Introduction Hello from the Toon!

Swllwmzn

New Member
Messages
2
Location
North East
Hello, I’m a latecomer to sax, started about 6 years ago going to adult groups at local music centre. Currently playing in a friendly Monday afternoon group where all except me and the music director are retired!

Have a Yamaha student model alto which is fine for my level of playing but considering a mouthpiece upgrade, just not sure what. I’ve tried a Selmer C*, didn’t get on with it at all.

I’ve played sop in the past and really want to start again - just for fun, not looking to spend a lot.
 
Welcome to the Café.

We can all recommend our favourite mouthpiece, but unfortunately all the recommendations will be different. What suits me may not suit you. So the only way to find a mouthpiece that suits you is to try some. I’m not sure what shops are near you (Northeast England I presume).
 
Hi from south of the Tyne in Durham. Yeah, lots of playing up and around the NE but sadly no sax focused retailers. If you know what you might like to try Dawkes offer at-home 14-day trials and returns for the cost of restocking. Steph at Durham music shop in Langely Moor might be able to source some for you to try. I don't think Windows has a great choice. Happy honkin'
 
Welcome to the cafe! Great to hear that you're playing in a group.

After 6 years, I can well understand that you're thinking of upgrading your mpc! I started out (as a tenor beginner) with a Selmer C* and within about a year, I upgraded to a Selmer D. From there, I upgraded a year or 2 later to an Otto Link and since then to 2 other mpc's.

I don't know much about mpc's (others do!) but some points that have helped me in 'upgrading' from time to time are:
  • start off by thinking about how your current mpc + reed combo might be limiting your playing, for example: ease of playing? tone quality?, volume?, the feeling of playing (freely) with an 'open' mpc vs struggling to get more air into a 'closed' mpc. In other words why exactly do you feel the need to 'upgrade'?
  • then imagine how a 'better' mpc might be easier to play, have a different sound quality, allow you to play more flexibly w.r.t. volume, etc.
  • then try out a couple of mpc's with a similar or slightly larger tip openings than you have now and pick one that seems to be the best personal 'fit' w.r.t. 'playability' and sound quality.

IHMO, it's well worth travelling to a sax shop that has a good selection of mpc's and trying out and comparing maybe 5-6 different mpc's with the advice of the staff. This seems much easier to me than trying out and returning one mpc at a time from home. If you like one or 2 mpc's in the shop, you can still ask for a home trial of a couple of weeks.

This Jody Jazz comparison chart has been shared many times on the cafe. It gives an impression of what other mpc's from the same or different brands are in the same 'ball park' as the mpc you use now.

FWIW, I once did an independent 'mpc test'. I'm not suggesting you travel to NL for a similar test 🙂 but the website's key message is that a mouthpiece should ideally match an individual sax player. So while Brand A, model M, tip opening X might be ideally suited to one player, it may unsuitable for someone else. I went to my 'test' with two main requirements:
  • I wanted a mpc that played more freely (and into which I could get more air) than my current mpc
  • I wanted a mpc that had a bit more 'edge' (brighter tones) than my current mpc.

I did a couple of tests of things like my lung capacity, airstream (loud/soft), embouchure strength, etc. The 'tester' suggested 5-8 mpc's to try out. Mostly well-known brands and a couple of lesser-known brands. I found that an obscure German brand was ideal for me. The independent tester didn't sell anything other than his time and expertise. So I ordered my 'ideal mpc' directly from the manufacturer. That was perhaps 10 years ago and I still play the mpc to this day. Later, I also ordered a PPT mpc (with right of return) from Taming the Saxophone. This is absolutely my favourite mpc but it's one (with a wider tip opening) that I need regular practice to play well on. When I get lazy on my practice schedule, I fall back on my 'obscure german brand mpc'.

In general, I would advise that you choose a mpc that is easy to play, has the right sound, etc. and might require bit more practice to learn to play it well over longer periods but is not so 'challenging' that your embouchure is exhausted afer 30 minutes.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,434
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom