Introduction Hi from N Ireland

Your right about the nonsense, but I suspect you've not played many different saxes.

Only too true (just the one 🙁)! But I've played a few clarinets, and the advantages I got when I finally moved to a posh model were quite subtle --- smoother and lighter action, didn't seem to break so many springs, nicer pad job, and the fact that they looked the part when you walked into an audition (not to be underestimated, that last one!). I may have made a better sound, but if so I'd say it was mainly because an easier-to-play instrument leaves you freer to concentrate on tone production, not because of any accoustic properties of the instrument itself.

You don't have to be 'great' to able to tell the difference between them. If I lend pupils my sax they don't usually want to give it back.
Bet you sound better on theirs than thay do on yours, though.

Good players can make any old piece of crap sound good. Beginners can't. They're helped greatly by using a good instrument.
Fair enough. I just wanted to suggest looking at alternatives before spending a huge amount of money, when it may be that Kat has a perfectly servicable sax already. I know the tone of my alto has improved dramatically since I first picked it up in June. I hope and expect it will improve some more over the next few months/years.

Burn the heretic! She's got a bari. Why would she want one of them weedy things?>:)
To play some higher notes?
Put those matches away right now! I meant in addition to the bari. For the price of an upgrade to a posh bari, you could probably buy two decent smaller saxes.

Cheers,

Martin
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hi Kat,

Welcome to the Cafe! I think deeop down every sax player wants a Baritone, they are just so bloody expensive and not in great demand for gigs. But whata great sounding instrument. I purchased a Bauhaus Walstein M2 tenor last year which is unbelievably good for the price (better than the Selmer SA80 I had a while ago). I would love to buy a Walstein Bari especially after Pete Thomas's endorsement of it. Just need to be very nice to the wife for awhile, and bide my time!!!
 
Bebop do they................!:shocked:;}

I've never wanted a Baritone sax or a Tuba for that matter. You can get the same effect sticking a trombone mouthpiece onto one of your radiator pipes (after draining it, of course, otherwise you would sound like a whale rinsing its mouth out after tooth brushing).

Seriously, it does seem that the classic order of acquisition is Alto - Tenor - Soprano - Baritone (high, low, higher, lower) but for some its just Tenor - Baritone. So your uniqueness is to be celebrated. I wanted to achieve great things on soprano when I started, but love Alto the most, as you know!

Vive La Difference............!:w00t:;}

Kind regards
Tom😎
 
Only too true (just the one 🙁)! But I've played a few clarinets, and the advantages I got when I finally moved to a posh model were quite subtle --- smoother and lighter action, didn't seem to break so many springs, nicer pad job, and the fact that they looked the part when you walked into an audition (not to be underestimated, that last one!). I may have made a better sound, but if so I'd say it was mainly because an easier-to-play instrument leaves you freer to concentrate on tone production, not because of any accoustic properties of the instrument itself.

Bet you sound better on theirs than thay do on yours, though.

Fair enough. I just wanted to suggest looking at alternatives before spending a huge amount of money, when it may be that Kat has a perfectly servicable sax already. I know the tone of my alto has improved dramatically since I first picked it up in June. I hope and expect it will improve some more over the next few months/years.

To play some higher notes?
Put those matches away right now! I meant in addition to the bari. For the price of an upgrade to a posh bari, you could probably buy two decent smaller saxes.

Cheers,

Martin

I.M.H.O All very valid and helpful points, I own quite a few saxes the best being a yas 62 but I tend to practice mainly on my lowly elkhart I've always tended to think that if the tones not too great it's probably down to the player not the played and why risk scratching dropping denting and generally damaging a quality instrument just practicing.The other thing is,if I can make the elkhart sound good how great will the 62 sound...john
 
Thanks for all the suggestions guys 😱)

I already have an alto but it has been stolen by my daughter as of 3 weeks ago, don't think I'll ever see it again 🙂 The bari that I have is OK-ish, still sounds like an oboe about G even with a Vandoren Jazz mouthpiece on it, although at least it holds in tune with that on it! With the moulded thing that came with it, it is nearly a semi-tone out of tune from bottom to top, that's way beyond what I can adjust for with embouchure!!

Biggest problem I have is I literally *can't* reach Bb. I have to take my hand off completely and swing through nearly a 1/4 turn to reach the bottom of the cluster. Had a gig last night and eventually gave up on the Bb's and either skipped them or went up an octave depending on what was happening.

The top register isn't really a problem 'cause I very rarely play up that high, apart from a nice solo in Nimrod but at least it's all up there so there isn't a change in tone half-way through! Looks like the Yamaha will be a good place to start for ergonomics, and in the grand scheme of Baris it's not that *hugely* expensive. Yani and Keilworth look really pretty but I'm not a good enough player to justify that sort of money really. I only play in rehearsals once a week and gig about once a month or so, and then there's very few solos.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,566
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom