Playing the saxophone Help with the next step please.

It's unfortunate that Big martin thinks I hate Jazz from the 1950s/60s. I grew up on it and loved it. I still enjoy the music. The question is about teaching and what one learns. One hopes that an individual wishing to learn an instrument has a notion of what they would like to play. For some reason in sax circles there is a culture of teaching the style of playing and the tunes of the 1950s/60s. There is no demand for this type of playing today so it's kind of a "tribute band" mentality where the student is encouraged to "ape" the style via an academic approach. Never mind that the people at that time were trying to play in a new style and weren't playing in the style of players form 60 years previously. Music and the arts move ahead. If you simply love that style, and have no desire to express yourself in any other way, then "go for it". There is however a whole world of music that has happened since then and is happening now. You can be a part of that and play something that is alive , fresh and communicates to people of today.

Without going to too much of a diatribe the problem with imitating the style of 60/70 years ago is that the basis for much of the playing is to use show tunes from that time or before. These are songs that few people today know. In the 1950s everybody knew these tunes, so when playing a variation in "the jazz style" everybody understood your clever twists and turns on that melody. It was fresh. The style, inflections and use of riffs and arpeggios were picked up by academics and to some degree codified. What was spontaneous improvisation then can now be taught... but it's not the same. What's being taught today is unfortunately very much removed from that idea of spontaneous improvisation. Teaching technique has meant that the heart and soul of what was happening back then is gone. It's become a race of who can play the fastest and string together well practiced (finger memory) riffs and arpeggios that fit the chord structure. It's not much fun for an audience to hear players trying to outdo each other in technique with the only intent being to impress. Music back then, and now, is about having something to communicate to an audience. That's been lost in the academic translation.

Having fun and a goal can be good, and the sax culture of playing "standards" in the style of 60+ years ago, can provide that goal and satisfaction in achieving higher levels of technical playing. It is however a clique that has no audience and in most ways more similar to working out in a gym where you're developing muscles and comparing yours to others. Outside of the gym nobody cares.
So to cut along story short what are you implying should be done or should be played. By taking for example the Melodic cord approach. I can nuddle to my hearts content but unless it’s recognised whose going to listen.
 
It's a question of intent. Many are happy to just be playing anything that fits. Being able to do this at speed can (for some) be impressive. That's a practice rooted in an academic approach to "playing the changes" or following the chord structure and using any number of riffs and arpeggios that one can apply in a "cut and paste" manner. This can be heard at any open mike jazz night and most often resembles a "fastest gun in the west" competition. It's technical playing that has the intent of impressing. It does take skill and a lot of practice.

Unfortunately it doesn't do much for the public who avoid this style of music. The reasons are simple, it's not giving the audience entertainment, it's a technical ego match, about as entertaining as watching guys in a gym trying to outdo each other in lifting weights. It's also almost exclusively heard in playing "standards". Tunes mostly from the 1950's and earlier. The original intent was to be playing tunes that everybody knew so that your clever variations on those would be recognizable. Few of the public know those tunes now, so that reference point is lost.

Improvisation can be used in many different genres of music besides playing standards. In most of those situations you need to be part of the music and enhancing the mood, story, adding harmony, counterpoint, or a number of other musical attributes, and often supplying the melody. That isn't taught or practiced in the academic method associated with playing "standards". There are few teachers who can encourage this type of improvisation. It comes from within the player who hears a line in the way one would sing. Can you sing a melody? Can you sing a harmony line? Counterpoint, rhythmic and patterns? If yes, then you have the mental/musical facility to be an entertainer and play any type of music you wish.

The steps to take if you have those abilities are big ones. Make your instrument your voice. This means years of attempting to play what you would sing until the instrument becomes your voice. All of the great players had this ability. They played what they heard in their mind...it's their distinct voice. The second step is to become a great listener. There are two aspect to this: 1. develop a great mental musical library that gives you inspiration with many different things you could play. 2. You need to be able to clearly hear what's happening in the music so that you can fit as backing, harmony, soloist, etc.

The choice of which path you take is yours. Knowing yourself and your abilities/talent, as well as what you wish to play should make the choice easiest.

A basic question for yourself is whether you wish to play for your own amusement or to entertain others. Your statement "unless it’s recognized who is going to listen" is kind of right, but it doesn't need to be a tune that's known to the listener, it just has to have something to say and give the listener. Back full circle...It's a question of intent.
 
Last edited:
I did do a big answer, but then moved it to its own thread as it kind went off on one a bit.

But very relevant to the way this discussion has gone I think.

 
Last edited:
Thanks all. I was feeling a little lost and also wondering if my question had a direction. To find its generated such a response is an answer to the title.

Having read through the post a couple of times I still need to digest it.

In relation to machine gun note playing. my first saxophone teacher always said “ It’s not the amount of notes you play it’s how they sound and pull the melody in”
 
Thanks all. I was feeling a little lost and also wondering if my question had a direction.
I think it's a great question, perhaps some of answers do take it in different direction but it's all good. As you are asking what should be your next step, then you are bound to get a lot of different answers, we all have different ideas. There is no one right answer to that question.

One thing I noticed about your first post was "Having completed my scales with a past teacher" and I wondered what that meant. Obviously it doesn't mean having mastered every scale known to man, but I am still curious as to what it does mean.

my first saxophone teacher always said “ It’s not the amount of notes you play it’s how they sound and pull the melody in”
That’s the way I like to think, however it is absolutely subjective. There are many people who appreciate loads of notes or very fast playing. For example the John Coltrane style of sheets of sound

Nothing wrong with it or aspiring to play many fast notes at all. Just not my cup of tea (any more), nor by the sound of it you're teachers.

What I mean is I don't think of it as an argument, it's down to personal preference.
 
At these crossroad moments the most important thing is to keep playing imo.

A path will often reveal itself as part of the journey.

The journey has no terminus, destination or road map. Enjoy the ride.

However, when following a meandering river, watch out for the oxbow lakes. They sometimes have alligators in them. 😉
 
Thanks Pete, I whole heartedly agree, we all have or ideas and opinions. Life would be pretty boring otherwise.

With regards to my reference on scales. It pointed to the standard Major and minor foundation taught in the beginning’s of our pathway. usually very much influenced by Classically teachers, the area I live it feels every teacher appears to have there roots from Classical. The last teacher I tried, confessed to learning Jazz scales because she wished to teach having come from a classical training. I’m not sure if you recall but. I was a member of this forum from its early beginnings and took my lead from your Books and DVD often working with my saxophone teacher, a very accomplished Session Saxophonist who also played with the Shirley Bassey Band, to guide me if I miss-interpreted any of your lessons. Sadly he passed away several years ago.

I was attempting to put it out there. I need something further on than a beginner. putting aside practicing long notes, that I do from top to bottom using the tuner as reference and playing lots of ballad and nuddeling with the melodic scales. At 62 I’m never going to be a professional but would like to up my game but how and where should my focus be.

Rambling over. Great site and very pleased to see it still here.
 
At these crossroad moments the most important thing is to keep playing imo.

A path will often reveal itself as part of the journey.

The journey has no terminus, destination or road map. Enjoy the ride.

However, when following a meandering river, watch out for the oxbow lakes. They sometimes have alligators in them. 😉
Thanks Colin, it’s an age thing. guess Im looking to get to the traffic light before it turns back to Red
 
Thanks Colin, it’s an age thing. guess Im looking to get to the traffic light before it turns back to Red
The Chinese have a saying about a journey requiring the first step. Time is a relative factor. I'm 75 and (dare I say it?) I'm a better player now than at 62, and I'm still getting better! Age is just a number. Some run into physical difficulties at a young age. Others seem to not have any problems and may keep going for quite a while. Fear of "the light turning red" doesn't stop you from driving. There is nothing to fear and everything to gain in embracing anything in life gives you a feeling of reward and accomplishment. It's a journey that doesn't necessarily have a destination and can be enjoyed all along the way with the right attitude.
 
If you are prepared to travel an hour or maybe consider online lessons "Saxophone Lessons and tuition in Manchester, Cheshire, Lancashire and UK - Alison Diamond" Saxophone Lessons and tuition in Manchester, Cheshire, Lancashire and UK - Alison Diamond
I've not had lessons with Alison but know people that have and were pleased.

Jx
Thanks Jeanette, I will have a look at website and consider online lessons. I do prefer 1to1 but it’s now looking this maybe my best option.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,702
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom