Saxophones How many tenors do you need?

One.

I found the one with the best sound and response, then had it overhauled to perfection.

I stopped counting how many tenors I have owned a long time ago. I determined which was best and sold the rest. Selling the last “backup” was perhaps the most difficult because it had been my #1 gigging tenor for almost 10 years.

If you’d asked “How many altos do you need?”, my answer would be “None, because I have a great tenor”.
 
Well, I learned on "vintage" horns (back then, even the top of the line Conn King Martin or Buescher was considered a cheap crappy student horn because it didn't say "Selmer" on it), so all this faffle about "ergonomics" leaves me a bit cold. I just want to say, "get thee to the woodshed and learn to play the thing."

I have only ever intentionally bought a second example of a specific voice - that was when I bought my cheap 16M Mexi-conn tenor wtih the intent of mounting a pickup in the neck - I didn't want to drill a hole in my 10M.

I also bought a second alto kind of by mistake when a friend relocated across country and offered me a screamin' good deal on an old Martin.

And I ended up with two Bb sopranos because I have never liked the Holton Collegiate/Couturier I bought back in the 90s for $100 from the drummer - that thumb ring is awful - and one day I decided to treat myself to a Buescher. The other soprano hasn't been played in 10 years, but it doesn't take up much space in the garage, so I'm not motivated to sell it on.

The whole collecting thing thank goodness never "took" with me. I've pretty much just got one of whatever I own.
 
I just need one. I'm not playing professionally so a YTS 23, 25, 275 or 280 would be more than enough for me. Or an Indiana, Armstrong, Buddy II, Conn 16M ...... . I play Martin Committee tenors. I have 3 + some extra tenors. My saxes didn't cost me so much. And I bought most of the my tenors before the internet hysteria started. Less money back then.
 
I don't think I have a true answer to your question but here is my tenor history. I bought my MKVI in February 1968 at Chuck Levins Washington Music Center when they were still on H street. I have played that horn for the past 55 years and in my mind, I never needed another tenor. I had my Conn Bari (Transitional 1930) overhauled a few years ago and have been loving the sound. Adjusting to the action has been an ongoing process, but I have no problem with it. The Bari's wonderful sound prompted me to purchase a Conn 10M. It's a 1947 that was Uberhauled by Music Medic back in 2006. It was silver-plated during the process so it matches my bari. So now I have two outstanding tenors, and I love playing both of them. If I need to do a classical gig, I will definitely go with the MKVI, but for playing in a big band or doing a small jazz gig, the Conn 10M will get the call.
 
If I need to do a classical gig, I will definitely go with the MKVI, but for playing in a big band or doing a small jazz gig, the Conn 10M will get the call.
You (sort of) confirm my suspicions. I was playing my 10m a couple of days ago, and when I came back in the living room I said to my wife “I don’t understand why they made any other saxes after they made this one. Or why they stopped making this one….”. I added that it might not be so suitable for classical work.
I do understand however that everybody has his/her own preferences, so there must be room for some other flavours …….
 
A response from the OP would be nice.
Come on. Don't be so jumpy. It's only been and a day and a half. As often, everybody steps in and provide interesting feedback really quick. That's great but perhaps the OP is busy with other things... 😉

We all have different backgrounds and history with sax so each one of us can have his own take. If you feel the need to try a modern horn, go for it. Then you'll know if it's what you need or not.

Some are very selective and will keep only one, others can't decide and will have many because they can.

I'm not in a GAS mood right now but there are a few tenors I'd like to try and perhaps own... :rolleyes:
 
and if you did decide you wanted a more modern and ergonomic tenor what would you choose?

I sold my Selmers, King Super 20, Buescher TH&C, Buescher Aristocrat, etc., ad nauseum, ad infinitum, and kept my Borgani Jubilee silver pearl OBT. As mentioned above, I had it overhauled (including new pivots and anything else required to make it mechanically perfect). Total cost was less than any of my Selmers or King, less, in fact, than most new Taiwanese horns.
 
Last edited:
Many thanks to everyone for your comments and suggestions. Its given me plenty to think about. I've been playing since 1984, mostly on old Kings and Conn's. The reason I'm thinking about a more modern sax is pretty much down to ergonomics, I'm having a few orthopaedic problems with my hands and I'm thinking maybe something a little easier to get my fingers around might be a good idea for the future. I've not really had the time and opportunity to try enough modern tenors to be able to make a decision. I did try a Keilwerth, a Yanagisawa, Yamaha 62 and Selmer Ref 36. I thought the Yamaha was brilliant for the price compared to others and I liked the sound of the Ref 36. I think I might do a bit more pondering....
 
Many thanks to everyone for your comments and suggestions. Its given me plenty to think about. I've been playing since 1984, mostly on old Kings and Conn's. The reason I'm thinking about a more modern sax is pretty much down to ergonomics, I'm having a few orthopaedic problems with my hands and I'm thinking maybe something a little easier to get my fingers around might be a good idea for the future. I've not really had the time and opportunity to try enough modern tenors to be able to make a decision. I did try a Keilwerth, a Yanagisawa, Yamaha 62 and Selmer Ref 36. I thought the Yamaha was brilliant for the price compared to others and I liked the sound of the Ref 36. I think I might do a bit more pondering....

I’ve been playing since the 60s, I understand aging hands. A Ref 36 was my #1 tenor for ~10 years - great voice, very responsive, and sufficiently flexible for me to use it in swing bands, contemporary big bands, a R&B tribute band, and a classical quartet. I came to it from a Balanced Action and a short stint on a Serie III. So now Selmer is going to discontinue it.

Ponder on…. 😉
 
Yamahas are very easy players, Keilwerths not so much for me but that probably depends on the size of your hands. Adjusting to the tone, or finding one you like, will be the biggest thing to deal with I would think if you are coming from Conns and Kings but I’ve played Kings for over 20 years and I’m sure that I could find a modern horn that suited if needs be, there are lots to try but I find the Super20 similar to modern horns, easy players really, while Zephyrs are more of a challenge, and earlier Kings would be very difficult, so it depends upon what you’ve played to date.
 
Last edited:
I'm gradually whittling down my "collection"; I've only got five tenors now - 2 Pierrets, Conn Chu, Lewin (Martin Handcraft), and my very first (high pitch) John Grey. I just sold my 10M. When I was younger I played modern machinery like Selmer Mk VI and Super 80, but for the blast 28 years just vintage horns. If I did buy a modern tenor it would be a s/h Yamaha YTS23 - they're cheap, easy to play and in tune.
 
Did you mean to say that? I like it! :thumb:

@farina_man - what was it made you sell the 10M? I guess it had the highest value and if one of the others played just as well for you it would be the logical choice perhaps. But might you regret it?
Freudian slip? I've played the Pierret Vibrator for so long it's like an extension of my arm! The 10M is a great horn, and I'd always wanted one, but after I got it I still liked the Pierret better, followed by the Lewin (which is my second choice horn) then the Chu which, of course, doesn't get used much, so I think that will be the next one to go - especially as I only have a very few gigs this year! In the circumstances someone else might as well enjoy the 10M and I can spend the dosh on groceries and heat!
 
I have somehow ended up with three tenors; 10m, NWII and an SX90R. I don't play the Keilwerth much but part of me feels like it's almost a necessity to have a modern horn.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,577
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom