extra plus on flexibility and tonal control.
However I would concur that the player needs to have a well developed embouchure in order to be able to make that kind of decision.
For what it's worth - I'm by no means an expert and can only relate to my own experience on the subject.
Patience, practice, perseverance, and the passage of time, and all will be well in the end. ;-)
 
But I'm not sure I do and as a sop player trying to improve tone and technique more pics would be useful. 🙂

I too thought the sax in the pic above had a curved neck which must make a difference?

Jx

I think what jbtsax is trying to convey is that a steep angle, a biting embouchure, a clarinet type approach, are not great for the soprano sax and that it's better to flatten the angle a bit; if not right angles, then somewhere in between.

It's about the particular music you are playing and the particular sound you are aiming for. Everyone is different to a degree, and it's free to experiment. In the end practice and a keen ear will guide you to the best approach for the result you desire. I don't think it's useful to change what you are doing unless it's done with care and attention.
 
I wanted to play soprano and got a cheap one off ebay. I could never play it and eventually gave up. I recently got a 'better' one, it's an elkhart 300 series, so not an expensive one, but the shop set it up and it plays quite well. My mouthpiece is a cheap Bari esprit. I got it out today as I've hardly played it since I bought it and found that it was difficult to play with good tone and intonation. I think its going to need a lot of practice! I did a little vid on my ipad so that I can keep a check on my progress. This is the starting point........
View: https://youtu.be/y5wKBEVbN10
 
I play a straight soprano and It goes quite close to perpendicular into my mouth. I believe this is the way it should be.

My head angle therefore is probably pointing down between 25 - 10 degrees.

25 degrees on a session, <10 degrees on a live performance because in that situation I find it important to maintain a lot of eye contact with the audience and/or other band members.
 
My sax coach Monik Nordine, who is a superb sop player has a similar position to what Pete has described, as does John Gross who I had the pleasure of getting to know recently. Check out his stuff online.
 
Lots of advice here. Here's one more: train your hearing because:
1. You can correct the pitch when playing with others.
2. You'll be able to spot an out-of tune note (which needs attention/correction) even when playing for yourself.
There's a lot of ear training software out there for mobile devices. That makes it much easier to squeeze in 10 to 15 minutes of practice per day. It's a horrible task at first because you have no idea where the progress should come from. But it's one of those things that get better by simply doing it. Ear training did me a whole lot of good (I don't get mugged anymore after playing the sop).
 
Back after a long break - 4 kids takes up your time, strangely...

I have found the soprano my natural instrument after starting on alto, and dabbling with the tenor occasionally. I think it depends on the player - some people just seem to suit a different size of horn. I would say do not be put off by some people saying it is the most awkward of the saxes - just try it and see. Go easy on yourself and make sure you play on a decent beginner soprano - the Bauhaus and the John Packer are good - especially the JP 243.

I also agree that the soprano is a different instrument which happens to share the same key work as a sax - a lot of truth in that. On the rare occasion I dust off my alto nowadays I sound awful!

I find mouthpiece choice on the soprano is important - I have recently been experimenting with a couple of mouthpieces with a narrow tip opening, because I play only classical, but I find the sound very disappointing. Very thin and oboe like, no depth. For a fuller sound I think I am now settling on the Beechler hard rubber 7S, having started on the Vandoren V5 S35 - still an excellent piece. Wide tip and soft reeds do it for me. Remember that a wide tip opening on a Soprano is still pretty narrow.

I agree that the curved crook on a straight soprano is much easier to play, and allows for a sling. Angle? See the Branford photo, above.

I read somewhere on the forum once that the really important thing when playing the sax is to have the sound you want to achieve in your head - you will then unconsciously be making all kinds of minute adjustments as you play to reach that sound. I knew that I wanted to sound the exact opposite of Coltrane!

Using a reed trimmer to take 0.5 - 1mm of off the tip of softer reeds also seems to produce a darker fuller sound. Rather than play harder reeds, which I find takes too much effort, I just trim a softer reed.

There - I think that has covered everything!
 
...and here is a relatively rare example of Branford playing classical (well, baroque) on soprano. Have a look at the angle. I think the soprano is so well suited to baroque playing - think of all the famous oboe concertos which could be transposed up a notch - Bach, Marcello etc.

I wish there was longer video, or even better a CD, of this series of concerts with the Chamber Orchestra of Philadelphia, named "Marsalis Well Tempered".

 
I knew that I wanted to sound the exact opposite of Coltrane!
I've often wondered if the Coltrane soprano sound is largely down to the recording set-up. If you stick the most classical of mouthpieces on a sop and then record it with mic pointing up the bell then the sound is going to be less than wonderful. I don't know if that was the case - can anyone here enlighten us?
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,333
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom