help - Solo on Billy Joel's 'Still Rock and Roll'

mark_whiteley

Member
Messages
46
Hi

One of the bands I help out at our local jam nights is trying to put together 'Still Rock & Roll' by Billy Joel which has an amezing, but short sax solo, sounds like it's on alto, but I'd have to do it on tenor. I intend to listen to the record and write it out on ledger lines, but does anyone know where I could find the solo in sheet music format I could purchase? I think the concert key for the song is C Maj so obviously D Maj for the tenor.
 
There's a chart of this on sheetmusicdigital.com - they only let you see the first page - guitar/piano/vocal - so I'm not sure if the sax solo is on the chart - however, for $4.50 (US) you at least get the chord changes and you can trascribe/print it.

Here's the link http://tinyurl.com/5rhzze

what a great solo - it will be superb on the tenor... 🙂
 
Thanks Luluna. I took a look - great website. It's not clear whether I would get the solo if I purchase the sheet, but I might take a chance on it. Claerly it's written in the same key as the record, ie C major for guitar & piano.
 
Hi

purchased the Sax solo for $1 very good value ! on the www.saxsolos.com website. The guy there Curtis, responds to e mails very fast and I got the music within the day.

Problem is, this solo is in the high octave on the Tenor and there's no way I can go straight to High F and F# yet, so have transposed it to the middle range octave ! Won't sound as good of course but will try it out with the band. As the singer is always transposing down a few keys because he can#t sing in concert A or D and has to sing almost everything in G or C I can't see he'll complain !!

thanks for contributions on this. Mark
 
Hi

purchased the Sax solo for $1 very good value ! on the www.saxsolos.com website. The guy there Curtis, responds to e mails very fast and I got the music within the day.

Problem is, this solo is in the high octave on the Tenor and there's no way I can go straight to High F and F# yet, so have transposed it to the middle range octave ! Won't sound as good of course but will try it out with the band. As the singer is always transposing down a few keys because he can#t sing in concert A or D and has to sing almost everything in G or C I can't see he'll complain !!

thanks for contributions on this. Mark
 
Thanks for everyone for contributions on this.

My tutor says he would 'never play anyone else's solo' and why would I want to play a solo that wasn't an improvisation?. I can see his point but said that when the audience hears the song and as the Sax solo approcahes, in their minds they are expecting that particular format of solo, with specific notes. He just didn't get it.

Anyway, I'm pressing on with practising the original solo, albeit in the middle octave.
 
Trevor,

I can understand why your tutor would want you to improvise your solos - but I think you have to consider:

1 - what type of chart are you performing
2 - who is your audience
3 - is it appropriate to improvise

If you are covering a famous pop tune - you are right in anticipating that the audience will be expecting to hear a highly recognizable solo. If you really become comfortable with the original solo - it won't hurt to throw in a few "licks" of your own.

I have an upcoming concert where I solo for "In the Mood". I have heart many different versions of the tenor sax solo of this classic piece. However, the director wanted the solo "as written" note for note as performed on a Youtube link I have on my blog. I convinced him last rehearsal to allow me to do a blend - partly as written, and partly improvisation.

Do what feels right to you - I'm sure it will be fantastic.

kind regards and best wishes for a superb solo!
8)
 
[Good advice, thanks, yes I suppose a mix of the original and some improv would be best, will try to develop it that way. We had the Jam night last night, and did an interesting experiment, substituting the horn and piano intros on Handbags & Gladrags with Tenor Sax ! Worked quite well ! As the Rod Stewart version was A Maj the tenor's in B and works very well as a replacement, we also had acoustic guitar, bass, and congas.

First time that I managed all the notes in 'It's still Rock & Roll' in the right order! But the solo's so fast that there isn't time to read it and play, so it has to practsied to death off the music.

Cheers Mark
 
Think if you're playing on a tune with a well recognized solo, stick to the original, I'm not sure if the original solo in Still Rock 'n' Roll wasn't from Mark Rivera, but both him and Richie Cannatta seem to play it the same both recorded and live.
Look at it another way, check out how Mark Rivera plays the solo on Urgent, compared to the Junior W. version it really doesn't make it at all.
There are some songs where you simply can't top the original and it seems to me in such cases there's not much point in trying. Sometimes even covering the original is more than enough challenge.
gruss - tone
 
Going it try it agaim tonight at the Jam night. We're trying to do a range of different types of Sax input eg. on Handbags & Gladrags the Sax is replacing the piano and horns on the record, but sticking faithfully to the descending tune.

We're going to put sax into James Taylor's 'How Sweet It Is' as a fairly free form solo, not sure if it's blues based yet, but the song is quite interesting as it's the 3 chord triad in reverse ie the verse goes C to D to G, but I think the concert key is G so the solo for tenor will be in A maj or A blues, should be fun.

I'm fortunate in having friends who are involved in several different band line ups who are prepared to let me join in on a sessional basis to try things out. It's amazing how much confidence you can gain from doing some pretty basic sax in the pub on a jam night. I would recommend it to anyone who has covered a few months of training. I just started with 3 notes doing 'love is the drug' and moved up from there. This is all fine for those who wnat to do pop & rock but of course other beginners will have more jazz based ambitions or maybe even to join an orchestra.

I've tried some classical exercises from the Otto practise book, and boy are they difficult, particularly the timing aspects of playing the pieces. But I think they are superb exercises.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,069
Messages
578,509
Members
8,131
Latest member
Jef B
Back
Top Bottom