Theory & Impro Half diminished chords - minor 7 flat five (m7b5)

paulhughes

Member
Messages
36
Location
Essex England
Sorry if this is a dumb question, but I have been looking at a transcription of Art Pepper's Autumn Leaves and see there is a B half-diminished chord, notated without a '7':
'Bø', seemingly a half-diminished triad. Would I be right in thinking this is just a shorthand version of 'Bø7'. I have looked at the Jazz symbols chart on this site and there is no 'Bø' chord symbol, only a Bø7 (in fact to be accurate a 'Cø7').

Thanks
 
Solution
It has to be half diminished 7 (aka minor7 b5) as there isn't really such a thing as a half diminished triad. If it's a triad then it's a diminished triad not half diminished which needs a 7th to define it as such.

Someone more pedantic than me (if there is such a person) might try to argue otherwise.

e.g. it's a triad, but if it did have a 7th, it would be a minor 7 not a dimished 7.

That is almost a bit of a zen concept though.

It's kind of lazy shorthand, like in the Omnibook you see B- E7 A and I'm pretty sure that B- is a Bm7 not a Bm triad.

So we can assume that yes Bø is the same chord as Bø7 and is B D F A
...
He actually plays an f sharp here and also 8 bars later, when it next comes around.
Naughty man.....playing “ wrong” notes.
...

It makes the bass player's "correct" F (Ab concert) sound a bit wrong though.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Vote:
Upvote 0
The band teacher I student taught with had a small dance combo he played trumpet in on weekends. He also had a keen sense of humor. He often talked about how bad the bass player in the group played. He came in one Monday and said he played a gig over the weekend but the bass player didn't show up. I asked, "What did you do". He said "We just kicked the piano on every beat, and no one could tell the difference". 🙂
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
A man gives his son an electric bass for his 15th birthday, along with a coupon for four bass lessons. When the son returns from his first lesson, the father asks, So, what did you learn?
Well, I learned the first five notes on the E string.
Next week, after the second lesson, the father again asks about the progress, and the son replies, this time I learned the first five notes on the A string.
One week later, the son comes home far later than expected, smelling of cigarettes and beer. So the father asks, hey, what happened in today's lesson?
.
.
Dad, I'm sorry but I couldn't make it to my lesson. I had a gig!
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I have looked at the Jazz symbols chart on this site and there is no 'Bø' chord symbol, only a Bø7 (in fact to be accurate a 'Cø7').
I tend to show a lot of examples in C or with C root. Perhaps I should show the Cø as well Cø7 seeing as people do use it to mean minor 7b5, albeit lazily.

EDIT: have now added that symbol:

 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0
I tend to show a lot of examples in C or with C root. Perhaps I should show the Cø as well Cø7 seeing as people do use it to mean minor 7b5, albeit lazily.

EDIT: have now added that symbol:


I really like that chart and find it very useful. A couple of thoughts on it:
  • The last column has "C-" on the row for C minor major 7. Isn't that just C minor ?
  • It could be helpful to have an additional column that spells out the notes for each chord (e.g. 1 b3 b5 b7) to allow people to make each chord type for every possible root note.
  • It could be worth having a comment about slash chords
Rhys
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,074
Messages
578,635
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom