Intonation Has anyone ever tuned and played a sax a 1/2 step low?

6441

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,846
Stevie Ray Vaughan tuned his guitar down a half-step to Eb to enable easier bending. As I was putting the mouthpiece on today, I put it on less cork and got it down almost a half step. Like the guitar, bends are easier, but of course by the same token, pitch is less stable. Still, there are crazy sax players out there. Has anyone heard of anyone doing this?
 
I've done this a number of times, but the intonation goes out as well from top to bottom. It's usually not a full half tone, but when playing with "native instruments" they are seldom tuned to 440 so you've got to make compromises. There are also many "different" tunings outside of our Western convention of the "tempered Scale".
 
I think a High Pitch sax is playing a quarter step up compared to a Low Pitch sax? So a concert Eb is F on a LP Bb tenor. Is it possible to adjust the tone on a HP tenor with mouthpiece (length, chamber design .... ) and reed ... to F# ????
 
From what I have read before, this would result in a sax that plays out of tune. You can tune the reference note to a certain pitch. But the rest of the notes would not be as they should be.
this explains it (look for the explanation of @jbtsax )
Or this article:
 
I have never heard of tuning a whole half step below.
I have heard of the opposite though: tuning slightly higher than fully in tune and 'lipping' down. But the reason advanced to do so was about tone (apparently some people found it made for a better one).
I don't know any of this from experience, just passing the hot potato (could just be rumors as well).
 
Without a similar adjustment to all of the toneholes pulling the mouthpiece out far enough to increase the "sounding length" of the instrument is going to create a host of intonation problems. Some folks have tried to play ""low pitch" saxes along with other instruments tuned to A=440 by pushing the mouthpiece farther onto the neck and have found this to be the case.

On stringed instruments the tuning of the open strings can be raised or lowered (within reason) and the placement of the frets, if any, still allows the intonation to be acceptable.
 
I understand the science. I think it would only work in completely non-tempered context where you might want that sound on purpose. (For what reason, I wouldn't know.)
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,061
Messages
578,385
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom