Playing the saxophone How important is it to blend in a section?

Thanks, Pete. If balance is right and phrasing is tight, then blend is less of a thing. I’d still rather have the guy with the Mindy Abair mouthpiece/Silverstein ligature/sterling silver Yanagisawa on lead alto rather than the second book. Yes, we really had a sub with such a setup.
 
Blend (for me) means sounding appropriate in any circumstance whether it's playing harmonies with a cello, a duet with guitar, or playing lead with a piano trio, etc. I never play with other saxes yet wish to use appropriate tone, phrasing and feeling when playing with any other instrument. The desire on my part is to be "inside the music" instead of sitting on top of it.

The topic is a good one as blending is a skill that requires listening and adapting. Unfortunately this is seldom taught or exercised. The Abersold type play along tracks all presume that the sax is always the lead instrument so sits on top of the music. There needs to be a balance in the way players listen and find ways to enhance rather than always stand out front. That can be in a horn section (as most people here seem to relate to), yet to my mind it's even more important when playing with other instruments as the only sax player. The music comes first. Making that work best should always be the goal.
 
Last edited:
One of the things I learned early on with the clarinet, is properly blending given where in the chord I was located. The 1st clarinet may be playing his written F (Eb concert) just below A (440), 2nd playing say, C below that (mid staff between treble and bass clef). As the 3rd I would be playing low A in the lower end of the chalumeau register. To compensate, the 1st was at say, mF. I would have to play slightly louder at an F, push more air out of the horn to balance out the 1st. The 2nd pushed a touch more air than the 1st but a touch less than the 3rd. Done correctly, we now sound as a section. Otherwise, it sounds like the 1st has the solo with 2nd and 3rd as more of a background. This is on clarinet.

Then there comes maintaining balance with an open chord (spans over an octave) versus a closed chord (within an octave), a bit more challenging.

With the tenor sax and the range within the chord they usually place me, which is an open chord with flutes, oboe and clarinets, compared with the clarinet, it is very easy to overblow the weaker woodwinds. Thus it may be written in the score as a forte, but I must back myself down to my mezzo-forte to blend with the weaker instruments, and so forth.

For me, it is more a feeling that one develops over time, learning the limits, especially when being rebuked by the conductor. 😉

IMO in small combo work especially when dealing with vocalists, an instrumentalist learns the importance of balance. In this case, the vocalist must always clearly cut through. One wants to sound blended with say the trumpet with the upper note in the chord inversion, tenor sax next below him, then the trombone. But all balanced with the singer.

The sax is a very versatile instrument. Blending with the trumpet having the lead and the sax 2nd under him/her, the trumpet tends to come through which IMO sounds closer to 2 trumpets playing, which is good when the band doesn't have a 2nd trumpet.
 
One of the things I learned early on with the clarinet, is properly blending given where in the chord I was located. The 1st clarinet may be playing his written F (Eb concert) just below A (440), 2nd playing say, C below that (mid staff between treble and bass clef). As the 3rd I would be playing low A in the lower end of the chalumeau register. To compensate, the 1st was at say, mF. I would have to play slightly louder at an F, push more air out of the horn to balance out the 1st. The 2nd pushed a touch more air than the 1st but a touch less than the 3rd. Done correctly, we now sound as a section. Otherwise, it sounds like the 1st has the solo with 2nd and 3rd as more of a background. This is on clarinet.
Good stuff - often referred to as voicing a chord, though, problems with words as always in music, we use the term to describe where the notes go in a chord too.
 
often referred to as voicing a chord
I'm not disputing that, but I have never heard it used in that meaning only in regard to, as you say, where the notes are in the chord, e.g. inversions, spacing of the notes etc. Open or closed (close) voicing.
 
I'm not disputing that, but I have never heard it used in that meaning only in regard to, as you say, where the notes are in the chord, e.g. inversions, spacing of the notes etc. Open or closed (close) voicing.
I think Bill Kinghorn used it. I might have mis-remembered. I’m sure I’ve heard other jazz pianists use it in that way. 🤷🏻‍♂️

Best
Jeff
 
Well, my previous reply disappeared. My experience in big bands has been that they vary considerably in the expectation of sax section "blend".

My background is in North Texas (not the school, but the geographic area) where the prevailing "ethic" of big band playing is derived from North Texas State (not the geographic area, but the school) and the One O'Clock Band and the Dallas Typewriter Orchestra; lead alto players play hard, baritone players play hard, jazz tenor players play hard, and the rest of the section plays up to their level.

I was shocked when I moved to New England by how SOFT everyone played, and you couldn't even hear the lead alto player much of the time, everything was all blendy-blendy. I know there was some comment about the way I persisted in punching out baritone hits, or soaring above the section in the appropriate places on lead alto. But it was good commentary. They just hadn't heard a lot of that kind of playing.

The point is that each group will have its own expectation.
 
Well, my previous reply disappeared. My experience in big bands has been that they vary considerably in the expectation of sax section "blend".

My background is in North Texas (not the school, but the geographic area) where the prevailing "ethic" of big band playing is derived from North Texas State (not the geographic area, but the school) and the One O'Clock Band and the Dallas Typewriter Orchestra; lead alto players play hard, baritone players play hard, jazz tenor players play hard, and the rest of the section plays up to their level.

I was shocked when I moved to New England by how SOFT everyone played, and you couldn't even hear the lead alto player much of the time, everything was all blendy-blendy. I know there was some comment about the way I persisted in punching out baritone hits, or soaring above the section in the appropriate places on lead alto. But it was good commentary. They just hadn't heard a lot of that kind of playing.

The point is that each group will have its own expectation.
That’s interesting. I’ve recently played with a couple of bands who made a tiny sound (in my estimation). My mf would drown the whole section. Thing is, if you listen to Miller / Basie, you can tell from the sonority of the tone that they are not playing with any particular restraint. Dynamics of course, and loud is never course or out of control; you can just tell that they are blowing the instruments.
In some cases, if you play in that way, you’re gonna outplay the whole band.

A big band rarely plays as if a lullaby. But, you can change your sound so that it gives the impression of being softer and “cuddly”. Loud can also be round too if wanted. So yes, same experience here, yet most of what I’ve encountered with “1st call players” is pretty big - including trumpet player John Chedoba (Paul Anka at that time) who felt like he was slapping me about the head when he played.
 
I'm not disputing that, but I have never heard it used in that meaning only in regard to, as you say, where the notes are in the chord, e.g. inversions, spacing of the notes etc. Open or closed (close) voicing.

It seems we’ve lost the distinction between blend and balance once more. Furthermore, these comments about where each note sits in the chord neglects the fact that the melody will move through chords. I suggest that a better approach is to listen in the moment as well as know whether one is playing the melody or harmony.
 
It seems we’ve lost the distinction between blend and balance once more.
Yes I agree. Though interesting point about bring out certain notes in chords / movement when there is none / inner lines - not blend though as you say.
 
Back when I was just getting started, something that really turned my head around was being right next to Larry Slezak as he warmed up. Young players, especially those who've come up in school bands constantly being told to play softer, tend to play with a real pinched inhibited sound; whereas real professional players play with a whole lot of verve, dynamics, and exaggerated mannerisms. What feels to the player like you're practically chewing the scenery, comes across to the third row in the auditorium like you're half asleep.

Experiencing the way a real pro plays in the same room was a foundational experience for me.
 
Thing is, if you listen to Miller / Basie, you can tell from the sonority of the tone that they are not playing with any particular restraint. Dynamics of course, and loud is never course or out of control; you can just tell that they are blowing the instruments.
IMO it is the style of music, playing out, written in a manner to be bold, brash. Personally I love it, brings out the best especially when there is that proper blending support of the instruments playing under the lead or above the lead.

Perhaps that is why in the day, they were extremely popular.

I don't know many today who can mimic the perfection done by the "ancient" big band orchestras of Glenn Miller, Artie Shaw, Count Bassie, Tex Beneke, and etc. I still enjoy listening to recordings of these old arrangements.
 
I don't know many today who can mimic the perfection done by the "ancient" big band orchestras of Glenn Miller, Artie Shaw, Count Bassie, Tex Beneke, and etc.
I think you owe it to yourself to check out the WDR Big Band on YouTube. There’s an also group in Texas called the Rebel Jazz Alliance that’s quite good, and the New London Big Band (in Connecticut) has Wayne Bergeron playing lead. They recently resurrected a bunch of previously unknown Thad Jones charts, written for Harry James, that were never recorded.

Further, the 8-bit big band in New York has the cream of the crop of NYC studio players. The Jazz At Lincoln Center Orchestra has a very old-school aesthetic. Talk about blend, those folks really take it to the next level. Steven Feifke doesn’t post too many videos, nor does Christian McBride or John Clayton, but these guys are huge proponents of the big band sound,, and their bands are smokin’ hot.

The music is there to check out if you make the effort. We won’t ever return to the heyday of the 1940’s and ‘50’s, but there are folks seriously dedicated to keeping that sound alive.
 
I think you owe it to yourself to check out the WDR Big Band on YouTube. There’s an also group in Texas called the Rebel Jazz Alliance that’s quite good, and the New London Big Band (in Connecticut) has Wayne Bergeron playing lead. They recently resurrected a bunch of previously unknown Thad Jones charts, written for Harry James, that were never recorded.

Further, the 8-bit big band in New York has the cream of the crop of NYC studio players. The Jazz At Lincoln Center Orchestra has a very old-school aesthetic. Talk about blend, those folks really take it to the next level. Steven Feifke doesn’t post too many videos, nor does Christian McBride or John Clayton, but these guys are huge proponents of the big band sound,, and their bands are smokin’ hot.

The music is there to check out if you make the effort. We won’t ever return to the heyday of the 1940’s and ‘50’s, but there are folks seriously dedicated to keeping that sound alive.
WDR are fabulous. One you didn’t mention is The Pacific Jazz Orchestra. Some nice stuff with Kandace Springs and Ben Wendell.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,362
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom