It's unfortunate that Big martin thinks I hate Jazz from the 1950s/60s. I grew up on it and loved it. I still enjoy the music. The question is about teaching and what one learns. One hopes that an individual wishing to learn an instrument has a notion of what they would like to play. For some reason in sax circles there is a culture of teaching the style of playing and the tunes of the 1950s/60s. There is no demand for this type of playing today so it's kind of a "tribute band" mentality where the student is encouraged to "ape" the style via an academic approach. Never mind that the people at that time were trying to play in a new style and weren't playing in the style of players form 60 years previously. Music and the arts move ahead. If you simply love that style, and have no desire to express yourself in any other way, then "go for it". There is however a whole world of music that has happened since then and is happening now. You can be a part of that and play something that is alive , fresh and communicates to people of today.
Without going to too much of a diatribe the problem with imitating the style of 60/70 years ago is that the basis for much of the playing is to use show tunes from that time or before. These are songs that few people today know. In the 1950s everybody knew these tunes, so when playing a variation in "the jazz style" everybody understood your clever twists and turns on that melody. It was fresh. The style, inflections and use of riffs and arpeggios were picked up by academics and to some degree codified. What was spontaneous improvisation then can now be taught... but it's not the same. What's being taught today is unfortunately very much removed from that idea of spontaneous improvisation. Teaching technique has meant that the heart and soul of what was happening back then is gone. It's become a race of who can play the fastest and string together well practiced (finger memory) riffs and arpeggios that fit the chord structure. It's not much fun for an audience to hear players trying to outdo each other in technique with the only intent being to impress. Music back then, and now, is about having something to communicate to an audience. That's been lost in the academic translation.
Having fun and a goal can be good, and the sax culture of playing "standards" in the style of 60+ years ago, can provide that goal and satisfaction in achieving higher levels of technical playing. It is however a clique that has no audience and in most ways more similar to working out in a gym where you're developing muscles and comparing yours to others. Outside of the gym nobody cares.