Mouthpieces Heading to the dark side

Thanks for those recent replies, a consistent line of thought is now emerging! I think I tend towards the free blowing as all my proper woodwind training was on flute, and I later did a dodgy self conversion job to saxophone. I've got a Morgan 3C which I thought would be the one, but surprisingly the Vintage seems to do the job a bit better. I also have a Yanagisawa HR 4 which is nicely free blowing, but gets a bit bright for me when pushing a bit harder. I'm coming to the conclusion that the adjustment I need is probably more personal than going and buying new stuff!

My Morgan C started as a 3, but divine intervened in the form of a saltillo tile floor - the only time in 50+ years of playing that I have dropped a mouthpiece. That 3C was refaced by Ed Zentera to 0.090" before Morgan started making a 6C, and it was life-changing for me. I later learned that James Houlik also preferred a similar tip opening. Bottom line: You are only a reface away from having a more free-blowing mouthpiece with dark(er) character. The baffle could also be adjusted if you want it even darker.
 
About every feature in a mouthpiece, that makes it brighter (larger baffle, smaller chamber, rings etc.) will tend to lower the feeling of resistance and increase responsiveness.

That all can be balanced by tip opening and facing curve. Without going into details, it is not by chance that large chambers used to be paired with small tips and vice versa. (A good mouthpiece maker can balance other factors in that equation and make other combinations feel right as well.)

So in general, a darker piece will need more air support and feel more resistant. You can balance this also by choosing a smaller tip opening or using a softer reed.

For myself, I increasingly avoid so called free blowing mouthpieces. The make playing at home very easy, like breathing. To the point where your air support gets lazy. But if you are in a loud acoustic environment, like a loud big band, it feels like you hit the bottom of the car with the first touch of the pedal. They start off to easy and then there is no reserve, no matter how hard you push.

When it comes to “healthy” resistance and plenty reserve, Phil-Tone pieces are also my number one choice.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,619
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom